Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Bacteriology, August 2003, p. 4558-4563, Vol. 185, No. 15
0021-9193/03/$08.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JB.185.15.4558-4563.2003
Copyright © 2003, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
and Margaret C. M. Smith*
Institute of Genetics, University of Nottingham, Queens Medical Centre, Nottingham, NG7 2UH, United Kingdom
Received 28 February 2003/ Accepted 9 May 2003
|
|
|---|
C31 and homoimmune relatives. Pgl is subject to phase variation, and data presented here show that this is at least partially due to expansion and contraction of a polyguanine tract present within the putative adenine-specific DNA methyltransferase gene, pglX. Furthermore, the pglX paralogue SC6G9.02, here renamed pglS, was shown to be able to interfere with the Pgl phenotype, suggesting that PglS could provide an alternative activity to that conferred by PglX. |
|
|---|
Streptomycescoelicolor has an unusual phage resistance mechanism termed the phage growth limitation (Pgl) system (9). The phenotype is characterized by the ability of the infecting phage (e.g.,
C31) to undergo a single phage burst, which produces progeny that are severely attenuated in a second infectious cycle. The model proposed by Chinenova et al. postulates that Pgl+ strains modify phage, which are then restricted during the second cycle (9). This modification is not lethal to the phage as progeny from a Pgl+ strain can infect and form plaques on Pgl- strains (9). Two loci, pglYZ and pglWX, have been identified as being necessary and sufficient for production of a Pgl+ phenotype in S. coelicolor (3, 19, 31). Two classes of Pgl- mutants are evident; class A mutants can be complemented by pglYZ (19), and class B mutants can be complemented by pglWX (31). PglW shows homology to eukaryotic-like serine/threonine protein kinases, while PglX resembles adenine-specific DNA methyltransferases. PglX is hypothesized to fulfill the modification component of Pgl through DNA methylation (31). PglY is distantly related to the AAA+ group of proteins thought to be required for the assembly, maintenance, and disassembly of protein complexes (23), a role that is consistent with the preliminary evidence that the Pgl proteins act as a complex (31). PglZ contains no recognizable functional motifs (3). A recent study suggested that PglZ could be phosphorylated in uninfected cells (15), possibly through the activity of PglW. Pgl may therefore act via phosphoproteins that in the first infectious cycle modify the progeny phage DNA through methylation, and in a subsequent infectious cycle the infection is somehow aborted (31). Unusually for a phage resistance system, Pgl has a very limited range of sensitive phages (i.e.,
C31 and its homoimmune relatives) (19).
The Pgl system has been shown to be phase variable, with Pgl- mutants arising at frequencies of 10-3 to 10-4 per spore (19) and reversion occurring at similar frequencies. Previously, the phase variation mechanism of Pgl was examined by genomic Southern blotting of the pgl loci from different Pgl+ and Pgl- strains (19, 31). With the exception of the IS1648 insertion into pglW in strain B135 Pgl- (and its derivative J1974), no large-scale structural rearrangements were identified in any Pgl- strain that could account for the phase variability. While insertion sequences have been reported to be potentiators of phase variation (34), this is not thought to be the case with the IS1648 insertion in B135 Pgl- as this strain is believed to be a UV-induced mutant rather than a natural phase variant (Helen Kieser, personal communication).
Data presented here show that the phase variation is at least partially due to expansion and contraction of a polyguanine tract present in the putative adenine-specific DNA methyltransferase gene, pglX. Furthermore, the pglX paralogue SC6G9.02, here renamed pglS, was shown to be able to interfere with the Pgl phenotype, suggesting that PglS may provide an alternative activity to that conferred by PglX.
|
|
|---|
was routinely used as the cloning host (26). High-titer stocks of the clear-plaque phage
C31c
25 (29) or the extended-host-range mutant
C31hc (10) were prepared as previously described (17). Plaque tests were performed by overlaying 1 ml of soft YT that was seeded with approximately 5 x 107 spores onto a Difco nutrient agar plate containing 10 mM MgSO4 and 8 mM Ca(NO3)2 spread with dilutions of phage (17). The antibiotic concentrations used were those described previously for E. coli (26) and Streptomyces (17). |
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Pgl status and length of the G tract in pglX of strains used in this study
|
pPS8001 was constructed as follows. A 5,229-bp SstI fragment containing pglS was inserted into pARO191 (24) to form pPS4001. An NdeI site overlapping the start codon of pglS was introduced through replacement of the 5' end via EcoRV-FseI digestion by using the PCR product obtained with primers 6G9TIPF (5'-ACGATATCCCATATGATCGACCGCAAGGCTCTGT-3') and 6G9TIPR (5'-GCGGCCGGCCTGGCCCTGGCCCAGTTCGT-3'). The resulting construct, pPS3006, was digested with XmaI and XbaI, which removed the 3' end of pglS, and the 3' end was replaced with a six-His-tag-encoding version generated by using PCR primers MENDSQ (5'-ACGTACTTCACCAACACCGC-3') and 6G9HIS (5'-GGTCTAGACTAGTGGTGGTGGTGGTGGTGGCTGCCGCGCGGCACCAGTCGCTTCTTGTCCTTGCCCC-3') to create pPS5006. The His-tagged pglS was isolated from pPS5006 as an NdeI-XbaI fragment and inserted downstream of the thiostrepton-inducible promoter ptipA in the expression vector pIJ6902 (M. Buttner, personal communication), creating pPS8001. pPS8003 was created as follows. A 5,772-bp BamHI fragment containing pglX was inserted into pARO191 to form pPS2002. An NdeI site overlapping the start codon of pglX was introduced through replacement of the 5' end, by using HindIII-FseI digestion, with the PCR product obtained with primers MMUTF (5'-AGAAGCTTCACATATGATCGACCGCAAGGCTCTGT-3') and MMUTR (5'-CAGCAAGCGGCCGGCCTGCCCATC-3'). The resulting construct, pPS3009, was digested with AatII, which removed the 3' end of pglX, and this 3' end was replaced with a six-His-tag-encoding version generated by using PCR primers 1F2NEW (5'-GCGACGTCGGATCCTAGTGGTGGTGGTGGTGGTGGCTGCCGCGCGGCACCAGCTGCTTCGCTGCTGCGCGAC-3') and MENDSQ to create pPS5028. The His-tagged pglX gene was isolated from pPS5028 as an NdeI-BamHI fragment and inserted into the E. coli expression vector pT7-7 (32), creating pPS5032. pPS8003 was generated by insertion of pglX from pPS5032 into pIJ6902 on an NdeI-XbaI fragment.
|
|
|---|
A similar strategy was used to determine whether Pgl- strains defective at the pglWX locus contained an expanded or contracted G tract within pglX. Eight different Pgl+ strains were sequenced and were shown to contain the expected 8-base G tract (Table 1 and Fig. 1). However, the class B Pgl- strains, M145 Pgl- (kindly provided by J. White, John Innes Centre) and 1915 (and also its derivative J1973), contained 9-base G tracts (Fig. 1 and Table 1). In addition, the spontaneously arising double Pgl- mutants J1902 and J1903 had 7- and 9-base G tracts, respectively (Fig. 1 and Table 1). These data indicate that in the JIC strain collection there have been four apparently independent events of expansion or contraction of the G tract to generate a Pgl- phenotype (1915, J1902, J1903, and M145Pgl-).
![]() View larger version (43K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Expansion and retraction of the G tract in pglX and its effect on plaque formation by C31. (A) Resistance and sensitivity of M145 and M145 Pgl- to C31c 25. (B and C) Presence of eight G residues (B) and nine G residues (C) in the variable G tract in the pglX gene in M145 and M145 Pgl-, respectively. All other Pgl+ strains tested gave sequence chromatographs identical to that shown in panel B. (D) Pgl- strain J1902 was the only strain to contain seven G residues (D).
|
1010) of the clear-plaque phage
C31c
25 (29) to select for Pgl+ phase variants. Ten phage-resistant J1973 colonies (N600 to N609) were isolated, and the spores were amplified for use in plaque tests. To eliminate the possibility that the isolated colonies were receptor mutants, they were challenged in plaque assays with the extended-host-range mutant phage
C31hc, which is capable of infecting receptor mutant strains (10). No plaques were seen on any of the phage plates (data not shown), suggesting that all 10 isolates had undergone phase variation from Pgl- to Pgl+. Sequencing of the region containing the G tract confirmed that each isolate had indeed regained an 8-base G tract. Together, these data strongly suggest that expansion and contraction of the G tract in pglX is at least partially responsible for the phase variation of Pgl.
A paralogue of PglX, PglS, can interfere with Pgl.
In the Pgl system the variable G tract is located in pglX. S. coelicolor A3(2) has a paralogue of pglX, SC6G9.02 (here renamed pglS) which encodes a protein with 76% identical amino acids (Fig. 2). The level of DNA identity is also 76%, but it is noteworthy that pglS does not contain an 8-base G tract in the equivalent position to that in pglX. pglS does, however, have a run of seven G residues 487 bp downstream. While previously we showed that pglS is not required for the Pgl phenotype (31), we did not test whether PglS could interact with other Pgl components in a manner reminiscent of the interaction of variable HsdS proteins that interact with HsdR and HsdM proteins in the type I R-M systems (12, 28, 30). If PglS can indeed interact with the other Pgl proteins and thereby change the phage specificity of the resistance phenotype, when we overexpress pglS, we would expect a Pgl- phenotype with
C31 and enhanced resistance to a subset of other phages. Plasmid pPS8001 expresses pglS fused to an N-terminal six-His tag from the thiostrepton-inducible promoter (ptipA). After introduction of pPS8001 or pPS8003 (expressing His-tagged PglX from ptipA) into Pgl+ strain M145 by conjugation, eight separate exconjugants were isolated from each conjugation, and spores were amplified for use in plaque tests. In the presence of 20 µg of thiostrepton per ml, M145 derivatives containing pPS8001 produced faint plaques, compared to no plaques obtained with M145 containing pPS8003 (Fig. 3). In a separate experiment pPS8001 did not confer a Pgl+ phenotype to pglX strain N703, whereas pPS8003 did (31; data not shown), indicating that PglX complements the pglX lesion but PglS does not. To explain the effect of PglS overexpression in M145, we propose that PglS is able to interact with other Pgl proteins, titrating them away from PglX and resulting in a weak Pgl- phenotype.
![]() View larger version (85K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Alignment of PglX and PglS. PglX and PglS were aligned to identify regions of similarity. A black background indicates identical amino acids, a grey background indicates functionally similar amino acids, and a white background indicates functionally dissimilar amino acids. The alignment was created by using the PileUp program from GCG. The region enclosed by a dashed box corresponds to the variable region in PglX and PglS and to the low-G+C-content region in the corresponding gene sequences. The S-adenosine methionine binding site and the N6-adenine DNA methylase signature are indicated by one and two grey lines, respectively, above the amino acid sequence.
|
![]() View larger version (72K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Pgl phenotypes of M145 derivatives: plaque production in M145 containing a PglS overexpression construct (pPS8001) or a PglX overexpression construct (pPS8003). The plates contained 20 µg of thiostrepton per ml.
|
C31 and its homoimmune relatives, the sensitivity of M145(pPS8001) to phages R4 and
HAU3 and a number of novel phages isolated from soil was tested. No change in the efficiency of plating or plaque morphology was observed (data not shown). |
|
|---|
As the variable G tract is located in pglX, we studied the role of the pglX paralogue pglS in the Pgl phenotype. Overexpression of PglS can confer a weak Pgl- phenotype (faint, cloudy plaques) in M145, a strain that is otherwise Pgl+. We propose that this effect is due to PglS outcompeting PglX for interaction with the other Pgl proteins. The PglX and PglS proteins are predicted to be DNA adenine methyltransferases. The current model for the mechanism of Pgl proposes that PglX modifies
C31 DNA so that during infection of the host with modified phage, the infection is aborted (31). If this were the case, the presence of a close homologue, pglS, in combination with the phase variation mechanism in pglX could potentially enable S. coelicolor to switch the specificity of the Pgl system to a different target. Our inability to detect enhanced resistance to several phages tested on M145 overexpressing pglS may simply have been because we did not test enough phages. Currently, there is no information on the transcription of pglS or regulation of its gene product, both of which also need to be considered in any switch mechanism.
A curious observation is that while PglS interferes with the activity of Pgl proteins in M145, higher levels of PglS apparently have the opposite effect on the Pgl phenotype of J1501. Introduction of pglS into J1501 on a low-copy-number, replicating vector has previously been shown to reduce the efficiency of plating of
C31c1 phage (2). It is not known how significant this is considering that of the many strains tested, J1501 was the only strain that showed this effect with the pglS-encoding construct. Another observation with strain J1501 is that its pglYZ genes appear to be only partially active, so that increasing the copy number confers a weak Pgl+ phenotype to J1501 and the
pglY mutant J1929 (2). One possible explanation for the behavior of J1501 is that this strain is less able to assemble stable, active Pgl complexes and extra copies of the PglY and PglZ or PglS proteins could rectify this defect, either directly through the proposed activity of PglY or via provision of additional scaffolds, as could be the case with PglS.
Analysis of the codon usage of pglWYZ showed that for the entire length, the G+C content is close to that observed for the average Streptomyces gene (72.1%) (4). In contrast, pglX and pglS both have much lower G+C contents (63.5 and 62.9%, respectively), particularly in the central regions. Moreover, alignment of the amino acid sequences of PglX and PglS showed that the proteins are virtually identical at their termini but diverge greatly in the middle (Fig. 2). The divergence in the central region was confirmed by alignment of the DNA sequences, indicating that sequencing errors do not provide a trivial explanation (data not shown). A significant change in base content compared to the overall average content is often an indication that the DNA has been horizontally acquired, and we speculate that pglX and pglS are mosaics. The differences in the activities of PglX and PglS could conceivably be localized to these variable regions.
Recently, homologues of the pgl genes have emerged in the microbial genome databases. A cluster encoding pglWYZ-like genes is present in the preliminary genome sequenceof the thermophilic actinomycete Thermobifida fusca (http://www.jgi.doe.gov/JGI_microbial/html/index.html). There are, in addition, two putative DNA methyltransferase genes homologous to pglX and pglS, and one of these has a low-G+C-content central region like pglX and pglS. However, alignment of the T. fusca PglX and PglS homologues did not reveal a highly variable region like that seen with PglX and PglS. Bacteriophages have been reported for T. fusca, but there is insufficient information to determine if there is a Pgl phenotype (25). More distant relatives are found in the Nostoc punctiforma genome, which has a cluster encoding pglZ, pglX/S, and pglY-like genes and another homologue of pglX/S at a distal location (http://www.jgi.doe.gov/JGI_microbial/html/nostoc/nostoc_homepage.html).
In summary, we describe a mechanism that at least partially explains the high-frequency phase variation in the Pgl system in S. coelicolor A3(2). A search of the S. coelicolor genome sequence for additional G tracts indicated that there are 28 8-base G tracts, eight loci with 9-base G tracts, one locus with 10 bases, and one locus with 12 bases (4). Only four of these loci are intragenic, lying within pglX, SCO1006, SCO5902, and SCO6313. SCO5902 is annotated as a transposase pseudogene, while the functions of SCO1006 and SCO6313 are not known. In general, it appears that G tracts are therefore avoided within gene sequences in Streptomyces and expansion and contraction of the G tract in pglX are likely to have been selected. The ability of PglS to interact with the Pgl system implies that it may be able to provide an activity that is an alternative to PglX activity, adding to the versatility of this unusual phage resistance phenotype.
This work was supported by the BBSRC.
Present address: Division of Geographic Medicine and Infectious Diseases, Tufts New England Medical Center, Boston, MA 02111. ![]()
|
|
|---|
C31 resistance mechanism of Streptomyces coelicolor A3(2). J. Bacteriol. 177:4681-4689.
C31. Gene 19:21-32.[CrossRef][Medline]
C31. Mol. Microbiol. 41:601-610.[CrossRef][Medline]
C31-specific phage growth limitation (Pgl) system of Streptomyces coelicolor A3(2). Mol. Microbiol. 7:329-336.[CrossRef][Medline]
C31: nucleotide sequence, analysis and functional cloning. Mol. Gen. Genet. 213:269-277.[CrossRef][Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»