Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Bacteriology, September 2004, p. 6118-6123, Vol. 186, No. 18
0021-9193/04/$08.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JB.186.18.6118-6123.2004
Copyright © 2004, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Microbiology Division, School of Animal and Microbial Sciences, University of Reading, Reading, United Kingdom
Received 23 April 2004/ Accepted 22 June 2004
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
An interesting feature of the genetics of phosphonate metabolism in E. coli is that the B strain can use phosphonates whereas the K-12 strain is cryptic despite containing the entire phn gene cluster (21). The genetic basis for this crypticity was investigated by Makino et al. (14) and traced to an 8-bp insertion in the coding region of the phnE gene in the K-12 strain relative to the B strain, causing truncation of the phnE product. They also observed that the 8-bp sequence is one element in the direct triply repeated sequence in the K-12 strain comprising two types of octamer variants in the arrangement 5'-ABB-3', where A corresponds to the sequence 5'-CGCTGGCG-3' and B corresponds to the sequence 5'-TGCTGGCG-3' (Fig. 1). Makino et al. isolated variants of E. coli K-12 able to use MePn as the sole P source (Phn+), and these were found to have deletions of octamer B, which, they postulated, occurred via a strand slippage event during DNA replication (14). The nature of the variation in the phnE gene in E. coli is investigated in more detail in this work.
![]() View larger version (18K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Repetitive sequence in phnE of E. coli. The figure shows part of the phn gene cluster in E. coli and focuses on phnE and the location and sequences of a direct triple repeat in the K-12 strain and a direct double repeat in the B strain, where A corresponds to the octamer 5'-CGCTGGCG-3' and B corresponds to the octamer 5'-TGCTGGCG-3'. The relative positions of pairs of primer used in this work to amplify two different segments of phnE of E. coli K-12 are shown under the gene organization. Amplicon 1 was used in the study in the AFLP analysis, and amplicon 2 was used for gene sequencing.
|
|
|
|---|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. E. coli strains used
|
Molecular biology techniques. (i) Extraction of genomic DNA. Template DNAs for PCRs were extracted from cultures as follows. One-tenth milliliter of culture was diluted with 0.9 ml of sterile distilled water in a 1.5-ml microcentrifuge tube. The tube was boiled for 5 min and snap-chilled in ice. The boiled cell suspensions were diluted 100-fold in sterile water, and 5 µl was sufficient to set up PCRs.
(ii) AFLP analysis. Deletions or insertions in phnE were monitored by amplified-fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) analysis as follows. Fragments of phnE of 200 or 192 bp containing the triple or double octameric repeat regions, respectively, were amplified from samples of liquid cultures or colonies by PCR using oligonucleotide primer set 1 (Fig. 1), comprising EcphnEF2 (5'-Cy 5-TTACCAGCCCGTTCGCCGCC-3') and EcphnER2 (5'-CCTTCCACCGGGCCAGGTTCAAT-3'). Amplifications were carried out with Bio-X-Act DNA polymerase (Bioline UK Ltd.) with the following thermal cycle: 30 cycles of 95°C for 30 s, 60°C for 1 min, and 68°C for 1 min. Products were purified with a PCR fragment purification kit (QIAGEN) and checked by gel electrophoresis in a 1% Tris-acetate-EDTA-agarose gel. Fragments were diluted and run together with standard-size fragments (50-bp ladder; Amersham) on a 6%, wt/vol, polyacrylamide sequencing gel in an ALF-Express automated sequencer (Amersham Pharmacia), and the gel image was visualized with ALF-Express software. Fragments were detected, sized, and quantified with AllelLinks, version 1.00 (Amersham Pharmacia). The relative proportions of the two alleles of phnE were estimated from a standard curve prepared from AFLP analysis of different mixtures of the K-12 strain MC4100 and the B strain BL21(DE3), prepared by mixing individual cultures grown in LB prior to preparation of templates DNA.
DNA sequencing. To sequence the region of phnE containing the triply or doubly repeated region, a 600-bp fragment was amplified by PCR with oligonucleotide primer set 2 (Fig. 1), consisting of EcphnES1 (5'-GCGGATCCCGCAGCTG-3') and EcphnER (5'-ACGGTCGCCGAGCGGACGTT-3'). The amplification protocol used was that described for the AFLP analysis above. The DNA was purified with a QIAGEN PCR purification kit and then sequenced with an ALF-Express automated sequencer and a cycle sequencing strategy using Cy 5-labeled EcphnEF and EcphnER primers.
|
|
|---|
and MC4100, grown in LB, were estimated by determining the CFU appearing 10 days after plating washed populations at suitable dilutions on MNM-agarose containing MePn and comparing them to those appearing on MNM-agarose containing Pi or o-phospho-L-serine or no added P source, as a negative control. Phn+ variants were observed to be present at the surprisingly high levels of 3.4 and 8.6% of the total CFU of DH5
and MC4100, respectively, of those observed on the plates containing Pi or o-phospho-L-serine. Plates with no added P source contained only pinpoint colonies, presumably growing on traces of utilizable P in the medium.
AFLP analysis of genotypic events in E. coli K-12 Phn variants.
AFLP analysis was used to monitor the status of the phnE gene in different populations of strains. DNA fragments spanning that segment of the phnE gene in K-12 which contains the triple octameric repeat were amplified with primer set 1 (Fig. 1) from culture lysates of organisms grown in various media. When strains were grown in LB, as expected, a 200-bp fragment was amplified from the K-12 strain (DH5
) while a 192-bp fragment was amplified from the B strain [BL21(DE3)] (Fig. 2). When the analysis was performed on various mixtures of cultures of these two strains, both 200- and 192-bp fragments were amplified and the peak areas were approximately proportional to those for the prepared mixtures (Fig. 2). This establishes that AFLP can be used to detect both forms of phnE if present in populations. AFLP analysis was then used to examine phnE in cultures growing in MNM containing alternative P sources. Studies were performed on both MC4100 and DH5
. Results were essentially identical. Fragments of 200 bp were amplified only from cultures grown to stationary phase in MNM containing Pi and o-phospho-L-serine as the sole added P sources. However, populations of Phn+ variants which had grown to stationary phase in MNM with MePn as the sole added P source gave rise to two fragment types, the major species being 192 bp and the minor species being 200 bp. Therefore, stationary-phase populations of purified Phn+ variants unexpectedly contained a mixture of two phnE alleles, of which the major form probably contained the expected 8-bp deletion reported by Makino et al. (14). We extended these studies by examining the state of phnE in cultures in both logarithmic and stationary phases of growth with MePn as the sole P source. In the log-phase populations we could detect only fragments of 192 bp, but, in stationary-phase populations, both 192- and 200-bp fragments were detected (Fig. 3). This suggested that the deletion in phnE may be reversible and of high frequency and that it is potentially linked to later stages of the growth phase.
![]() View larger version (16K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. AFLP analysis of phnE in E. coli. Primer pair 1 (Fig. 1) was used to amplify a small fragment containing the octameric repetitive element in phnE from populations of two strains of E. coli grown to log phase in LB. PCR products were analyzed as described in Materials and Methods. Shown are fragments detected as peaks in the AFLP analysis. Tracks 1 and 5, PCR fragments produced from cultures of K-12 strain MC4100 and B strain BL21(DE3), respectively; tracks 2 to 4, artificial mixtures of MC4100 and BL21(DE3), each grown to an optical density at 600 nm of 0.7 and mixed prior to extraction of template and amplification in the ratios 9:1, 6:4, and 2:8; track M, 200-bp marker peak from the 50-bp standard ladder set used to determine fragment lengths.
|
![]() View larger version (12K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. AFLP analysis of phnE in cultures of E. coli K-12 MC4100 growing with different phosphonates. Cultures of K-12 MC4100 were grown in MNM with different phosphonates as sole P sources, which had been inoculated from Phn+ variants isolated and purified on MNM-agarose containing the respective phosphonate. PCR products were analyzed as described in Materials and Methods. Shown are fragments detected as peaks in the AFLP analysis. Tracks correspond to the phosphonates supporting growth as follows: 2, MePn, log phase; 3, MePn, stationary phase; 4, EPn, log phase; 5, AMPn, log phase; 6, 2-AEPn, log phase; 7, 3-APPn, log phase; M, 200-bp marker peak from the 50-bp standard ladder set used to determine fragment lengths.
|
![]() View larger version (18K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. AFLP analysis of phnE in cultures of E. coli K-12 MC4100 growing with different phosphonates. Shown is AFLP analysis of phnE at the stationary phase of successive subcultures of a Phn+ variant of E. coli K-12 MC4100 selected and purified on MNM-agarose. The inoculum level used for each round of subculture was 0.03%. The tracks show the fragments produced after amplification performed at the end of each subculture in the following succession of media: 1, MNM with MePn as the sole added P source; 2 to 4, LB. Tracks M, 200-bp marker peak from the 50-bp standard ladder set used to determine fragment lengths.
|
![]() View larger version (22K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Variation in the sequences of phnE genes in various isolates of E. coli. (Top) Sequences determined in this work for that part of phnE containing the octameric repetitive element for the following strains and conditions: MC4100/Pi, MC4100 grown in MNM with Pi as the sole added P source; MC4100/MePn, a Phn+ variant isolated and purified on MNM-agarose with MePn as the sole P source; MC4100/MePn LB, revertant obtained after successive subculture of a Phn+ variant in LB. Asterisks, positions of the direct repeat sequences. (Bottom) Sequences published for four strains of E. coli: K-12 and B (14), the enterohemorrhagic strain 0157:H7 (9, 16), and the uropathogenic strain CFT073 (22).
|
Phn+ variants obtained with different phosphonate sources. A requirement for the 8-bp deletion in phnE for utilization of other organophosphonates was also examined. In this experiment, Phn+ variants of MC4100 were isolated and purified on MNM-agarose with alternative phosphonates provided as sole P sources. AFLP analysis was performed on logarithmically growing populations with primer set 1. As with Phn+ variants selected and grown on MePn, fragments of 192 bp were amplified from all populations which grew well using EPn, AMPn, 2-AEPn, and 3-APPn as P sources (Fig. 3). Also, as with Phn+ variants selected on MePn, all these variants gave rise to mixtures of 192- and 200-bp fragments in stationary phase (data not shown). Very slow growth was observed with PhPn and PPn. In the PhPn cultures, a 200-bp fragment was the sole fragment amplified, but in the PPn-grown organisms traces of the 192-bp forms were detected. No significant growth was observed with the following phosphonates: N-butanephosphonate, tert-buty phosphonate, 1-AEPn, 1-EPn, 1-APPn, phosphonoacetate, phosphonoformate, and phosphonomycin.
Properties and behavior of the phnE gene in non K-12 E. coli strains. Eleven strains of E. coli originally isolated from raw water or sewerage sludge on nutrient broth or LB were screened for potential crypticity in phosphonate metabolism and for the occurrence of the triple-repeat sequences in phnE. Their ability to use MePn as a sole P source on MNM was tested as for the K-12 strains previously. Of 11 independent isolates, four strains, 1, 8, A3, and D7, gave plating efficiencies significantly below 100% (at 5.7, 39, 35, and 1.3%, respectively) on MePn compared to the controls supplied with Pi. This suggested that these strains may be cryptic and may contain an inactivated phnE gene similar to that observed in K-12 strains. Therefore we determined the nucleotide sequences of the 600-bp fragments of the phnE genes surrounding the octameric repeats amplified from cultures not exposed to added phosphonates (Fig. 5). However, although a few base substitutions affecting only the third base coding positions were observed in the different phnE sequences, all strains contained the double octameric repeat sequence in phnE, as found in the B strain (data not shown).
|
|
|---|
102 per generation in either direction but that the equilibrium of the switch strongly favors the "off" form unless selection for phosphonate utilization is applied. The octameric sequence involved in this postulated slip strand event is, at 8 bp, relatively long, and interestingly it is the most commonly occurring octamer in the genome of E. coli K-12 (2). It also contains the core trimer 5'-CTG-3', thought to be the DnaG primase binding site (11, 18, 23, 24). The apparent high instability in phnE in K-12 may be linked to the potential involvement of this octamer in the initiation of DNA replication.
Mutations in DNA replication, repair, and recombination influence instability in tandem repeat sequences (3, 12, 17). All the K-12 mutants examined prior to selection for MePn utilization exhibited the typical K-12 5'-ABB-3' or "off" form of phnE even though some carry mutations in functions known to increase deletions between repetitive sequences, including mutations in recA and the sbcB-encoded 3' exonuclease I and the dnaQ49ts mutation, which affects DNA polymerase
-subunit exonuclease activity and the physical interaction of the
-subunit with the polymerizing
-subunit.
The physiological significance of the switch in E. coli K-12 remains unclear. In the "on" direction, the switch allows E. coli K-12 to use not only MePn but also EPn, AMPn, 2-AEPn, and 3-APPn; hence phnE is implicated in transport of all these organophosphonates. Elashvili et al. (6) have shown that the phnE gene is necessary for uptake of some organophosphates since the 8-bp deletion event in phnE enabled the E. coli K-12 strain JA221 to utilize diisopropyl fluorophosphate and its hydrolysis product, diisopropyl phosphate.
Surprisingly, the phnE switch appears to be confined to K-12 strains. E. coli strains for which genomes have been determined appear to contain the "on" form of phnE, including the uropathogenic strain CFT073 (22), where the 5'-AB-3' repeat is perfectly conserved, and the enterohemorrhagic strain O157:H7 (9, 16), although here T substitutes for C at the seventh base in octamer A in the 5'-AB-3' sequence (Fig. 5). We also found no evidence for the presence of the "off" form of phnE in several E. coli strains isolated recently from environmental samples.
Although the phnE switch may be an artifact possibly arising from the repeated mutagenesis to which the K-12 strain has been subjected, it is possible that it might protect against the uptake of naturally occurring inhibitory phosphonates present in the natural environment or in some way affect surface receptors required for coliphage or lymphocyte recognition.
We thank Elizabeth Pontin and Mike Taylor for running the sequencer and help with the analysis software packages. We also most grateful for the provision of strains to Malgorzata Bzymek, Susan Lovett, Roel Schaaper, and Robert Wells and the E. coli Genetic Stock Center at Yale University.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»