Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Bacteriology, July 2002, p. 3801-3807, Vol. 184, No. 14
0021-9193/02/$04.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JB.184.14.3801-3807.2002
Copyright © 2002, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Laboratoire de Microbiologie et de Génétique Moléculaires, CNRS, 31062 Toulouse Cedex, France
Received 1 March 2002/ Accepted 15 April 2002
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Failure of CDR gives rise to several phenotypes, including an increase of 50- to 100-fold in recombination in the terminus region (11, 12, 25, 26). This terminal recombination reflects the extreme fragility of the dif region after inhibition of CDR, presumably a result of engulfment of the localized dif region by the closing septum. The recombination-stimulating events are, or culminate in, double-strand breaks, since terminal recombination is largely RecBCD dependent. Consistent with this scenario, trapping by septum of DNA joining sister nucleoids and DNA degradation near dif have been detected in CDR- mutants (18, 24, 30).
Genetic studies of the DAZ have revealed the role played by the polarity of the regions that flank dif in generating this domain. First, the "natural" orientation of ca. 30 kb on either side of dif must be maintained for dif to be active: inversions in these regions can be deleterious (29). Second, the presence near dif of the prophage
in a certain orientation (which inverts on either sides of the site) inhibits the resolution process (12). The dif site maps in the region where the polarity of replichores generated by certain skewed oligonucleotides changes sign (8, 12). The skew of RGNAGGGS (or Rag) motifs is especially spectacular: these motifs are skewed everywhere on the chromosome (Table 1), but their skew is accentuated near dif since, along 360 kb to the left and 280 kb to the right of the site, 97% of these sequences are located on strands running 5' to 3' from oriC to dif (Table 1 and Fig. 1). Although there is no evidence that Rags are the determinants underlying the polarity phenomena described here, we assign them this role on a provisional basis on the grounds that they are the most promising candidates. Two arguments support this proposal: (i) the region of prophage
responsible for the CDR inhibition effect harbors Rags skewed in a 10:1 proportion (J. Corre, unpublished results), and (ii) the regions flanking dif on the Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi or serovar Typhimurium chromosomes have only little similarity with the Escherichia coli corresponding regions, although they display the same skew of Rag motifs as in E. coli (www.sanger.ac.uk).
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Distribution of Rag motifs in different chromosome regionsa
|
![]() View larger version (28K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Distribution of Rag and Chi elements near dif and in TSK. The horizontal lines represent 400 kb of the TER region centered on dif. The positions of replication terminators TerC and TerB are indicated. Vertical lines indicate the positions and orientations of Rag (5'-RGNAGGGS-3') and Chi elements (5'-GCTGGTGG-3'), based on the published sequence of E. coli (7). Chi stimulates RecBCD recombinase activity when the complex arrives at GCTGGTGG from the 3' end (33).
|
Consequently, we have further examined the role of FtsK as a motor that drives the DNA movements needed for CDR by measuring the effect of an ftsK mutation on terminal recombination. If an ftsK mutation inhibits only Xer recombination while allowing normal dif positioning, recombinogenic lesions will occur near dif only, so that terminal recombination in this ftsK mutant will be indistinguishable from terminal recombination in a xerC mutant. If, on the other hand, FtsK is needed for positioning of dif prior to Xer recombination, the closing septum will trap DNA from a much wider region of the mutant chromosome, thus modifying the gradient of terminal recombination as a function of chromosomal position. The comparison of terminal recombination in an ftsK mutant with that in an xerC mutant indicates that two positioning processes, one FtsK dependent and one FtsK independent, cooperate to localize dif under the septum. Furthermore, because our assay can provoke interference with local polarity, these results provide evidence that FtsK acts in a polarity-sensitive process.
|
|
|---|
TSK prophage, is in iso-orientation when its own skew merges with the ambient skew and in antiorientation in the opposite situation. This is illustrated Fig. 1.
Bacterial strains, bacteriophages, and genetic procedures.
All strains analyzed for terminal recombination derive from CB0129 (W1485 F- leu thyA thi deoB or deoC supD [4]) and harbor tet (tetracycline resistance [Tcr]) or Tn10 insertions previously described (11, 12, 25). The ftsK1::cat (chloramphenicol resistance) is described elsewhere (14). The xerC2::Apr (ampicillin resistance) allele was described by Louarn et al. (26). The
(recB recC)::Apr mutation was as described previously (11). These mutations were transferred by P1 transduction by standard protocols (27). Bacteriophage
TSK is described by Corre et al. (12). Cultures were routinely made in Luria-Bertani (LB) medium (27).
Prophage excision assay.
Our routine test for indigenous recombination is a prophage excision assay (12, 25). It is performed on strains made lysogens for a phage
derivative (
TSK) that is proficient for lyzogenization but carries tet sequences coming from Tn10 transposon in place of the att int region (Fig. 2). This prophage can integrate by homologous recombination into a chromosome that carries a resident Tn10 or tet sequence and then becomes flanked by direct repeats. Since the phage repressor is thermosensitive, bacteria cured of the prophage can be scored easily as CFU at 42°C. Curing results preferentially from excisive homologous recombination between the flanking repeats. Routinely, frequencies of cured bacteria were determined as follows: eight 24-h-old individual colonies grown on LB agar medium at 30°C were each resuspended in 0.5 ml of LB broth and grown overnight at 30°C. These clones were then mixed as two groups of four clones; each group was plated on LB agar (containing 8 x 10-3 M sodium citrate to avoid
reinfection when the strains were
sensitive) and then incubated at 30 or 42°C. Replicate determinations displayed significant variability, as expected from the stochastic nature of the excision event, but in general this did not exceed ±20% of the reported average value. When CDR is inhibited by an ftsK mutation, the difference in selective values of the lysogen versus the nonlysogen parent is minor and can be neglected: growth competition experiments have indicated that there is no, or only limited, selective advantage for lysogens versus nonlysogens after 25 generations or after a 5-day incubation in stationary phase (data not shown). Since bacterial curing frequencies are measured after the same number of generations (ca. 30) for all strains, the variations observed are solely imputable to variations in excision frequencies per cell generation.
![]() View larger version (21K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Prophage excision assay. (A) System for monitoring indigenous recombination. Phage TSK carries a 2.8-kb tetAR (Tcr) fragment from Tn10 interrupted within tetA by two insertions providing kanamycin resistance (Knr) and streptomycin-spectinomycin resistance (Smr). It can recombine with a resident tetAR sequence and inactivate the Tcr character to form a Tcs lysogen. Owing to the cI857 mutation, the prophage is repressed only at a low temperature (30°C). It is induced and kills its host at 42°C. (B) Prophage loss after excisive recombination between the flanking repeats restores the ability to form colonies at 42°C, so that the number of temperature-resistant bacteria present in a clone derived from a single lysogen is a measure of prophage excision frequency when lysogens and nonlysogens display the same generation time, which is the case in CDR- mutants.
|
|
|
|---|
prophage of our assay induces uneven distribution of the terminus DNA between sister cells (Fig. 3B). This facilitates homology searching, thus helping cells to recover viability.
![]() View larger version (46K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Model for prophage excision and recovery of circular chromosome monomers from a dimer in a xerC mutant. (A) The strain harbors an iso-oriented prophage in the terminus region, with no associated perturbation of the positioning of dif sites at division. Trapping by the septum immobilizes the dif regions and leads to generation of double-strand ends. The absence of overlap leaves no possibility for recombination to yield a circular monomer in either of the daughter cells. Both cells are doomed. (B) A pseudo-DAZ generated at the junction of an antioriented prophage and the chromosome can result in septal trapping of DNA distant from dif, whereas the positioning of the second thread is correct. The resulting overlap of terminus sequences can be used to generate a prophage-cured circular monomer by homologous recombination between the indicated Tes and Tek elements in the cell to the left, while the cell to the right is doomed. (C) When the prophage maps at or near dif, positioning operates to place prophage DNA under the septum. In the example depicted (chosen for simplicity), breakage in the trapped zone results in simultaneous prophage excision and chromosome repair, provided the RecBCD enzyme, responsible for the repair, encounters the stimulating Chi site present in the tet sequence. Both cells can recover a viable monomer chromosome.
|
![]() View larger version (21K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Frequency of prophage loss from various positions in the TER region of the ftsK1::cat mutant. The frequency of cured bacteria is plotted against the position of the tetAR integration locus. Symbols: , prophages in antiorientation; , prophages in iso-orientation. Curve II, based on the present data obtained in the ftsK1 mutant, takes into account both orientations. The other curves are extracted from previously published work (12): curve I, xerC2 mutant, prophage iso-oriented; curve III, xerC2 mutant, prophage antioriented. The positions of relevant loci (dif, TerC, TerB) are indicated. The extent of the DAZ, the zone in which dif gains progressively resolution activity as it is moved toward its natural site (29), is shown by a graded bar. The positions tested (the distances in kilobases from dif are in parentheses, negative to the left and positive to the right): 1, zda192 (-151); 2, trg (-100); 3, zdc310 (-35.3); 4, zdc330 (-15.8); 5, (zdc330-zdc338) (-15.8/-7.0); 6, zdc338 (-7.0); 7, (zdc338-hipA) (-7.0/+1); 8, hipA (+1); 9, zdd355 (+8.9); 10, zdd365 (+17.8); 11, zdd370 (+23.2); 12, zde381 (+34); 13, zde395 (+48); 14, zde406 (+58); 15, zdf237 (+100); and 16, zdh57 (+180). Both prophage orientations were assayed at positions 1, 3, 4, 6, 8, 9, and 11. Curing frequencies of prophages inserted at positions external to the terminus, lacZ (6 min), and tna (82 min) are also indicated. They were as low in the FtsK- background, 1.5 x 10-4 and 3.5 x 10-4, respectively, as in wild-type bacteria at the same positions (25).
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Genetic controls on terminal recombination at two positions
|
Alteration of the same process triggers terminal recombination in ftsK and in xerC mutants, and repair requires RecBC. Fragility due to inactivation of FtsK and that due to absence of XerC should be related, since both factors are needed for CDR. To examine this prediction, we constructed xerC2 ftsK1 double mutants and measured their capacity for prophage excision at two positions. Excision frequencies of the double mutants were about the same as those of the equivalent ftsK1 single mutants (Table 2), supporting the view that both genes are involved in the same pathway. Furthermore, with antioriented prophages, the double mutant displayed lower excision rates than the single xerC2 mutant. The ftsK1 mutation is thus epistatic on a xerC2 mutation, indicating that FtsK has, in addition to its role in Xer recombination, other functions in the resolution pathway and that these functions operate before Xer recombination.
RecBCD is an actor in all processes of hyperrecombination in the terminus described thus far (11, 12, 19). This is also the case for ftsK1-induced fragility, since the frequency of prophage curing is strongly decreased when recB and recC genes are deleted (Table 2). Thus, the recombination-stimulating events occurring in the ftsK1 mutant produce double-strand ends, as in other situations leading to terminus fragility. These double-strand ends may result from guillotining (the trapped DNA is broken) or garroting (the next replication forks arriving in the trapped region are stopped, and subsequently nascent strands are extruded and anneal).
|
|
|---|
When terminus positioning is near normal but CDR is inactivatedthe situation corresponding to curve I of Fig. 4trapping occurs at or near dif, so that the consequences of aborted CDR are detected only in the vicinity of dif. The lower but much broader profile of terminal recombination in the ftsK1 mutant (curve II in Fig. 4) suggests that the fragile region is much less accurately determined in this mutant, although clearly still belonging to the terminus. A straightforward interpretation is that positioning of the terminus is the result of two successive processes. The first is a coarse positioning independent of FtsK, reflected by curve II, that accompanies or follows postreplication reconstruction of nucleoid structure. This positioning is not precise enough to allow efficient resolution at dif, but it is sufficient to situate the DNA that links the nucleoids in the terminus region. The second mechanism is a fine-tuning involving FtsK that positions the dif sites close to each other under the septum, so that CDR can take place or, if CDR fails, so that recombinational rescue is restricted to a limited region near dif.
Coarse positioning might be passive, a mere consequence of the terminus being replicated by a machinery anchored in the center of the cell where the septum will eventually form (13, 23), accompanied by sequential compaction of nascent DNA into two nucleoids. In this model, the links between nucleoids would "naturally" be confined to the terminus. Alternatively, the retention of a terminus macrodomain (TER region; 20 to 30% of the chromosome) in the vicinity of the future septum may be determined actively and specifically. This possibility is supported by cytological analyses of the terminus (20, 28). Experiments now in progress that are aimed at determining whether relocation of the region where replication forks collide causes a corresponding displacement of the region of elevated excision should shed light on this issue.
A remarkable finding is that terminus fragility is indifferent to prophage orientation in ftsK1 mutants, in contrast to the observation that in xerC mutants terminal recombination is a function of prophage orientation (Fig. 4 and Table 2). The conclusion is that the polarity-sensitive positioning mechanism must be FtsK dependent. How FtsK reads and uses DNA polarity furnished by Rags, or other similarly skewed elements, to mobilize DNA is unknown. Polar elements may act as inhibitors or as activators of the sliding of DNA through the FtsK-based edifice built at the septum. In either case, the direction of DNA movement under the closing septum would be dictated by the mobilized material itself.
Does FtsK have a role beyond ensuring the resolution of dimers? For example, the FtsK-dependent positioning process may help preclude accidental trapping of DNA by the septum. This could happen when a DNA loop is extruded past the septum into the opposite cell compartment. An FtsK ring might form on each thread of DNA passing through the septum and move the intruding loop in the direction dictated by the skewed elements. As shown in Fig. 5, the final result would be elimination of the loop and positioning of dif under the septum (an epiphenomenon in the case of a monomer chromosome). This again illustrates the interest for the cell in possessing a mobilization system in which the direction of DNA movement is dictated only by elements belonging to the mobilized material. The 14-min region from 26.5 to 40.5 min is characterized by a very low frequency of anti-Rags (Table 1). The strong polarity of Rag motifs in the TER region has perhaps evolved to combat the trapping of material that is forced by the chromosome or cell architecture to remain close to the septum. Outside the strongly polarized TER region, intrusion loops, if formed, might also be destroyed by the FtsK-dependent mobilization process. In this case, anti-Rag clusters would have the task of limiting the journey of a loop toward dif. The occurrence of such clusters is, however, consistent with random choice, suggesting that they have not been favored by selection (Table 1).
![]() View larger version (33K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. How FtsK might eliminate intrusion loops and position dif sites under the septum. (A) A DNA loop extruded from the nucleoid on the left wanders in the cytoplasm of the future sister cell to the right. When the septum is closing, FtsK forms ring structures around the two DNA threads. FtsK mobilizes these threads in the directions (indicated by arrows) dictated by Rags or similar DNA polar elements. (B) When one FtsK ring meets a region polarized in antiorientation (here, the DAZ at the replichore junction near dif), it stops mobilizing DNA; the other ring keeps acting, so that the size of the loop is gradually reduced. When the second ring meets the DAZ, dif is located under the septum and the loop is eliminated.
|
We thank François Cornet for numerous discussions. We are most grateful to David Lane for his interest, critical reading, and many improvements to the manuscript.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2010 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»