Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Bacteriology, November 2004, p. 7670-7679, Vol. 186, No. 22
0021-9193/04/$08.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/JB.186.22.7670-7679.2004
Copyright © 2004, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Department of Microbiology and Immunology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan
Received 14 May 2004/ Accepted 11 August 2004
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
, 933W has three operator repeats in the right operator region (OR), but unlike
and all other studied lambdoid phages, which have three operator repeats in the left operator region (OL), 933W only has two operator repeats in OL. As was observed with
, the 933W OR and OL regions regulate transcription from the early PR and PL promoters, respectively. A lysogen carrying a 933W derivative encoding a noncleavable repressor fails to produce Stx, unlike a lysogen carrying a 933W derivative encoding a cleavable repressor. This finding provides direct evidence that measurable expression of the stx genes encoded by a 933W prophage requires induction of that prophage with the concomitant initiation of phage gene expression. | INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In most identified STEC strains, the toxin genes, stxAB, are located in the genomes of prophages that resemble the coliphage
(7, 22, 24, 27, 40, 58). Lambdoid phages share similar genome organization and schemes of transcription control (3, 20). The
prophage remains in a quiescent state due to binding of the cI-encoded repressor protein to the right and left operator sites, in this way inhibiting transcription from the phage early promoters PR and PL, respectively (47). Prophage induction, which leads to lytic growth, results from removal of repression. This event occurs primarily through RecA-mediated repressor autocleavage following activation of the bacterial SOS response by a DNA-damaging agent (32). During lytic growth, transcription from the early PR promoter modified through the action of the phage-encoded N protein transcends a number of terminators, resulting in expression of the Q protein (reviewed in reference 14). Q, in turn, modifies transcription initiating at the late PR' promoter, which, as shown for
, results in synthesis of a
26-kb mRNA that encodes all late functions (52). The location of the stx genes, downstream of PR' and upstream of the lysis cassette, is conserved among most identified Stx-encoding prophages (27, 37, 43, 51, 58) (see Fig. 1A). Thus, prophage induction ultimately results in Q-modified transcription initiating at PR' that transcends the tR' terminator, leading to expression of downstream genes that include stx and those encoding lysis functions. No obvious mode of release of Stx by the intact bacterium has been identified (38). However, it has been suggested, with some corroborating evidence, that phage-mediated lysis provides the route for Stx release (36, 60). Studies with an stx2-encoding phage provide compelling evidence that Stx production and release can occur primarily from a small fraction of a STEC population that undergoes prophage induction (60). At least in that case, the repressor-operator interactions must play a major role in the process of Stx production and release.
|
primarily by the work of Ptashne and his many collaborators (45). The
cI-encoded repressor binds as a dimer to the operator repeats but not with equal affinities (reviewed in reference 29). The CI dimers cooperatively bind to OR1 and OR2 to form a tetramer, repressing PR, and OL1 and OL2 to form a tetramer, repressing PL (see Fig. 1). Moreover, recent studies have shown that interaction of the tetramers bound at OL with those bound at OR further stabilizes repressor binding (8, 49). However, there are variations in the arrangement of operator repeats in other lambdoid phages (4). For example, phage H-19B, carrying stx1, possesses four operator sites in OR (55). In addition, analyses of repressor interactions with OR suggest that H-19B repressor binding may differ from that observed in
(55). Studies conducted with a genetic tool designed to identify lysogens in which prophages spontaneously induce indicate that H-19B and 933W induce more readily than lambdoid phages that do not encode Stx (33). The apparent central role of the repressor-operator interaction in Stx expression by phages carrying stx2 led us to investigate the repressor-operator region of phage 933W, which carries stx2, and directly assess its role in regulating Stx expression. | MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
imm933W lysogens were constructed essentially by procedures developed for
(17).
(ii) Isolation of
imm933Wvir.
A
250-bp DNA fragment containing the putative OR region of 933W was mutagenized using the Mn-dITP PCR method (63). The primers used in PCR amplification were 5'-GGCTATAGCCATTCCCCTAC-3' and 5'-CGCTAACTCCACAAGCCTTC-3'. Isolated PCR products were electroporated into competent cells (64) of K9838, a contiguous dilysogen with the hybrid prophage
imm933W and a defective
cI857 prophage. In addition, K9838 carries a plasmid that constitutively expresses the N protein of H-19B, which is functionally the same as N of 933W (33). The defective prophage encodes the thermally sensitive
CI857 repressor, the
Red recombination functions, and the
Xis and Int proteins (64). The Xis and Int proteins act to excise the
imm933W prophage from the bacterial chromosome (18). Following electroporation, the culture was incubated at 32°C in 1 ml of LB for approximately 1.5 h. The culture was diluted to 10 ml and incubated overnight at 39°C. Incubation at the high temperature allows for constitutive expression from the defective prophage of both the Red recombination and Int and Xis excision functions. This resulted in recombination of the electroporated DNA with the
imm933W prophage and excision of the prophage from the bacterial chromosome.
Partially virulent phages, with mutations in OR that reduce repressor binding, were isolated from the lysate as plaque formers on a lawn formed by K9835, a
imm933W lysogen that also carries a plasmid that constitutively expresses the N protein. Lysates of
imm933W partial vir mutants, confirmed by their ability to grow on lawns formed by K9835 and K37, but not K9680 (a
imm933W lysogen), were then made from single plaques. Spontaneous fully virulent mutants were selected from lysates of partially virulent mutants as plaque formers on lawns of K9680.
(iii) Construction of
imm933Wvir with targeted mutations in OR.
Partially virulent
imm933W mutants with a designed mutation in OR2 were constructed using the
Red system to cross the mutation from a synthesized single-stranded oligonucleotide (10) into the
imm933W prophage in K9838. This procedure was conducted essentially as described above for the isolation of
imm933W partial vir mutants. The sequence of the oligonucleotide was 5'-CATGAGTACGATACTAAAGCACTTGCAAAAACTTT-CAGTACAACCATAA-3'. Spontaneous fully virulent mutants were selected from partially virulent mutant lysates as plaque formers on lawns of K9680.
(iv) Construction of 933WcI(Ind).
A 933W prophage with an ind mutation was constructed using the mini-
red recombination system (6, 30). Based on previous studies with other SOS-inducible repressors (56), Lys codon 178 was changed from AAG to an Asn codon, AAC, in strain K10575, a 933W lysogen. The single-stranded DNA oligonucleotide 5'-ATGATCCAGATGCCTTTGGTCTTCGTGTGAAAGGAGACGCAATGTGGCCCAGAATAAAATCAGGAGAATATGTACTC-3', containing the nucleotide substitution, was used to generate this codon change. Lysogens containing the Lys-to-Asn codon change in the 933W cI gene were identified by the mismatch amplification mutation assay PCR technique (5) using primers that yield a product only if the DNA contains the specified codon change. The strain with the wild-type cI and the strain with the Lys-to-Asn codon change in cI were cured of their mini-
by a heat pulse at 42°C (6), generating strains K10599 and K10595, respectively.
(v) Construction of
imm933WcI(Ind).
A
imm933WcIind hybrid phage was constructed by crossing the cI(Ind) allele from the prophage in K10595 to an infecting
cI857Kan phage (obtained from Ry Young). Following the infection, recombinants with 933W immunity were obtained as plaque formers on a lawn formed by K124 (a
lysogen). The centers of turbid plaques were picked and streaked on an LB-plus-kanamycin plate for colonies. Putative lysogens were shown to have 933W immunity and to be refractory to mitomycin C treatment. The K37 derivative containing the
imm933WcI(Ind) Kanr prophage was designated K10693.
(vi) Construction of
imm933WcI(Ind) ts.
The starting strain used in the isolation of the cI temperature-sensitive (ts) mutation, K10710, is a derivative of K37 that is resistant to
and has the mutS::amp allele (13) and a
imm933WcI(Ind) Kanr prophage. The mutS allele was included to increase the mutation rate, and
resistance was included to eliminate reinfection by released phage. The Ind mutation largely eliminates spontaneous induction of the prophage. K10710 was grown in LB to mid-log phase, and bacteria were sedimented, resuspended in an equal volume of LB, and incubated at 42°C with shaking for 4 h. The bacteria were treated with CHCl3 and sedimented. The supernatant was plated on a K37 lawn and incubated overnight at 32°C for plaques. The centers of turbid plaques were picked for colonies by streaking onto LB-plus-kanamycin plates, which were incubated at either 32 or 42°C. Two of five tested colonies grew at 32°C and not at 42°C. Further testing showed that the prophages in these bacteria were induced at high temperature. DNA sequencing identified a codon change, causing a Thr-to-Ile change, at codon 170 as well as the Ind mutation at codon 178. The K37 lysogen with the
imm933WcI(Ind) ts prophage was designated K10717.
Construction of a plasmid with the cI gene. The 933W cI gene was PCR amplified from strain K9675 using primers 5'-CCATGGTTCAGAATGAAAAAGTGC-3' and 5'-CTCGAGCGAACTTTTCAG-CCACTCCCT-3'. The isolated PCR product was digested with NcoI and XhoI and inserted into the pET-33b(+) vector (Novagen) downstream of the T7 promoter by using the appropriate sites, yielding a fusion of the cI gene in frame with the coding sequence for a His6 tag. DNA sequencing confirmed the integrity of the insert. The constructed vector was then transformed into BL21(DE3), generating strain K10786. In vivo tests showed that the C-terminal His tag has no effect on immunity to superinfection.
Purification of rCI protein. Recombinant CI (rCI) repressor protein fused to a His6 tag at its carboxy terminus was isolated from a culture of strain K10786 by using the Qiagen (Valencia, Calif.) protocol for isolating His6-tagged proteins under native conditions.
Gel mobility shift assays.
Radioactive DNA probes for OR and OL were generated by labeling the 5' end of the sense primer with [
-32P]ATP and subjecting the respective probe to PCR amplification with an unlabeled antisense primer, using DNA from a vir phage lysate or strain K9675 as the template (55). The primers used in the PCR amplification of the
250-bp OR probe are the same as those used for the mutagenesis of OR in the isolation of vir mutants. The primers used in the PCR amplification of the
220-bp OL probe were 5'-CATAAGCCCTTCTGATGACAA-3' and 5'-ATAGACCTCCTG-ATCAACTTT-3'. The PCR products were isolated by ethanol precipitation (54). Gel mobility shift assays (55) were performed using increasing concentrations of purified rCI.
Isolation of RNA.
RNA used in the identification of the 933W PR and PL promoters was purified from extracts derived from infection of K37 with
imm933W (55). RNA used in the identification of the 933W PRM promoter was isolated from a culture of K9675 grown to mid-log phase. RNA was extracted by the Trizol method (65).
Primer extension analyses.
The 933W PR, PL, and PRM promoters were identified by primer extension analyses (65). The primers used to PCR amplify the
250-bp DNA fragment generated as the template for the sequencing reactions used in the identification of PR were 5'-ACAAGCCTTCGCA-ACTTCAG-3' and 5'-CGCTAACTCCACAAGCCTTC-3'. The former primer was then used for the sequencing reactions and amplification of cDNA. The primers used to PCR amplify the
240-bp DNA fragment generated as the template for the sequencing reactions used in the identification of PL were 5'-CTTTGTCAGCGCCGTAGATTC-3' and 5'-TG-TAACTCGCTAAACCATGC-3'. The former primer was then used for the sequencing reactions and amplification of cDNA. The primers used to PCR amplify the
190-bp DNA fragment generated as template for the sequencing reactions used in the identification of PRM were 5'-TGCGCTAGCCGCTGGGCGAA-3' and 5'-ACAAGC-CTTCGCAACTT-CAG-3'. The former primer was then used for the sequencing reactions and amplification of cDNA. DNA sequencing was conducted using the Thermosequenase kit (USB) with an [
-33P]dNTP mixture (Amersham).
Toxin assay. Soluble protein was obtained from cultures of K10595 and K10599 and subsequently analyzed for Stx2 levels by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) (59).
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
operators (reviewed in references 19 and 47), we used mutations to demonstrate that these putative operator repeats function as repressor-binding sites in vivo. Virulent (vir) phage mutants grow in the presence of their cognate repressor because of nucleotide changes in their operators that significantly lower the affinity of the repressor for the operators, permitting transcription from the associated promoters in the presence of repressor. The classical
vir mutants were selected as variants that form plaques on a lawn formed by a
lysogen (23). Later studies demonstrated that two mutations in OR and one mutation in OL, or one mutation in OR and two mutations in OL, are necessary and sufficient for
virulence (12).
To isolate virulent mutants in 933W, a hybrid phage was constructed between
and 933W, designated
imm933W. This construction was required because phage 933W is not stable in lysates, probably because of its large genome (41, 43).
imm933W was useful for these experiments because it has the operators, cI gene, and immediately surrounding regions from 933W, while the rest of the genome derived from
. Hence, the genome size is close to that of
, resulting in a more stable phage particle. Additionally,
imm933W has the att site of
, permitting
functions to excise the prophage from the E. coli chromosome (see below). PCR analysis showed that
imm933W contains a portion of the 933W genome extending from the N gene to the genes encoding replication functions (unpublished data).
Virulent mutants of
imm933W were generated in a two-step process. In planning the first step, we assumed that early-gene expression in phage 933W is analogous to that observed in
. The N protein is the only gene product required for lytic growth encoded in the
PL operon (reviewed in reference 15). We assumed that the same is true for 933W. Accordingly, a
imm933W mutant with base changes in OR, decreasing repressor affinity and permitting transcription from PR in the presence of repressor, should be able to grow lytically in a 933W lysogen when the N protein is supplied in trans. Therefore, for the first step in isolating
imm933Wvir mutants, DNA fragments containing the putative OR region that were synthesized under error-prone conditions were introduced into the
imm933W lysogen by electroporation. The recipient lysogen, K9838, has two contiguous prophages,
imm933W, the phage to be made virulent, and a defective
cI857, the supplier of recombination functions (64). In addition, the N protein (functional for 933W) was constitutively expressed from a plasmid, eliminating the need for a mutation(s) in OL, to allow
imm933W, containing mutations in OR, to grow in the presence of repressor. Recombinant phages with mutations in OR that reduce repressor binding sufficiently to allow for growth in the presence of repressor, referred to as partially vir mutants, were selected for their ability to form plaques on a lawn formed by K9835, a
imm933W lysogen carrying a plasmid that constitutively expresses an N protein that functions with 933W. However, because they have an intact OL, these partial vir mutants do not grow in a
imm933W lysogen, K9680, in which N is not supplied in trans. In the second step, fully virulent derivatives were isolated from partially virulent mutants by selecting spontaneous OL mutants as plaque formers on a lawn formed by a
imm933W lysogen (strain K9680).
DNA sequencing showed that the two
imm933Wvir mutants we isolated in independent experiments have three mutations in OR, located in OR2 and OR1, in combination with one mutation in OL, in either OL1 or OL2. The
imm933Wvir mutants isolated and the mutations in their operator regions are listed in Table 2 and illustrated in Fig. 1B. Both
imm933Wvir mutants contain changes in bp -3 of OR2 (Table 2; Fig. 1B). To determine if mutation of this position, when combined with a mutation in OL, is sufficient to confer virulence in
imm933W, we constructed a
imm933W partially vir mutant with a TA-to-AT change at bp -3 of OR2. This mutation was made using a single-stranded DNA oligonucleotide containing the base change (see Materials and Methods). The partially vir recombinant and the subsequent fully vir mutant containing this base change were isolated by using essentially the same steps used to generate the original
imm933Wvir mutants. The fully vir mutant containing the TA-to-AT bp change,
imm933WvirT-3A, in addition to a mutation in OL, has added mutations in both OR1 and OR2 (Table 2; Fig. 1B) that were not in the DNA oligonucleotide used in constructing the mutant. Therefore, we cannot determine if mutation of bp -3 in OR2, in combination with a mutation in OL, is sufficient to confer virulence. Despite several attempts by both direct and random mutagenesis, we never obtained
imm933Wvir mutants with fewer than three mutations in OR (data not shown).
|
imm933W virulence. It should be noted that the selection we used to isolate
imm933Wvir mutants differs from the way in which the classical
vir mutants were obtained (23). This may explain why the virulent mutants we obtained had more mutations in OR. The same selection strategy used here, however, was used in the isolation of H-19B virulent mutants, and those mutants had only one mutation in OR (55). Nonetheless, we emphasize that the results of our study do not rule out the possibility that fewer than three mutations in OR, with a mutation in OL, are necessary for virulence in 933W.
In vitro binding assays with repressor protein.
To confirm that the regions identified by sequence analyses and mutagenesis bind repressor in vitro, gel mobility shift assays were conducted with a recombinant form of the 933W CI protein (rCI). This protein, purified to near homogeneity (data not shown), contains a His6 tag at its carboxy terminus. The rCI protein is functional since an E. coli derivative, K10786, in which the rCI protein is expressed from a plasmid, is specifically immune to infection with either 933W or
imm933W (data not shown). Hence, the His tag does not interfere with the biological activity of this repressor protein under these conditions.
To examine repressor interactions with the OR repeats, gel mobility shift assays were conducted with increasing concentrations of rCI protein incubated with a
250-bp radiolabeled DNA probe that included the wild-type OR repeats. Three band shifts were observed when the OR probe was incubated with increasing concentrations of rCI (Fig. 2, lanes 1 to 8). These results suggest that there are three repressor-binding repeats in the right operator region. Whereas the first shift of the OR DNA probe occurred with an rCI concentration of
0.8 nM (Fig. 2, lane 2), the second shift of the probe required ca. fourfold more protein (
3.4 nM) (lane 4). Incubation of the DNA probe with the same rCI concentration (
3.4 nM) resulted in incomplete shifting to the third position (lane 4). A nearly complete shift of the DNA probe to the third position was evident when the probe was incubated with
13.4 nM rCI (lane 6), and complete shifting of the probe was observed with
53.7 nM rCI (lane 8).
|
imm933Wvir-6 mutant (Fig. 1B; Table 2). This decrease in rCI affinity for this probe is particularly noticeable in the second and third shifts of the probe containing the mutant sequence (Fig. 2, lanes 9 to 16). In comparison to the binding efficiencies evident when rCI was incubated with the probe containing the wild-type sequence, ca. fourfold more protein (
13.4 nM) was required to shift the probe with the mutant sequence to the second position (lane 14). Whereas
53.7 nM rCI was sufficient to shift all of the bound probe with wild-type sequences, the same concentration of rCI did not shift the probe with mutant sequences to the third position (lanes 8 and 16).
To examine repressor interactions with the OL repeats, gel mobility shift assays were conducted with rCI protein and a
220-bp radiolabeled DNA probe that included the wild-type OL repeats. Two band shifts were observed when rCI was incubated with the OL probe (Fig. 3, lanes 1 to 8). This result is consistent with the presence of two repressor-binding repeats in the left operator region rather than the three found in the OL of
and other lambdoid phages (45). The first shift was observed with
0.8 nM rCI (Fig. 3, lane 2). The second shift was detected when the DNA probe was incubated with
6.7 nM rCI (lane 5). These findings agree with those of Koudelka et al. (28), who also found that there are two repressor-binding sites in OL by gel shift analyses and DNase I footprinting.
|
imm933Wvir-6 OL region (Table 2; Fig. 1B) failed to result in two shifts of the probe at the same concentrations of protein required for shifting of the probe with wild-type OL sequences (Fig. 3, lanes 9 to 16). Whereas the bound DNA probe containing wild-type sequence was entirely shifted at rCI protein concentrations between
13.4 and
26.9 nM (lanes 6 and 7), the DNA probe containing the mutant sequence was not entirely shifted with
53.7 nM rCI (lane 16). These results show that, as with the mutant OR probe, rCI has decreased affinity for the OL probe containing the mutations present in OL of
imm933Wvir-6.
Identification of PR, PL, and PRM.
Evidence for the location of the 933W early promoters PR and PL was obtained by using primer extension to identify likely transcription start sites. RNAs used to identify the PL and PR transcription start sites were isolated from E. coli strain K37 infected with phage
imm933W. Based on the identification of a putative start site for the PR transcript (Fig. 4A), 10 and 35 sequences were assigned by comparing the upstream sequences to E. coli consensus promoter sequences (53) (Fig. 1B). As predicted by sequence analysis (43), we found that the 933W PR promoter spans all of OR2 and overlaps the left end of OR1 by 1 nucleotide (Fig. 1B). Based on the identification of a putative start site for the PL transcript (Fig. 4B), the 10 and 35 sequences were assigned according to promoter consensus sequences (53) (Fig. 1B). The putative 933W PL promoter elements overlap the two operator repeats in the OL region (Fig. 1B). In
, binding of repressor to
OL1 and
OL2 is sufficient to repress PL. In 933W, the position of the PL promoter elements, relative to OL1 and OL2 (Fig. 1B), indicates that repression of PL is achieved much the same way as it is in
.
|
and HK022 initiate at the A of the AUG start codon of cI (2, 46). If the same is true for 933W, then transcription probably starts at the A residue, which is the A of the AUG start codon of cI in this case as well, at a greater frequency. As predicted by sequence analysis (43), we found that the 933W PRM 35 sequence overlaps OR2 and the 10 sequence flanks the right end of OR3 (Fig. 1B).
Construction of noninducible 933W and
imm933W prophages.
To extend our studies of the repressor control of 933W Stx expression, we constructed a derivative of 933W with a mutation in the cI gene that presumably blocks autocleavage of the repressor protein. The repressor proteins of lambdoid phages, as well as other autocleavable proteins, consist of an amino-terminal DNA-binding domain and a carboxy-terminal dimerization domain, connected by a linker called the hinge region (45). Little and colleagues showed for the
and LexA repressors that RecA-mediated autocleavage occurs when a conserved Ala-Gly bond, positioned in the hinge region of the protein, is hydrolyzed by a nucleophilic attack of a conserved Ser-Lys catalytic dyad (56). Mutations changing either the conserved Ser or Lys residues in the
repressor protein abrogate this autocleavage mechanism (31). The analogous Ser and Lys codons were identified in the 933W cI gene (J. W. Little, personal communication), and this information was used to construct a noninducible 933W prophage; Lys codon 178 of the 933W cI gene was changed to an Asn codon.
K10595, a lysogen with a 933W prophage that encodes a CI protein with the K178N change, produced very few infectious virions even when grown in the presence of the inducing agent mitomycin C (data not shown). Furthermore, spontaneous release of phage from K10693, a lysogen containing the hybrid phage
imm933W with the K178N cI mutation, was extremely low, less than 2.4 x 107 per lysogen. This was significantly lower than the spontaneous release observed with the lysogen carrying the wild-type isogenic
imm933W prophage, 2.7 x 103 per lysogen. Hence, the cI K178N mutant allele has the characteristics of a classic Ind mutation and the prophages with the cIK178N change were designated
imm933WcI(Ind) and 933WcI(Ind). The few phages released from the
imm933WcI(Ind) lysogen have spontaneous mutations that appear by plaque morphology to inactivate the repressor (data not shown).
Assessing the role of CI autocleavage on Stx production.
To assess the role of prophage induction in the production of Stx2 by a 933W lysogen, we compared toxin levels produced by strains K10599 and K10595, containing the wild-type or the cI(Ind) 933W prophages, respectively, cultured in the presence or absence of mitomycin C. The essential idea underlying this approach is that if Stx expression depends on induction of the 933W prophage, then a lysogen with a 933WcI(Ind) prophage should produce extremely low levels of Stx. An ELISA using anti-Stx2 antiserum was used to measure Stx levels. The levels of Stx2 in total protein obtained from sonicated cells and culture supernatant from a culture of K10595, the strain with the 933WcI(Ind) prophage, were negligible when cultured in the presence or absence of the inducing agent mitomycin C (Fig. 5). In contrast, K10599, the strain with the 933W wild-type prophage, produced
25 to 35 ng of Stx per ml when bacteria were cultured in the absence of an inducing agent (Fig. 5B). The Stx levels increased by more than two orders of magnitude when K10599 was cultured in the presence of mitomycin C (Fig. 5A). These data demonstrate that production of Stx2 requires transcription initiating at the repressor-regulated phage early promoters. Removal of repression allows entry into lytic growth, a process abrogated by the K178N mutation in the 933W cI gene, which presumably results in a protein resistant to autocleavage. By showing that an Ind mutation in the cI gene eliminates Stx production, these results provide the most direct evidence that prophage induction is required for toxin production by 933W lysogens (16, 60).
|
Use of the cI(Ind) mutant specifically enabled us to circumvent a major problem in isolating a cIts derivative of 933W. The background of phage released by a wild-type lysogen is quite high, making it difficult to isolate cIts derivatives from a lysogen carrying a prophage with a wild-type cI gene by mutagenesis and subsequent shift to high temperature. Because a prophage with a cI(Ind) allele has such a low background of phage release, it can be used to search directly for ts mutants. We used the
imm933WcI(Ind) Kanr hybrid phage as the progenitor in the search for a cIts mutation because the hybrid phage is far more stable than 933W. Details of the isolation of the temperature-inducible prophage, designated
imm933WcI(Ind) ts, are outlined in Materials and Methods. DNA sequence analysis showed that this mutant had a single nucleotide change, in addition to the ind change, in the cI gene, encoding a Thr-to-Ile substitution at codon 169. As shown in Fig. 6, when a lysogen carrying the
imm933WcI(Ind) ts prophage was grown at 32°C and then shifted to 42°C, the culture was lysed. The control lysogen carrying the
imm933WcIind prophage does not show any lysis following the temperature shift.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Previous studies have led to the idea that there is a relationship between prophage induction and Stx expression in the case of the stx2 phages 933W and
361 (16, 60). Although there is a promoter associated with the stx2 genes, transcription of these genes occurs primarily from Q-modified transcription initiating at the upstream phage late promoter PR' (60). Q modification is required for transcription to transcend terminators located between PR' and the stx genes (Fig. 1A). Q expression, in turn, requires transcription initiating at the early PR promoter. Since PR is under CI repressor control, expression of Q and, in turn, Stx from the prophage requires induction. Because loss of repression leads to prophage replication, induction also leads to a significant increase in the copy number of the stx genes. Hence, the repressor-operator interactions of these phages serve as primary regulators of Stx2 expression.
In this paper we report the isolation of three virulent (vir) mutants of
imm933W. These are designated vir because, even though they have the operator/promoter region (immunity region) of 933W, they can grow lytically in a 933W lysogen. Each of these mutants was shown to have base changes in its putative operator regions (Table 2). Moreover, by gel shift analyses we observed that purified repressor, rCI, exhibits decreased affinity for a DNA probe containing operator sequences matching that of a vir mutant,
imm933Wvir-6, relative to its affinity for a DNA probe containing wild-type operator sequences (Fig. 2 and 3). Thus, we can assume that in vivo
imm933Wvir mutants can grow in the presence of repressor because their operators contain base changes that lower the affinity of repressor binding, permitting expression from the early promoters PR and PL, which drive lytic growth. These results provide definitive evidence that the putative operators identified by sequence analyses (11, 43) are the sites required for repression of phage 933W.
Unlike the classical
vir mutant (21), which has two mutations in OR, the
imm933Wvir mutants we isolated have three mutations in OR, but like the classical
vir mutant, they have one mutation in OL. To assess the possibility that three mutations in 933W OR are required for virulence, we constructed a partially virulent mutant by site-directed mutagenesis. This mutant was then used to isolate a spontaneous fully virulent mutant. To generate the mutation, we employed a template that had the OR2 bp-3 mutation, the mutation shared by two isolated
imm933Wvir mutants. Again, when a fully virulent mutant was obtained, in addition to a mutation in OL, three mutations were identified in OR. These results suggest that virulence in 933W may differ from that seen with other lambdoid phages, which have either one or two mutations in OR. Like
, P22 and HK022 require two mutations in OR for virulence (4, 44). In contrast, phages H-19B, 434, and 21 require only one mutation in OR for virulence (44, 55, 61).
Gel shift analyses conducted with purified 933W repressor, rCI, and a DNA probe with the sequence of the OR region were consistent with the existence of three binding repeats in the 933W OR (Fig. 2), as predicted by sequence analyses (43). It has been observed that in
, binding of the repressor to
OR2 is nearly concurrent with binding of repressor to
OR1, due to cooperative interactions between the protein dimers bound to the two sites (45). We observed that ca. fourfold more rCI is required to shift the probe containing the 933W OR region to the second position (Fig. 2). Assuming that the first shift results from rCI binding to OR1 and the second shift results from rCI binding to both OR1 and OR2, it appears that binding of repressor to these sites may not be influenced by cooperativity, at least not under these in vitro conditions. In contrast, the rCI levels required to shift the probe to the third position in gel mobility shift assays were not significantly greater than the levels of rCI sufficient to shift the probe to the second position. A more detailed discussion of rCI binding to the OR repeats is included in reference 28.
Gel shift analyses using rCI incubated with a DNA probe with the sequence of the OL region indicate that there are only two repressor-binding sites in OL (Fig. 3). Our results are qualitatively consistent with those of Koudelka et al. (28), who used gel shift analyses and DNase I footprinting to examine repressor binding to OL. They detected repressor binding to only two sites in OL as well. Bacteriophage 933W is the only phage in the lambdoid family, of which we are aware, that contains only two repressor-binding repeats in OL.
We note that although the results of our gel mobility shift assays are qualitatively similar to the findings of Koudelka et al. (28), approximately 10-fold more rCI protein was required to shift the DNA probes in our assays (Fig. 2 and 3) (see the accompanying paper [28]). We offer three possible ways in which these quantitative differences can be explained. First, inefficient radiolabeling of our DNA probes might have resulted in an excess of unlabeled DNA probes that competed with radiolabeled DNA for binding with rCI, thus requiring more rCI to shift the radiolabeled probe. Second, since the rCI protein concentration reflects total protein, both active and inactive, it is possible that the percentage of active protein in our rCI preparation was lower than that of inactive protein. This would result in more total protein required to shift the DNA probes. Finally, the difference could be due to our use of a His6-tagged protein while Koudelka et al. (28) used the natural protein. Although the C-terminal His6 tag does not qualitatively affect repressor activity, it may quantitatively influence the binding activity of rCI.
A role for the third binding repeat in the
OL region was identified by Dodd et al. (8). They found that binding of repressor to
OL3 enhances the binding of repressor to
OR3, which, in turn, leads to repression of transcription initiating at PRM. In
, the repressor tetramers bound to OL1 and OL2 establish octamers with the repressor tetramers bound at OR1 and OR2 by looping out the intervening region (8, 49). Measurements of
repressor binding to its respective OR sequences independent of OL sequences indicated that the concentrations of repressor necessary for binding OR3 are very high (25). Although repressor binding to OR3 turns off transcription from PRM, the high levels required for binding at OR3 made it difficult to see how OR3 contributes to regulation of repressor expression under physiological conditions in which the repressor levels are not high enough (34). However, the studies by Dodd et al. (9) demonstrate that interactions between OL1 · OL2 and OR1 · OR2 align the dimer bound to OL3 in position to interact with the dimer bound to OR3 so that repressor binding at OR3 is stabilized. In this way, the dimers bound to OL3 contribute to the effective repression of PRM by the CI protein. By controlling repressor expression from PRM, OL3 probably serves to help maintain repressor at proper levels to ensure that the prophage will be induced under appropriate conditions. Because 933W does not have an OL3, this model of PRM repression appears not to be applicable. The way in which 933W compensates physiologically for this lack of OL3 is an open question, which takes on added significance when considering the role of induction in the expression of stx from the 933W genome.
A recent study indicates that H-19B and 933W induce more readily than do the non-Stx-encoding lambdoid phages tested (33). Moreover, it has been suggested that this enhanced induction may have been selected to facilitate Stx production and/or release. Although H-19B and 933W appear to have similar spontaneous induction frequencies, their immunity regions differ in both structure and function. It seems plausible that these two phages have acquired independent mechanisms that make them more readily inducible. Because 933W does not possess OL3, it is likely not to regulate transcription initiating at PRM by precisely the same mechanisms as
and presumably other lambdoid phages. However, it remains to be determined how phage 933W regulates transcription initiating at PRM. Phage H-19B repressor interactions with its respective operator repeats differ from what is observed in
(55). Additionally, H-19B requires only one mutation in OR and one mutation in OL for virulence, suggesting the possibility of weak binding at OR. Due to the medical relevance of prophage induction to the progression of disease associated with STEC infection, examination of the immunity regions and, more specifically, the repressor-operator interactions of more Stx-encoding phages is warranted. In particular, it will be important to determine if high rates of spontaneous induction are a common attribute of phages that encode Stx.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
Vic DiRita is thanked for helpful suggestions in preparing the manuscript. John Little is thanked for pointing out the codon change resulting in the ind mutation. Ry Young is thanked for supplying the
cI857Kanr phage. Gerald Koudelka is thanked for sharing data.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|