Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Bacteriology, September 2003, p. 5301-5305, Vol. 185, No. 17
0021-9193/03/$08.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JB.185.17.5301-5305.2003
Copyright © 2003, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Krista Owens,1,2 Srdjan Jelacic,4,
and Phillip I. Tarr4,
Mucosal and Vaccine Research Center, Veterans Affairs Medical Center,1 Department of Medicine, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55417,2 Department of Pediatrics, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio 43210,3 Department of Pediatrics, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington 981954
Received 10 March 2003/ Accepted 20 June 2003
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Background. Bacteria differing only for a particular gene are often used to assess the phenotypic significance of specific genes (5-7, 10, 16, 21, 22). One technique for producing isogenic Escherichia coli mutants involves introducing a replication-defective suicide plasmid containing a modified version of the target gene into a wild-type strain. Derivatives with a mutant allele exchanged for a wild-type allele are isolated through serial selection and screening steps (8, 23). Mutant validation is usually limited to confirming the intended allelic exchange. Here we describe inapparent secondary mutations in allelic exchange mutants created in different laboratories and wild-type strains by contemporary suicide plasmid methods.
Strains. CP9 (O4:K10/54/96:H5), CFT073 (O6:K2:H1), and RS218 (O18:K1:H7), wild-type pathogenic E. coli strains (1, 11, 13, 14, 23, 26-28), contain established or putative virulence genes, such as pap (P fimbriae), hly (hemolysin), cnf1 (cytotoxic necrotizing factor 1), iha (iron-regulated gene homologue adhesin), sat (secreted autotransporter toxin), iutA (aerobactin system), and malX (pathogenicity-associated island [PAI] marker) (20). UPEC76 is a double pap mutant of CFT073 (23).
Mutagenesis. The two CP9 hlyA genes, encoded on separate PAIs (18), were targeted for mutation (in the laboratory of H.A.L., Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio) by using pWAM1746, a derivative of the sucrose-counterselectable suicide vector pCVD442 (24). The hlyA::Kanr mutation from pWAM1746 was introduced into one copy of hlyA in CP9. In a second round of allelic exchange targeting the second CP9 hlyA gene, selection for mutants with two copies of hlyA::Kanr yielded derivatives such as WEX139 (Table 1). Additionally, the Kanr gene in pWAM1746 was replaced with a chloramphenicol resistance (Chlr) gene; this construct was used to generate hlyA::Kanr hlyA:Chlr derivatives (e.g., WEX404 in Table 1). Putative double hlyA mutants were screened for antibiotic resistance, hemolysin, and CNF1 production (25) and were examined in Southern blots (30) for hlyA, cnf1, and pCVD442 sequences (8).
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Characteristics of selected E. coli parent strains and their putatively isogenic derivatives
|
To delete papG alleles I and III in strain CP9, in-frame deleted versions of these genes were ligated separately into suicide vector pCVD442 and the resulting plasmids were introduced into a nalidixic acid-resistant CP9 derivative (CP9Nalr) in the laboratory of J.R.J. (University of Minnesota, Minneapolis). Dual antibiotic selection yielded the desired integrants. After nonselective growth, derivatives having resolved the plasmid were selected on 5% sucrose agar without sodium chloride. PCR using flanking and internal papG primers confirmed allele exchange. A double papG mutant was created in a papG allele I single mutant by using the papG allele III suicide plasmid, described above.
papG allele III of a Nalr RS218 derivative (RS218Nalr) was deleted (by J.R.J) as described for CP9Nalr.
iha was deleted (in the laboratory of P.I.T., University of Washington, Seattle) from CFT073Nalr, a Nalr CFT073 derivative. An in-frame-deleted version of iha was ligated into pCVD442, yielding the construct used to derive allelic exchange iha mutants of CFT074Nalr, as described above for papG in CP9Nalr. Exchange was confirmed by PCR with internal and flanking iha primers. iha was similarly deleted from UPEC76.
Extended virulence genotypes. Isolates were tested in duplicate for 35 virulence-associated markers by multiplex PCR (19, 20).
PFGE. XbaI- with or without AvrII-generated macrorestriction profiles were examined by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) (performed according to the 1998 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention training course "Standardized molecular subtyping of foodborne bacterial pathogens by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis"). Altered profiles were confirmed in duplicate.
Findings. In six of the nine unique (host strain-target gene-suicide vector) combinations, unintended nonparental genotype alterations were observed (Table 1 and Fig. 1 to 3).
![]() View larger version (127K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. PFGE profiles of strain CP9 and selected derivatives. Lanes 1 to 4 contain XbaI digests, and lanes 5 to 8 contain AvrII digests. Lanes: 1 and 5, WEX404 (hlyA cnf1 papG allele III); 2 and 6, WEX139 (hlyA cnf1); 3 and 7, CP9 (parent); and 4 and 8, WEX135. Arrowheads indicate positions of profile differences between parent and derivatives. Solid arrowheads indicate complete loss or gain of band, and open arrowheads indicate diminished intensity of band.
|
![]() View larger version (90K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. AvrII PFGE profiles of strains CFT073Nalr and selected derivatives. Lanes: 1, CFT073Nalr; 2, JJ1073 (iha iutA hlyD mutant of CFT073Nalr); 3 and 5, JJ1078 and JJ1080, respectively (both, iha iutA mutants of CFT073Nalr); 4 and 6, JJ1079 and JJ1091, respectively (both, iha mutants of CFT073Nalr). Arrowheads indicate positions of profile differences between parent and derivatives.
|
Forty-six (6%) of 800 second-round derivatives (e.g., WEX404), created with a Chlr derivative of pWAM1746, were phenotypically Kanr Chlr Amps Hly- as expected. However, like WEX139, each was CNF1- and contained no cnf1 by Southern hybridization. These isolates also lost papG allele III (Table 1) and exhibited altered PFGE profiles (Fig. 1).
papG alleles I and III were deleted individually from CP9Nalr without detectable secondary mutations (Table 1). However, deletion of papG allele III from an allele I single mutant (JJ972), although producing several apparently isogenic double papG mutants (e.g., JJ985 to -987), also yielded derivatives (e.g., JJ988 to -989) with altered XbaI PFGE profiles (Fig. 2) despite retaining their virulence genotype (Table 1). PFGE alterations with retained virulence genotyping also occurred with attempted deletion of papG allele III from RS218Nalr (data not shown).
![]() View larger version (106K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. XbaI PFGE profiles of strains CFT073Nalr, CP9Nalr, and selected derivatives. Lanes: 1, CFT073Nalr; 2 to 4, JJ1073, JJ1076, and JJ1077, respectively (all iha iutA hlyD mutants of CFT073Nalr); 5, JJ1078 (iha iutA mutant of CFT073Nalr); 6, CP9Nalr; 7, JJ988 (double papG mutant of CP9Nalr). Arrowheads indicate positions of profile differences between parents and respective derivatives.
|
![]() View larger version (12K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Map of the regions of the CFT073 genome adjacent to iha. Positions of relevant genes (hatched boxes) are shown according to their coordinates in the CFT073 genome. Open boxes represent putative deletions involving iha (downward arrow) and flanking regions. Deletion I iha mutants (not shown) exhibit only an internal deletion within iha. Deletion II iha mutants also have lost the F7-2 papA allele, iha flanking sequences, sat, and iutA. Deletion III mutants have lost all these markers plus hlyD. All mutants retain R2 (malX) and R1 (sacpa). Dashed arrows indicate possible extension of deletions, and dotted vertical lines indicate known minimal or maximal boundaries of deletions.
|
Implications of findings. The high frequency of unanticipated, inadvertent, secondary mutations involving shifts in PFGE patterns and loss of other known virulence loci when often-employed suicide vectors are used is of concern, because the central tenet of allelic exchange is that the resulting phenotypic differences are specifically attributable to the target mutation. However, if additional mutations result, they, and not the intended mutation, may cause the differences. This is particularly problematic when secondary mutations involve known or putative virulence genes and the phenotype of interest is virulence (10).
The high frequency of secondary mutations using unrelated strains and a diversity of target alleles suggests that inadvertent mutations may be common with pCVD442 and, perhaps, other allelic exchange systems. It should be noted that we targeted genes within PAIs, which are structures with a propensity for spontaneous deletions and rearrangements (3, 4, 12, 29, 32), and the unintentionally deleted genes occurred within the same PAIs. We speculate that aberrant integration and/or excision of plasmids caused changes in neighboring DNA, analogous to perturbations in genomic architecture in E. coli K-12 when lysogenized by a Shiga toxin 2-encoding bacteriophage (17). The patterns of virulence gene loss support this hypothesis with CFT073, for which the structure of the relevant PAI is defined (Fig. 4).
Exclusion of inadvertent secondary mutations, short of whole-genome sequencing (2, 32) or other methods that detect small interchromosomal differences (31), poses challenges. That PFGE detected all secondary mutants recommends this modality. Alternatively, multiple independent deletants for the same target gene could be prepared, possibly even in different wild-type backgrounds (25), subjected to confirmation of retention of a panel of non-target loci, and then tested in various systems to confirm uniformity of effect.
Complementation of presumed isogenic in-frame mutants would also help corroborate specific attribution of effect (10), but this approach too is imperfect, because gene regulation and copy number may significantly influence phenotype (9, 15, 25), although low-copy-number vectors may help (15). Alternatively, the wild-type allele could be restored to the genome at the native locus by reverse allelic exchange. These considerations illustrate the challenges inherent in attempting to define causal relationships in complex biological systems, the use of contemporary molecular methods notwithstanding.
Thomas A. Russo provided CP9, Harry L. T. Mobley provided CFT073 and UPEC76, and Kwang Sik Kim provided RS218. Adam L. Stell and Sheldon N. Finver provided expert technical assistance. Dave Prentiss (VA Medical Center) helped prepare the figures.
Present address: Battelle Memorial Institute, Columbus, OH 43201. ![]()
Present address: University of Washington School of Medicine, Seattle, WA 98195. ![]()
Present address: Department of Pediatrics, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, MO 63110. ![]()
|
|
|---|
1-4)Gal-binding adhesins. J. Infect. Dis. 175:983-988.[Medline]
Gal(1-4)-ßGal binding in virulence of a wild-type strain. Mol. Microbiol. 10:143-155.[Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»