Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Bacteriology, July 2003, p. 4066-4073, Vol. 185, No. 14
0021-9193/03/$08.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JB.185.14.4066-4073.2003
Copyright © 2003, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Institute of Biological Chemistry,1 Core Facility for Protein X-Ray Crystallography, Academia Sinica,2 Institute of Chemistry, National Taiwan University, Taipei, Taiwan3
Received 21 February 2003/ Accepted 23 April 2003
|
|
|---|
ß
ßß topology. The structure is similar to that of Sso10b1 (also called Alba) from the same organism. However, Sso10b2 contains an arginine-rich loop RDRRR motif, which may play an important role in nucleic acid binding. There are two independent Sso10b2 proteins in the asymmetric unit, and a plausible stable dimer could be deduced from the crystal structure. Topology comparison revealed that Sso10b2 is similar to several RNA-binding proteins, including IF3-C, YhhP, and DNase I. Models of the Sso10b2 dimer bound to either B-DNA or A-DNA have been constructed. |
|
|---|
Two members of the 7-kDa proteins, Sso7d from Sulfolobus solfataricus and Sac7d from Sulfolobus acidocaldarius, have been studied extensive (7, 9, 20), but little is known about the 8-kDa and 10-kDa proteins. Sulfolobus solfataricus Sso10b is one of the 10-kDa members. Unlike the 7-kDa protein, Sso10b is conserved in most archaeal genomes sequenced, including all of the thermophiles and hyperthermophiles whose genomes have been completed, and is distributed among both the euryarchaeota (which encode histone-like proteins) and the crenarchaeota (which do not) (8).
Sso10b is abundant (4 to 5% of total soluble protein) and binds double-stranded DNA tightly but without apparent sequence specificity (1, 10, 29). Sso10b may form dimers or oligomers in cells. Electron microscopic studies of SacI0b from Sulfolobus acidocaldarius suggest that it binds DNA duplexes without significant compaction, affording protection against degradation by the nuclease DNase I (15).
Several archaeal species, including Sulfolobus solfataricus, Archaeoglobus fulgidus, Aeropyrum pernix, and Methanopyrus kandleri, have two copies of the Sso10b genes (Sso10b1 and Sso10b2). The Sso10b1 gene is found ubiquitously. The Sso10b2-like gene exists in many Sulfolobus strains, for instance, S. solfataricus, S. shibatae, and S. tokodaii. Ssh10b1 was isolated from the fraction containing the DNA binding activity (16), but Ssh10b2 protein could not be found in S. shibatae cells. These two isoforms are different in size and sequence (Fig. 1A). Sso10b1 is larger, with 100 amino acids, and Sso10b2 is 89 amino acids long. Sso10b1 has a longer N-terminal end and a longer sequence between residues 71 and 80 (Sso10b2 numbering). Sso10b1 (pI = 11.11) is significantly more positively charged, with a net +7 charges, than Sso10b2 (pI = 9.39), with a net +3 charges.
![]() View larger version (63K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. (A) Sequence alignment of Sso10b proteins from different archaeal organisms, including Sso10b2 (GenBank accession no. P74762) and Sso10b1 (Q971T6) from Sulfolobus solfataricus, Mka1 from Methanopyrus kandleri (Q8TXF9), Afu1 from Archaeoglobus fulgidus (O28323), Pfu1 from Pyrococcus furiosus (Q8TZV1), Mth from Methanopyrus kandleri (Q8TWE6), Ape from Aeropyrum pernix (Q9YAX2), Mja from Methanococcus jannaschii (Q57665), Pae from Pyrobaculum aerophilum (Q8ZVL3), and Tvo from Thermoplasma volcanium (Q979S5), are aligned. Orange, yellow, and light blue indicate the level of homology (100, 70, and 50%, respectively) of these genes. The secondary structures of Sso10b2 and Sso10b1 are shown below the alignment. (B) Carton presenting the ß ß ßß topology of Sso10b2.
|
A subfraction of the proteins from Sulfolobus solfataricus cell extracts were found in a stable complex with the silencing protein Sir2 (1). A protein tightly bound to Sir2 was identified as Alba, which turned out to be identical to Sso10b1. Lys16 and the adjacent Lys17 of Alba are known to be important for DNA binding (1). It was shown that Lys16 of Alba underwent deacetylation by Sir2, which affected the DNA-binding affinity of Alba.
The crystal structures at 2.8 Å (tetragonal) and 2.6 Å (hexagonal) resolution of Sso10b1 have been solved recently (25). To further explore the function and diversity of the Sso10b1 and Sso10b2 proteins, we present the crystal structure of Sso10b2 from Sulfolobus solfataricus at a substantially higher resolution, 1.85 Å, than those of Sso10b1.
|
|
|---|
For crystallization experiments, the Sso10b2 protein was dissolved in deionized water to make a 10-mg/ml solution. The hanging-drop vapor diffusion method was used, with the protein-to-reservoir ratio being 1 µl:1 µl. With Hampton Research Crystallization kits for the initial screening, we obtained plated crystals in 2 to 3 days, with the reservoir containing 500 µl of 25% polyethylene glycol MME 550-10 mM ZnSO4-100 mM morpholineethanesulfonic acid (MES), pH 6.5.
We performed electrophoretic mobility shift assays on the binding of Ssob2 to more than 10 different self-complementary DNA oligonucleotides. Our results showed that Sso10b2 effectively retarded the mobility of all DNAs tested. Thus, Sso10b2 has the ability to bind to double-helical DNA, just like Sso10b1. Sso10b2 mixed with different sequences and lengths of DNA fragments were also tested for crystallization at the same time, but no crystal could be obtained.
A high-quality crystal was crystallized with the drop containing an additional 7% sucrose. The crystal was soaked in the reservoir solution for cryodata collection. The preliminary X-ray analysis was performed with an in-house MicroMax002 X-ray generator with a Rigaku R-Axis IV++ image plate system. The high-resolution data were collected at beamline BL17B2 in the National Synchrotron Radiation Research Center, Hsinchu, Taiwan. The Sso10b2 crystal belongs to the P21212 space group, with unit cell dimensions of a = 36.02 Å, b = 134.98 Å, and c = 35.86 Å. There are two Sso10b2 molecules in an asymmetric unit.
Since the crystallization setup contained ZnSO4, we surmised that the crystals might have Zn2+ ions bound to protein molecules at specific positions, which may be used as anomalous scattering atoms. Although X-ray fluorescence scanning near the Zn absorption edge confirmed the presence of a Zn2+ ion, we were not certain whether the signal was merely due to the Zn2+ ion from solution. Nevertheless, we proceeded to collect the Zn-multiwavelength anomalous diffraction (MAD) data at Taiwan beamline BL12B2 in SPring-8, Japan, with the wavelengths of peak (1.2824 Å), edge (1.2830 Å), and high remote (1.2802 Å). The ADSC Quantum 4R charge-coupled device and Oxford Cryostream cooler were used for data collection. In total, 120 degrees of reflection data were collected by the oscillation method, and the oscillation range was 1 degree. The crystal-to-detector distance was 150 mm, and the exposure time was 30 s for each image. The data were processed and integrated with HKL2000 (19). The detailed statistics are listed in Tables 1 and 2.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Data collectiona
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Refinement of X-ray data
|
The final model contains the residues from 2 to 89 in chain A, 4 to 89 in chain B, 150 water molecules, and one Zn2+ ion. Figure 2 shows the electron density map surrounding the Zn2+ ion, which reveals the tetrahedrally coordinated Zn2+ ion. The detailed coordination structure is discussed later. The first two residues in chain B could not be determined because the unclear electron density. Ramachandran plot (nonglycine and nonproline) shows 144 (91%) residues in the most-favored regions, 12 (7.6%) in the additional allowed regions, and 2 (1.3%) in generously allowed regions. No residue is located in the disallowed regions. The refinement statistics are listed in Tables 1 and 2.
![]() View larger version (48K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. (A) 2Fo-Fc electron density maps surrounding the Zn2+ ion at the 1 level. (B) Dimer structure mediated by the Zn2+ ion.
|
|
|
|---|
ß
ßß topology (Fig. 1B) and comprises two parallel
-helices (
A and
B) packed against a four-ß-stranded (ß1 to ß4) sheet (Fig. 3A). The first two ß strands are parallel, and the third strand is antiparallel to the other strands. The fold does not resemble any of the histone-like families. The two monomers in an asymmetric unit are almost identical, with an root mean square distance of 0.60 Å and 81 C
atoms, but has a slight variation in two loop regions from 29 to 33 which is formed by helix
A and strand ß2, and 71 to 77, connected with strands ß3 and ß4, respectively.
![]() View larger version (46K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Crystal structure of Sso10b2 monomer. (A) Ribbon drawing of Sso10b2 monomer. The -helices are colored in magenta, and the ß-strands are green. The conserved basic residues are colored light blue, and the hydrophobic residues are coral. The RDRRR motif is shown in red. (B) Superposition of Sso10b2 and Sso10b1. The conserved Lys12 and Lys14 residues in Sso10b2 (Lys16 and Lys17 in Sso10b1) that may be acetylated are highlighted, with their side chains drawn as ball and stick bonds.
|
atoms) (Fig. 3B), but Sso10b2 has a shorter hairpin loop between strands ß3 and ß4 and contains an arginine-rich RDRRR motif. The higher B-factor of the hairpin loop in chain A but not in chain B, which is stabilized with the sym metry-related molecules in the crystal, implies that this loop is flexible in solution.
The study of Alba and Sir2 suggested that Alba bound to DNA targets, and the binding between Alba and DNA was regulated by Sir2 via the deacetylation of the conserved Lys16 residue of Alba (1). Sequence alignment of various archaeal Sso10b gene products indicated that the conserved acetylated Lys residue also existed in Sso10b2 (Fig. 1A and Fig. 3B). The conserved acetylated Lys12 (Lys16 in Alba) and Lys14 (Lys17 in Alba, which is not acetylated) are located at the center of the loop connected by the first ß-strand, ß1, and helix
A, which is stabilized by the interaction network composed by His19 and the neighboring residues. This loop, which contains two negatively charged residues, Glu17 and Asp18, is less hydrophobic than Alba and all archaeal Sso10b1-like proteins. The conserved positively charged Arg41 and the neighboring residues all pointing toward the same space as Lys12 confirmed that the ability to bind to nucleic acid targets is likely located along this surface.
Dimer structure.
The two independent molecules (molecule A and molecule B) in the asymmetric unit of the P21212 space group make contacts with each other in three directions, reflecting three kinds of possible dimer forms. The surface areas of the two Sso10b2 molecules in the asymmetric unit are 5,510 Å2 and 5,597 Å2. We found 1,220 Å2, 942 Å2, and 401 Å2 buried in the interface of three possible dimer forms (form 1, form 2, and form 3, respectively). Form 1, having the largest contact surface area, resembles a body with outstretched arms (the ß-hairpin loops), which is the same as the proposed Alba dimer (25). The 13 hydrogen bonds (Table 3) involved in the dimerization are located at the second helix (
B) and last two ß strands (ß3 and ß4). Extensive interactions between conserved hydrophobic residues Ile43, Val47, Val66, and Ile81 also stabilize the dimer. Those hydrophobic interactions would be the major driving force for dimer formation in solution.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 3. Distances between hydrogen bonds and salt bridges in the Sso10b2 dimer
|
![]() View larger version (62K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Structure and surface potential of Sso10b2 dimer. On the predicted surface for DNA binding, there are 18 (R11, K12, K14, R41, K45, R73, R75, R76, and R77 on each molecule) basic residues.
|
A helices provide 10 hydrogen bonds, and the conserved hydrophobic Leu21 and Ile24 amino acids participate in the formation of the dimer. This interface also appears in the structure of Sso10b1 (25).
In the third form, the interface of the dimer is also contributed by the two helices (
A from molecule A and
B from molecule B), but it is unique in the Sso10b2 crystal formed along the 21 axis. There are only six hydrogen bonds between two monomers. However, unlike the first two dimers, a strong ionic force is provided by Asp18, Asp22, and, surprisingly, Lys14 in one monomer and Asp55 in the other via a Zn2+ ion, as described before (Fig. 2A and B). The coordination distances surrounding the Zn2+ ion are listed in Table 4. The coordination involving the NH2 group of the Lys14 side chain implies that this amino group is not protonated. Since Lys14 is likely to be involved in the acetylation-deacetylation process, based on its homology to Alba, its ability to coordinate the Zn2+ ion raises an interesting question, whether the Zn2+ ion participates in the acetylation-deacetylation process of Lys14 in Sso10b2.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 4. Distances around the Zn2+ ion
|
Interestingly, Sso10b2 has a unique arginine-rich motif, which is known to be important for RNA binding (27). RNA-binding proteins containing arginine-rich motifs function in transcription, translation, RNA trafficking, and packing. The arginine-rich motifs exhibit diverse secondary structures. The side chain of arginine can make specific contacts with the phosphate and enlarges the major groove of RNA. The charged guanidinium group has the potential to form pentadentate hydrogen bonds and is flexibly tethered to the protein main chain by a long aliphatic side chain. In a previous study, the Ssh10b2 protein could not be identified from the fraction containing DNA binding activity. The purified DNA binding fraction of S. solfataricus also identified the existence of Alba only (1). It is possible that Sso10b2 is not expressed at a high enough level to be detected or is not expressed at all. If this is the case, why and how these two isoforms are differentially expressed are interesting questions to pursue. These data seem to suggest that Sso10b2 may have a distinct role from Sso10b1, as discussed below.
A three-dimensional alignment search of the DALI server (11) showed that the topology of Sso10b is similar to that of two RNA-binding proteins, the C-terminal domain of E. coli translation initiation factor IF3 (2) and cell division protein YhhP (12). But the hairpin loop has large variations. All of them adopt a ß
ß
ßß topology (Fig. 5). In IF3, the conserved Arg89, Lys102, and Phe99 are important for the binding of rRNA (6, 18). Arg89 and Lys102 may interact with rRNA directly, and Phe99 stabilizes the Arg139-Glu96 salt bridge by the stacking interaction with Arg139. These three residues are close to the position of Lys12, Lys14, and His19 in Sso10b2. The Glu21 important for cell elongation in Yhhp (30) is also located near the acetylated Lys14 in Sso10b2. Sso10b2 also has a high level of structural homology to the N-terminal domain of the DNase I protein (22) (Fig. 5A). The structure of DNase I with a nicked DNA duplex defined the DNA binding site of DNase I, whereby a protruding ß-hairpin loop sits in the minor groove of duplex in the distorted B-DNA form, and another study (28) indicated that DNase I can interact with but cannot cleave DNA in the A conformation. The highly homologous conformations, including the length of the hairpin, between Sso10b2 and DNase I suggest that the DNA-binding mode may be similar as well.
![]() View larger version (30K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Structural alignment of Sso10b2 with DNase I (2DNJ), YhhP (1DCJ), and IF3-C (1TIG). The root mean square deviation values of the main chain atoms are 1.4 Å (180 atoms), 1.6 Å (212 atoms), and 1.5 Å (200 atoms), respectively. The root mean square deviation values of the C atoms are 2.8 Å (70 atoms), 2.5 Å (69 atoms) and 2.3 Å (69 atoms), respectively.
|
![]() View larger version (66K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. Models of Sso10b2 dimer bound to DNA. The conserved positively charged amino acids Lys12, Lys14, Arg41, Arg73, Arg75, Arg76, and Arg77 are close to the phosphate groups along the minor groove. (A and B) Model of an Sso10b2 dimer bound to B-DNA. (C and D) Model of an Sso10b2 dimer bound to A-DNA.
|
A helices of the dimer in this model are prominently located at opposite sides of the DNA double helix. It is conceivable that one Sso10b2 dimer could interact with an adjacent dimer through two
A helices involving the conserved hydrophobic Leu21 and Ile24 amino acids and other hydrogen bonds, as seen in form 2 (see above) dimer interactions. Such interactions extending in both directions up and down the DNA would allow the DNA double helix to be completely covered by Sso10b proteins, thermally stabilizing the DNA duplex and protecting DNA from DNase attacks. Whether these interactions are cooperative is not clear. In another model, the Sso10b2 dimer binds on the relatively shallow surface of the minor groove of A-DNA (or RNA). The two loops containing Lys12 and Lys14 bind to the phosphates across the major groove, whereas the loops containing the RDRRR motif (R73 to R77) extend away from each other and bind to the phosphates over the narrow entrance of the deep major groove (and beyond), also at a distance nearly one turn of the A-DNA helix apart.
In both models, the loops and the side chains of Arg and Lys are presumably flexible enough to adjust their conformations to avoid any possible unfavorable steric contacts. Of course, the exact binding mode of Sso10b2 to DNA or RNA will need to be resolved by structural analysis of an Sso10b2-nucleic acid complex and biochemical and biophysical studies of Sso10b proteins. It is of interest that Sac7d and Sso7d produced a large DNA kink with the local A-DNA conformation at the protein binding sites (9, 20). Therefore, it would not be surprising that the actual DNA conformation induced by Sso10b1 and Sso10b2 binding will not occur as suggested in either of the hypothetical models proposed here or elsewhere (25).
There remain a number of interesting issues to be addressed in the future. Why are there two Sso10b proteins, Sso10b1 and Sso10b2? Do they have different biological functions? It is not clear whether the native Sso10b2 protein isolated from S. solfataricus contains acetylated lysines or not. What are the relationships between the three classes of 7-kDa, 8-kDa, and 10-kDa proteins in terms of their biological functions? Like Sso7d, Sso10b2 is a small hyperthermophilic protein. What is the structural basis for its extraordinary heat stability? Those issues will be pursued.
|
|
|---|
/ß domains linked by an
-helix. EMBO J. 14:4056-4064.[Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»