Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Bacteriology, April 2003, p. 2548-2554, Vol. 185, No. 8
0021-9193/03/$08.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JB.185.8.2548-2554.2003
Copyright © 2003, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Andrew K. Haydock, and John A. Leigh*
Department of Microbiology, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington 98195
Received 28 October 2002/ Accepted 21 January 2003
|
|
|---|
(FdhA) and ß (FdhB) subunits and a putative formate transporter (FdhC) as well as a carbonic anhydrase analog. The second gene cluster encodes only FdhA and FdhB homologs. Mutants lacking either fdhA gene exhibited a partial growth defect on formate, whereas a double mutant was completely unable to grow on formate as a sole methanogenic substrate. Investigation of fdh gene expression revealed that transcription of both gene clusters is controlled by the presence of H2 and not by the presence of formate. |
|
|---|
and ß, encoded by fdhA and fdhB, respectively (15, 19).
The presence or absence of formate dehydrogenase genes does not predict the ability to grow on formate. Species known to contain contiguously encoded homologs of fdhA and fdhB include Methanococcus maripaludis, Methanococcus voltae, Methanobacterium formicicum, Methanococcus jannaschii, and Methanopyrus kandleri. Of these species, only the first three can use formate (4). In the species Methanothermobacter thermautotrophicus, strain Z-245 can use formate but strain
H cannot. This difference is attributed to the presence in the former strain of fdh genes that are absent from the same genomic context in the latter (15). Nevertheless, fdhA and fdhB homologs are present in the genome of strain
H, albeit not closely related to those known in strain Z-245. Furthermore, at least one species that is unable to grow on formate, M. jannaschii, possesses formate dehydrogenase enzyme activity (11).
The organization and regulation of formate dehydrogenase genes have been studied in M. formicicum (23) and M. thermoautotrophicus strain Z-245 (15), both of which use formate. In each species a gene designated fdhC precedes fdhA and fdhB. FdhC contains several potential membrane-spanning regions (23) and may encode a formate transporter. Northern blots in both species indicated the presence of three mRNA types, one containing fdhC, fdhA, and fdhB, another containing fdhC alone, and the third containing fdhA and fdhB. An apparent transcription start site was identified upstream of fdhC in both species. The smaller mRNAs could be formed by termination or processing between fdhC and fdhA, although a separate initiation of transcription in this region could not be ruled out. In M. thermoautotrophicus Z-245 the levels of fdh mRNA increased when the availability of hydrogen was decreased (15).
We have studied the formate dehydrogenase genes of M. maripaludis. Examination of the genome sequence of M. maripaludis indicated the presence of genes encoding two distinct formate dehydrogenases. Biochemical studies had shown that two distinct formate dehydrogenases exist in the related species Methanococcus vannielii (9, 10), but genetic studies were not carried out. Due to the development of genetic methods for M. maripaludis (21), we have been able to produce mutants in both sets of fdh genes and to determine their roles in growth on formate. In addition, we used lacZ fusions to determine factors that regulated the expression of both gene sets.
|
|
|---|
Construction of mutants. The fdhA1::neo mutant, MM707, was constructed as follows. A 2,064-bp PCR product containing the fdhA1 gene was amplified from LL chromosomal DNA by using primers FdhA1 and FdhA2 (Table 1). The PCR product was TA-cloned into pCR2.1Topo (Invitrogen), producing pCRfdhA303. A promoterless, terminatorless neomycin resistance cassette was amplified from pRCN230 (pRCN115 [5] with the Pur cassette replaced by a Neo cassette [1]) by using primers NeoForCla and NeoRevNde and then were cloned into the ClaI and NdeI sites of pCRfdhA303. The resulting plasmid, pCRfdhA303neo, was used to transform LL as described below.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Primers used in this study
|
Allelic exchange was accomplished by transforming (20) LL with pCRfdh303neo or pBSfdh336-11pac and selecting on McC agar plates containing neomycin or puromycin, respectively, under 16 lb of H2:CO2/in2. PCR and Southern blots confirmed that the wild-type allele had been replaced by the disrupted allele in these mutants and that no vector sequences remained (data not shown). MM708 was then transformed with pBSfdh336-11pac to produce the double mutant MM709.
Growth curves. Overnight McC-H2:CO2-grown cultures were diluted 1:50 into duplicate tubes containing 5 ml of the appropriate fresh medium. Tubes were pressurized with H2:CO2 or N2:CO2 to 40 lb/in2. The optical density at 600 nm was determined immediately and at intervals throughout the growth curve. Readings were taken from duplicate cultures and were averaged.
Construction of lacZ reporter plasmids.
Various regions upstream of fdhA1, fdhC1, and fdhA2 (see Fig. 4) were PCR amplified and then were cloned into the SpeI and NsiI sites of pWLG40+lacZ (6) such that the ATG was fused in frame with the ATG of lacZ. Each construct used the native ribosome binding site present upstream of the respective gene. The primers used to construct each plasmid are shown in Table 1. Each plasmid was sequenced to confirm that no errors had been introduced by PCR and then were used to transform LL. Plasmid pWLG40+lacZ was used as a positive control because it contains the hmv promoter, which is constitutively expressed (6). Plasmid pWLG
hmv is identical to pWLG40+lacZ except that the DNA between the SpeI and NsiI sites was deleted, thus removing the hmv promoter; this plasmid served as a promoterless negative control.
![]() View larger version (30K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Regulation mediated by regions upstream of fdh genes. Strains containing plasmids with lacZ fused to the indicated upstream regions were grown on H2:CO2 or on formate. Numbers in parentheses indicate the number of base pairs upstream of the putative start codon. ß-Galactosidase activities are means ± standard deviations of duplicate measurements from a single culture after 9 h of growth on the indicated substrate. The medium used was McC plus Tris.
|
Sequence analysis and nucleotide sequence accession numbers. The genome sequence of M. maripaludis strain LL is an ongoing collaboration of J. A. Leigh with M. Olson (University of Washington Genome Center). M. maripaludis fdh sequences are deposited in GenBank (accession numbers AY236515 and AY236516).
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (28K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Growth of M. maripaludis LL on H2:CO2 or formate. Squares, H2:CO2; circles, H2:CO2 plus Tris plus formate; triangles, N2:CO2 plus Tris plus formate; diamonds, H2:CO2 plus Tris; asterisks, N2CO2 plus Tris. The medium used was McC. O.D. 600 nm, optical density at 600 nm.
|
subunit genes and found two separate gene clusters, which we named fdh1 and fdh2 (Fig. 2). We found no other formate dehydrogenases in the genome; distant homologs to FdhA appeared to be molybdopterin-containing proteins with different functions. The fdhA1 gene lay immediately upstream of an fdhB homolog, fdhB1. An fdhC homolog, encoding a putative formate transporter, was found upstream of fdhA1 separated by an open reading frame (ORF) of unknown function and a carbonic anhydrase homolog. In contrast, in M. formicicum (23) and M. thermoautotrophicus strain Z-245 (15) fdhC is immediately upstream of fdhA, and genes corresponding to the ORF of unknown function and the carbonic anhydrase homolog are not present. In addition, a small ORF of unknown function lay upstream of fdhC in M. maripaludis. The entire fdh1 cluster was preceded by a sensor histidine kinase homolog. The fdhA2 gene lay immediately upstream of an fdhB homolog (fdhB2); no fdhC homolog was found near fdhA2, nor was a carbonic anhydrase gene or a homolog of either unknown ORF present. The fdh2 cluster was preceded by dhyS encoding a homolog of deoxyhypusine synthase. The two fdh clusters of M. maripaludis encoded closely related proteins; FdhA1 and FdhA2 were 65% identical and FdhB1 and FdhB2 were 62% identical. Each gene was preceded by a sequence similar to that of a ribosome binding site (data not shown). Both fdhA alleles contained a TGA codon at amino acid 132 (fdhA1) or 133 (fdhA2) which presumably encodes a selenocysteine residue. The presence of selenocysteine is not uncommon in formate dehydrogenases (8, 10).
![]() View larger version (16K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. The fdh gene clusters of M. maripaludis LL. Intergenic distances are as follows (in base pairs, between genes): sensor histidine kinase-213-ORF-247-fdhC1-40-ORF-23-carbonic anhydrase-304-fdhA1-38-fdhB1; dhyS-639-fdhA2-23-fdhB2. Mutations constructed in fdhA1 and fdhA2 are shown. neo, neomycin resistance gene; pac, puromycin resistance gene; Pmcr and Tmcr, promoter and terminator derived from the M. voltae methylreductase gene (7).
|
Both fdhA genes contribute to growth on formate. The relative importance of the two fdh gene clusters in growth on formate was assessed by constructing mutants in either or both fdhA genes. Internal sections of each gene were deleted and replaced by neomycin or puromycin resistance markers (Fig. 2). The mutants were then analyzed for growth on formate, and their growth was compared to that of wild-type strain LL (Fig. 3). Mutants lacking either fdhA1 or fdhA2 showed a significant growth defect on formate. When both fdhA alleles were inactivated, M. maripaludis was completely unable to grow with formate as sole methanogenic substrate. All strains grew well on H2:CO2. The entire experiment was repeated, with similar results. These results suggest that both fdhA genes contribute to growth on formate as the methanogenic substrate.
![]() View larger version (30K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Growth of M. maripaludis fdh mutants on H2:CO2 (upper curves) or N2:CO2 plus formate (lower curves). Solid lines, LL; dashed lines, fdhA1 mutant; dashed and dotted lines, fdhA2 mutant; dotted lines, double mutant. Lines join readings that were taken every 1 to 2 h. Readings from duplicate cultures were averaged. The medium used was McC plus Tris. O.D. 600 nm, optical density at 600 nm.
|
Regulation of fdh expression.
We studied the expression of each fdh gene cluster by constructing a series of plasmid-encoded lacZ fusions to possible promoter region DNAs. Intergenic regions upstream of fdhC1, fdhA1, and fdhA2 were judged to be of sufficient length to contain possible promoter regions (see Fig. 2). Therefore, regions extending various distances upstream of fdhA1, fdhC1, and fdhA2 were PCR amplified and fused in frame with the ATG of lacZ on a low-copy replicative plasmid. Thus, each construct contained the native ribosome binding site and start codon fused to lacZ. The extent of each upstream region is shown in Fig. 4. M. maripaludis LL was transformed with these plasmids, and ß-galactosidase assays were done with McC medium with either H2:CO2 or formate (with N2:CO2) as methanogenic substrate. Controls included a plasmid (pWLG40+lacZ) in which lacZ is constitutively expressed (6) and a plasmid (pWLG
hmv) which lacks a promoter upstream of lacZ. As shown in Fig. 4, fusions to DNA immediately upstream of fdhA1 (pFL20 to pFL22) were not expressed on either substrate, suggesting that no promoter lies in this region. Fusions made to DNA upstream of fdhC1 (pFL30 to pFL33) had ß-galactosidase activity, suggesting that a promoter lies in this region. In all cases fdhC-lacZ expression was higher when cultures were grown on formate in the presence of N2:CO2 than when grown on H2:CO2. Plasmids pFL30 to pFL32, collectively containing DNA ranging up to 520 bp upstream of fdhC, gave similar results. In contrast, higher expression and greater regulation appeared to occur when DNA between 520 and 668 bp upstream of fdhC was included in the region fused to lacZ (pFL33). This result suggests that the regions between the start codon of fdhC and 520 bp and between 520 and 668 bp both contain separate sequences involved in the activation of fdhC expression with formate plus N2:CO2. Notably, 520 bp upstream of fdhC is only 30 bp upstream of a small ORF of unknown function (see Fig. 2). Therefore, activation involving the region upstream of 520 bp might be due not only to DNA that acts cis to fdhC but also to the expression of this ORF.
ß-Galactosidase fusions were also made by using DNA upstream of fdhA2 (pFL10 to pFL13, Fig. 4). No ß-galactosidase was expressed from plasmid pFL10, suggesting that no promoter is present in the 157 bp immediately upstream of the start codon of fdhA2. Fusions containing
362 bp of DNA were all expressed, indicating the presence of a promoter in this region. Likewise, all three fusions were upregulated two- to threefold in formate-containing medium with N2:CO2, suggesting the presence of a regulatory site.
A time course experiment was performed to extend the above observations. In all cases, enhancement of fdhC1 (Fig. 5A) and fdhA2 (Fig. 5B) expression in the presence of formate and N2:CO2 was observed starting 3 h after inoculation. As before, the highest expression of fdhC1 occurred only with pFL33, which contains 668 bp of upstream DNA. An increase in expression of both fdhC1 and fdhA2 was consistently seen after 9 h of growth on H2:CO2. One possible explanation is that H2:CO2 pressure was decreasing and that, as shown below, fdh expression is controlled by the presence of H2.
![]() View larger version (35K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Time course of fdh regulation. Strains containing plasmids as shown in Fig. 4 were grown with H2:CO2 and then were used to inoculate medium with H2:CO2 (open bars) or formate plus N2:CO2 (filled bars). The medium used was McC plus Tris.
|
![]() View larger version (32K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. Effects of H2 and formate on fdhC1 and fdhA2 regulation. LL containing pFL33 (A) or pFL13 (B) was grown under the following conditions: lanes A, H2:CO2; lanes B, H2:CO2 plus formate; lanes C, N2:CO2 plus formate; lanes D, H2:CO2 plus formate flushed with H2:CO2 at 6 h; lanes E, H2:CO2 plus formate flushed with N2:CO2 at 6 h. Grey bars, 6 h; black bars, 9 h. The medium used was McC plus Tris.
|
|
|
|---|
Maximum expression of both fdh clusters depended on the absence of H2 and not the presence of formate. This observation parallels that of Nolling and Reeve (15), who noted that in M. thermoformicicum Z-245, fdh expression was regulated by the availability of H2. Whether formate had any regulatory effect was not addressed in that study. In M. maripaludis, growth on H2 was superior to growth on formate (Fig. 1), and downregulation of fdh by H2 would be in accordance with the organism's tendency to grow on formate only when H2 is absent. However, why significant fdh expression still occurs when hydrogen is present is unknown; a biosynthetic function would be one explanation, but as stated above we were unable to find evidence to support this idea. Besides regulation by H2, fdh expression in M. formicicum is stimulated by molybdate (23), a phenomenon we did not investigate with M. maripaludis.
By fusing different segments of fdh promoter region DNA to lacZ we were able to localize the sites necessary for expression and regulation. In the case of fdh2 both expression and regulation were mediated by DNA between 157 and 362 bp upstream of the fdhA coding sequence. In the case of fdh1 transcription was initiated within 192 bp upstream of fdhC, and no transcription was initiated upstream of fdhA. These results are consistent with those of studies with M. formicicum (23) and M. thermoautorophicus strain Z-245 (15) which suggested that transcription occurred from a promoter upstream of fdhC with processing of some transcripts between fdhC and fdhA. Regulation of fdh1 appeared to be more complex than that of fdh2, being mediated partially by DNA within 192 bp of fdhC but with additional activation depending on DNA between 520 and 668 bp upstream of fdhC. Future experiments will characterize the regulatory roles of these upstream regions in more detail, including the possible function of the small ORF upstream of fdhC.
Present address: Department of Medicine, Division of Infectious Diseases, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98104. ![]()
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»