Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Bacteriology, July 2005, p. 4430-4443, Vol. 187, No. 13
0021-9193/05/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/JB.187.13.4430-4443.2005
Copyright © 2005, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
and
Daniel J. Wozniak*
Department of Microbiology and Immunology, Wake Forest University School of Medicine, Medical Center Blvd., Winston-Salem, North Carolina 27157
Received 8 December 2004/ Accepted 18 March 2005
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
Nonmucoid isolates of the opportunistic pathogen Pseudomonas aeruginosa colonize the respiratory tract surface of the CF lung following persistent infections by organisms such as Staphylococcus aureus and nontypeable Haemophilus influenzae (1, 32). As lung disease progresses, mucoid variants of P. aeruginosa emerge and dominate the population (6). Exopolysaccharide expression leads to the formation of an endobronchial biofilm, which encases the microorganisms in a dense polysaccharide matrix that allows the bacteria to escape the lung's abundant phagocytic cell population (10, 18, 33, 35). Once established, mucoid P. aeruginosa microcolonies are seldom eradicated, leading to chronic infection of the lungs and perpetuating progressive pulmonary disease (28).
Mucoidy is a descriptive term for the production of the exopolysaccharide alginate, which is a negatively charged linear copolymer of ß-1,4-linked D-mannuronic acid (partially O acetylated), and its C-5 epimer,
-L-guluronic acid (11, 19). P. aeruginosa alginate has been shown to prevent complement activation and neutrophil chemotaxis, as well as to resist phagocytosis and scavenge free radicals released by activated macrophages (7, 27, 34). Expression of the mucoid phenotype is largely due to the acquisition of stable mutations in at least two regions of the chromosome, collectively referred to as the muc loci (12). Of the three classes of muc mutations that have been shown to lead directly to alginate production, the muc-2 and muc-22 mutations are within mucA, which encodes an anti-sigma factor responsible for sequestering the alternative sigma factor AlgT (AlgU;
22) to the inner membrane (4, 20, 22). Over 80% of mucoid P. aeruginosa isolates collected from CF patients demonstrated mutations in mucA (4), suggesting that the environment of the CF lung may select for variants that acquire stable mutations within this region of the chromosome.
Most of the P. aeruginosa genes encoding the alginate biosynthetic enzymes are clustered in a single operon, and the first gene of this operon, algD, encodes GDP-mannose dehydrogenase. GDP-mannose dehydrogenase catalyzes the rate-limiting step in alginate biosynthesis by converting GDP-mannose to GDP-mannuronic acid (37, 40). Transcription of algD is initiated by AlgT, which shares homology with the Escherichia coli extreme heat shock sigma factor
E and is responsible for the expression of several regulatory factors that positively enhance algD operon transcription (21, 24, 47). These include the response regulators AlgR and AlgB and the transcriptional activator AlgZ (2, 46).
AlgZ (GenBank accession no. AF139988) (3), PA3385 (39), is a proposed member of the ribbon-helix-helix (RHH) family of DNA binding proteins and shares 30% amino acid identity with the Mnt repressor of the Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium bacteriophage P22 (3). AlgZ binding activity was first observed while examining cell extracts from the mucoid P. aeruginosa CF isolate FRD1 for binding to sequences upstream of the algD promoter (2). AlgZ expression is conserved among mucoid CF isolates, and AlgZ is essential for algD transcription and alginate production (3). Recent studies have shown that algZ transcription is dependent on AlgT, suggesting that regulation of algD transcription is controlled by AlgT and AlgT-mediated expression of algZ (47).
Many DNA binding proteins in prokaryotes act as either activators or repressors of transcription (5, 14, 38). Most members of the RHH family of DNA binding proteins are repressors (29, 41). Some, such as PutA from E. coli and ParD of the broad-host-range plasmid RP4/RK2, also serve as autoregulators (13, 25). Here, we present evidence that AlgZ binds specifically to two sites upstream of its promoter and that subsequent protein-DNA interactions lead to repression of algZ transcription. Thus, AlgZ has a dual role as an activator of an essential P. aeruginosa virulence determinant and a repressor of its own synthesis. To our knowledge, this is the first report of an RHH protein exhibiting both activator and repressor functions in vivo.
|
|
|---|
Tc was cut with SmaI and ligated to generate pAB3. This construct was then substituted for wild-type algZ in the chromosome of FRD1 to generate FRD1224 (mucA22
algZ::
tet). Site-directed mutagenesis of pPJ136 was used with mutant oligonucleotide algZ19 (Table 1) to generate the algZ19 allele, which substituted an alanine residue for AlgZ residue Arg22 (pPJ150). The BamHI-HindIII fragment from pPJ150 was subcloned into pEX18Ap, resulting in pPJ157. This was then substituted for the
algZ::
tet allele in FRD1224 to generate FRD2238, which expressed AlgZ R22A. A single-copy algZ-lacZ fusion was placed at the attB site of FRD2238, resulting in FRD2503. All manipulations in E. coli were performed in either the JM109 or BL21(DE3) strain (Promega). All oligonucleotides used in this study are listed in Table 1 and were synthesized by the DNA Synthesis Core Laboratory at Wake Forest University School of Medicine. Chemicals and molecular biology reagents were purchased from Sigma or Promega unless otherwise stated. |
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Oligonucleotides used in this study
|
Overexpression of AlgZ and AlgZ R22A, extract preparation, and immunoblot analysis. Plasmid pPJ145, which expresses native AlgZ (47), was transformed into E. coli BL21(DE3) cells. The bacteria were grown to mid-log phase, and protein expression was induced for 3 hours by the addition of 1 mM isopropyl-thio-ß-D-galactopyranoside (IPTG). The cells were spun at 8,000 rpm and resuspended in fractionation buffer with glycerol (10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, 100 mM NaCl, 1 mM MgCl2, 5% glycerol). Following cell rupture by French press, the crude lysate was spun at 35,000 rpm and passed through a 0.45-µm filter. To overexpress AlgZ R22A in E. coli, the algZ19 allele was subcloned into a pET29a vector (pPJ162). The procedure for protein expression and extract preparation for AlgZ R22A is the same as for AlgZ, as stated above. Protein levels were quantitated by Bradford assay (9), and the titrations used in EMSAs for AlgZ or AlgZ R22A proteins (Fig. 1) were visualized by immunoblot analysis using an AlgZ-specific polyclonal antibody as previously described (47).
![]() View larger version (63K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. AlgZ binds to the algZ promoter. EMSAs were used to test binding interactions between wild-type AlgZ or variants and end-labeled fragments (278 to +202 bp) containing the algZ promoter. (A) Labeled DNA fragments were incubated with different amounts of an extract derived from E. coli BL21(DE3)/pPJ145 (AlgZ, lanes 3 to 10) or BL21(DE3)/pET29a (expression vector, lane 2) in the following amounts: lane 1, 0 µg; lane 2, 0.5 µg; lane 3, 0.25; lane 4, 0.5 µg; lane 5, 0.65 µg; lane 6, 1 µg; lane 7, 1.5 µg; lane 8, 2 µg; lane 9, 2.2 µg; lane 10, 2.5 µg. (B) Corresponding Western blot illustrating the amount of AlgZ that was added to each lane of the DNA binding assays shown in panel A. (C) EMSA containing labeled DNA incubated with an E. coli extract derived from BL21(DE3)/pPJ162 (AlgZ R22A, lanes 3 to 10) or BL21(DE3)/pET29a (expression vector, lane 2) in the following amounts: lane 1, 0 µg; lane 2, 0.5 µg; lane 3, 0.5 µg; lane 4, 1 µg; lane 5, 1.5 µg; lane 6, 2 µg; lane 7, 2.5 µg; lane 8, 5 µg; lane 9, 10 µg; lane 10, 15 µg. (D) Corresponding Western blot of AlgZ R22A illustrating the amount of AlgZ R22A that was added to each lane of the DNA binding assays shown in panel C. (E) EMSA with wild-type (lane 2) and His-tagged AlgZ (lanes 3 to 10) in the following amounts: lane 1, 0 µg; lane 2, 0.5 µg of wild-type AlgZ from BL21(DE3)/pPJ145 extract; lane 3, 0.092 µg of pure His-AlgZ; lane 4, 0.21 µg; lane 5, 0.30 µg; lane 6, 0.39 µg; lane 7, 0.51 µg; lane 8, 0.60 µg; lane 9, 0.69 µg; lane 10, 0.81 µg. (F) EMSA with native R22A (lane 2) and His-AlgZ R22A (lanes 3 to 10) in the following amounts: lane 1, 0 µg; lane 2, 0.5 µg of native R22A AlgZ from BL21(DE3)/pPJ162 extract; lane 3, 0.10 µg of pure His-AlgZ R22A; lane 4, 0.20 µg; lane 5, 0.30 µg; lane 6, 0.41 µg; lane 7, 0.51 µg; lane 8, 0.61 µg; lane 9, 0.71 µg; lane 10, 0.79 µg.
|
Isolation and labeling of DNA.
DNA fragments were isolated and labeled as previously reported (2). In brief, fragments containing portions of algZ, algD, or algB were amplified by PCR using Taq polymerase and oligonucleotides listed in Table 1. Template DNA was contributed by pDJW585 (algZ) (47), pDJW221 (algD) (45), or pJG194 (algB) (3). For the labeled fragment used in Fig. 1, algZ sequences (278 to +202 bp) were amplified with the algZ33 and algZ16 primers (Table 1). For the overlapping PCR assay (Fig. 2), end-labeled fragments were generated with primer pairs algZ33 and algZ37 (278 to +109 bp), algZ33 and algZ39 (278 to 173 bp), algZ14 and algZ34 (185 to 66 bp), algZ32 and algZ35 (77 to +20 bp), and algZ36 and algZ37 (+10 to +109 bp). One primer for each PCR was end labeled using T4 polynucleotide kinase and [
-32P]ATP, as described in the manufacturer's instructions. Following PCR amplification, excess [
-32P]ATP was removed using G-50 columns (Amersham). Labeled DNA was then extracted using phenol-chloroform-isoamyl alcohol, ethanol precipitated, dried, and resuspended in a suitable amount of deionized water. For the competition assays, the algZ14 primer was labeled as described above and incubated in a PCR with algZ25 to generate a 183-bp end-labeled fragment (185 to 3 of algZ). Unlabeled competitor DNAs 183 bp in length were generated by PCR amplification of pDJW585 (algZ) using algZ14 and algZ25 primers, of pDJW221 (algD) using algD5 and algD40 primers, and of pJG194 (algB) using algB12 and algB63 primers.
![]() View larger version (90K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. AlgZ binding is localized to a region spanning from 185 to 66 bp upstream of algZ. (A) The sequence of algZ (278 to +109 bp) was divided into four overlapping fragments (fragments A to D). Fragment A encompassed sequences from 278 to 173 bp. Fragment B encompassed sequences from 185 to 66 bp. Fragment C encompassed sequences from 77 to +20 bp. Fragment D encompassed sequences from +10 to +109 bp. (B) DNA fragments were end labeled and incubated either alone (lanes 1, 4, 7, 10, and 13), with 0.5 µg of an extract derived from E. coli BL21(DE3)/pET29a (expression vector, lanes 2, 5, 8, 11, and 14), or with 0.5 µg of an extract derived from BL21(DE3)/pPJ145 (AlgZ, lanes 3, 6, 9, 12, and 15) in an EMSA. The amount of AlgZ used in this experiment was determined empirically and verified by phosphorimaging densitometry to be the amount of protein required to shift 89% of the free DNA containing all four fragments (A to D) (lane 3). Arrows indicate AlgZ-DNA complexes.
|
Competition assay. Quantitation of labeled and unlabeled fragments for the competition assay (see above) was performed using an ethidium bromide spot plate and Alpha Ease version 5.5 software (Alpha Innotech Corporation). Following standardization of the concentrations of all DNA fragments, approximately 4 pmol of labeled DNA was incubated in a DNA binding reaction (in a 40-µl overall volume) without protein or with 1 µg of an AlgZ-enriched extract, as well as 3 µg of poly(dI-dC) and binding buffer. Unlabeled competitor DNAs were then added to specified reactions at a ratio of 1:1-, 1:5-, 1:10-, 1:25-, 1:50-, or 1:100-fold excess of competitor. All reactions were incubated at 25°C for 10 minutes and separated on a 4% PAGE gel for 2 h at 200 V. The gel was dried at 80°C for 45 min and exposed to a phosphorimaging screen. The amount of free DNA was quantitated using ImageQuant software.
In situ copper phenanthroline footprinting.
In situ 1,10-phenanthroline-copper footprinting was performed as previously described (2). Primer algZ25 was end labeled with [
-32P]ATP and used in a PCR amplification of the algZ promoter (pDJW585) with unlabeled primer algZ14 (see Fig. 4). To footprint the coding strand (data not shown), primer algZ14 was end labeled with [
-32P]ATP and used in a PCR amplification of the algZ promoter (pDJW585) with unlabeled primer algZ25. These experiments were also repeated with His-AlgZ as the protein source (data not shown), and all reactions were processed as described previously (2). For another footprint (see Fig. 5), a similar protocol was followed, except primer algZ62 was end labeled with [
-32P]ATP and used in a PCR amplification of the algZ promoter (pDJW585) with unlabeled primer algZ34. End-labeled fragments were incubated in DNA binding assays containing 1.13 µg of purified His-AlgZ and footprinted as described above. For the noncoding strand (data not shown), primer algZ34 was end labeled with [
-32P]ATP and used in a PCR amplification of the algZ promoter (pDJW585) with unlabeled primer algZ62. The fragment was incubated with His-AlgZ and footprinted as described previously (2).
![]() View larger version (36K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Copper-phenanthroline footprinting reveals an AlgZ binding site (algZ1) centered at 93 bp upstream of algZ. (A) AlgZ-algZ complexes subjected to copper-phenanthroline footprinting. DNA binding assays containing AlgZ and an end-labeled DNA fragment (185 to 3 bp) were separated on a 4% acrylamide gel in an EMSA. A representative EMSA is shown, with lanes containing the following amounts of an extract derived from BL21(DE3)/pPJ145 (AlgZ): lane 1, 0 µg; lane 2, 0.13 µg; lane 3, 0.25 µg; lane 4, 0.5 µg; lane 5, 0.65 µg; lane 6, 1 µg; lane 7, 1.5 µg; lane 8, 2 µg; lane 9, 2.2 µg; lane 10, 2.5 µg. Free and complexed DNAs were subjected to in situ copper-phenanthroline footprinting, and cleaved DNAs from three higher-order complexes (1 to 3) were recovered from the gel, along with a control fragment (free algZ) lacking protein. These fragments are indicated by arrows. (B) Copper-phenanthroline footprinting of AlgZ-algZ complexes. Treated fragments (free algZ DNA [] and complexes 1 to 3) were separated on a 6% PAGE gel and run adjacent to a sequencing ladder. Areas of footprint are indicated by solid boxes, and regions of hypersensitivity are indicated by striped boxes. (C) Sequence of the algZ1 binding site, centered approximately 93 bp upstream of the algZ promoter and covering a 38-bp region of DNA spanning from 112 to 74 bp. Footprints for both noncoding (B) and coding (data not shown) strands are shown. Footprinted regions are indicated by boldface type and solid boxes, and regions of hypersensitivity are indicated by striped boxes.
|
![]() View larger version (38K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Identification of a second AlgZ binding site (algZ2) centered at 161 bp upstream of algZ using copper-phenanthroline footprinting. (A) AlgZ-algZ complexes subjected to copper-phenanthroline footprinting. DNA binding reactions were analyzed by EMSA and contained an end-labeled DNA fragment (242 to 66 bp) and His-AlgZ in the following amounts: lane 1, 0 pmol; lane 2, 1.52 pmol; lane 3, 3.05 pmol; lane 4, 4.57 pmol; lane 5, 6.1 pmol; lane 6, 7.62 pmol; lane 7, 9.15 pmol; lane 8, 10.7 pmol; lane 9, 12.2 pmol; lane 10, 13.7 pmol. Free and complexed DNAs were subjected to in situ copper-phenanthroline footprinting, and cleaved DNAs from two higher-order complexes (1 and 2) were recovered from the gel, along with a control fragment (free algZ) lacking protein. These fragments are indicated by arrows. (B) Copper-phenanthroline footprinting of AlgZ-algZ complexes. Treated fragments (free algZ DNA [] and complexes 1 and 2) were separated on a 6% PAGE gel and run adjacent to a sequencing ladder. Areas of footprint are indicated by solid boxes, and the region of hypersensitivity is indicated by a striped box. (C) Sequence of the algZ2 binding site, centered approximately 161 bp upstream of the algZ promoter and covering an 18-bp region of DNA spanning 170 to 153 bp. Footprinted regions for the coding strand (part B) are shown. Footprinted regions are indicated by boldface type and solid boxes, and the region of hypersensitivity is indicated by a striped box.
|
|
|
|---|
We then investigated whether the binding of AlgZ to the algZ promoter was specific. The Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium bacteriophage P22 repressor Mnt utilizes N-terminal amino acid residues Arg2, His6, Asn8, and Arg10 for high-affinity DNA contacts that are required for transcriptional regulation (16). AlgZ shares approximately 30% amino acid identity with Mnt, including conservation of an N-terminal arginine residue at position 22 that corresponds to Arg10 in Mnt (3). Site-directed mutagenesis was used to substitute an alanine residue for Arg22, and this variant (AlgZ R22A) was examined for its ability to bind to the algZ promoter. An end-labeled DNA fragment containing sequences flanking the algZ promoter was incubated with increasing concentrations of AlgZ R22A, and the protein-DNA complexes were separated using EMSA (Fig. 1C). Samples were also analyzed by immunoblot assay to detect the amount of AlgZ R22A added to each DNA binding reaction (Fig. 1D). In contrast to native AlgZ, AlgZ R22A failed to bind algZ DNA (Fig. 1C). This loss of binding activity was also observed when AlgZ R22A was tested for binding to the AlgZ binding site at algD (data not shown), suggesting that Arg22 is required for AlgZ DNA binding activity at multiple promoter regions and contributes specific contacts at each promoter.
The above-mentioned studies used native AlgZ or AlgZ R22A present in extracts of E. coli. A His-AlgZ variant was generated, purified, and tested for binding to the algZ fragment (see Materials and Methods). The binding activity of His-AlgZ for the algZ sequence was similar to the activity seen with native AlgZ (Fig. 1E), since multiple AlgZ-algZ complexes were formed with increasing His-AlgZ and the complexes exhibited mobilities similar to those formed with native AlgZ (Fig. 1E, compare lanes 2 and 3). We also generated a His-R22A AlgZ, which failed to bind DNA similarly to native AlgZ R22A (Fig. 1F). We concluded from these studies that the DNA binding activity of purified AlgZ was similar to the activity of the native protein. Both native and His-AlgZ proteins were used in the subsequent experiments.
AlgZ represses its own synthesis. To directly test the role of AlgZ in autoregulation, we engineered single-copy algZ-lacZ transcription fusions at the neutral attB site in algZ+ (FRD1310) and algZ-null (FRD1312) P. aeruginosa strains. The ß-galactosidase levels produced by each strain were measured in six separate experiments, and the averages are shown in Table 2. We observed a >2-fold increase in ß-galactosidase activity over wild-type levels in the algZ-null strain FRD1312, suggesting that AlgZ functions as an autorepressor.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. AlgZ represses transcription of the algZ promotera
|
Localization of AlgZ binding at algZ. To further define the AlgZ-algZ binding interaction, the sequence contained in the algZ-lacZ transcriptional fusion (278 to +109 bp) was divided into four overlapping fragments designated A to D (Fig. 2A). These fragments were labeled, amplified, and incubated with AlgZ in an EMSA (Fig. 2B). Addition of AlgZ to the fragment with all four regions (A to D) (Fig. 2A) produced two protein-DNA complexes and shifted 89% of the DNA (Fig. 2B, lane 3) compared to controls containing either free DNA alone (lane 1) or DNA incubated with an extract containing an expression vector (lane 2). When this concentration of AlgZ was tested with fragments A to D individually, 81% of fragment B (185 to 66 bp) was shifted upon addition of AlgZ (Fig. 2B, lane 9) and most closely resembled the binding activity observed with the fragment containing regions A to D (compare lanes 3 and 9). AlgZ bound weakly to fragments A and D individually, with approximately 2% of the free DNA of fragment A (278 to 173 bp) shifted (Fig. 2B, lane 6) and 8% of the free DNA of fragment D (+10 to +109 bp) shifted upon addition of AlgZ (lane 15). Although a shift appeared to be present when AlgZ was incubated with fragment C (Fig. 2B, lane 12), there was not a significant percentage of free DNA lost upon addition of AlgZ (compare lanes 10 and 12). These results suggested that fragment B (185 to 66 bp) contained high-affinity AlgZ binding site(s).
AlgZ binding upstream of algZ is a specific interaction. Loss of DNA binding activity by AlgZ R22A (Fig. 1C) suggests that AlgZ binds specifically to the algZ promoter. To rigorously validate that AlgZ binds specifically to a site(s) found between 185 and 66 bp, we performed a competition assay. An end-labeled fragment which overlapped fragment B (Fig. 2A) was incubated with saturating amounts of AlgZ and increasing concentrations of unlabeled competitor DNA fragments. Free and complexed DNAs were analyzed by EMSA (Fig. 3). As increasing concentrations of the unlabeled specific competitor algZ fragment were added (lanes 2 to 7), the complexes were gradually titrated away. In contrast, when the AlgZ-algZ DNA binding assay mixtures were incubated in the presence of unlabeled nonspecific DNA, the protein-DNA complexes were not significantly titrated away until the unlabeled fragment was at 100-fold excess of the labeled fragment (lanes 9 to 14), suggesting that AlgZ interactions upstream of the algZ promoter are specific.
![]() View larger version (116K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. AlgZ binds specifically to a site(s) upstream of the algZ promoter. End-labeled DNA fragments encompassing sequences from 185 to 3 bp upstream of algZ were incubated with the indicated amounts of protein and competitor DNA in an EMSA. Lanes 1 to 7 and 9 to 20 contain 1 µg of an extract derived from BL21(DE3)/pPJ145 (AlgZ). The lanes contained the following molar excess concentrations of specific competitor DNA (lanes 2 to 7, algZ competitor; lanes 15 to 20, algD competitor) or nonspecific algB competitor DNA (lanes 9 to 14): lanes 2, 9, and 15 contained 1x concentration competitor DNA; lanes 3, 10, and 16 contained 5x; lanes 4, 11, and 17 contained 10x; lanes 5, 12, and 18 contained 25x; lanes 6, 13, and 19 contained 50x; lanes 7, 14, and 20 contained 100x. Lane 1 contained no competitor DNA, and lane 8 contained no protein or competitor DNA.
|
Footprinting studies reveal two adjacent AlgZ binding sites positioned upstream of the algZ promoter. To accurately identify the AlgZ binding site(s) in fragment B (185 to 66 bp) (Fig. 2A), in situ copper-phenanthroline footprinting was performed. An end-labeled DNA fragment was incubated with increasing concentrations of AlgZ, and the protein-DNA complexes were subjected to EMSA. Three distinct complexes with differing mobilities were detected when increasing concentrations of AlgZ were added to the DNA binding reactions (Fig. 4A, compare lanes 4, 8, and 10), with complexes 1 and 2 producing signals of greater intensity than complex 3. Multiple DNA-binding reactions containing labeled DNA and AlgZ in the same amounts used in lane 4 or 10 were processed by EMSA, and complexes 1 to 3 (Fig. 4A) were subjected to in situ copper-phenanthroline footprinting. The individual complexes were excised from the gel, and the cleaved DNA was eluted and separated on a 6% sequencing gel adjacent to a sequencing ladder (Fig. 4B). The footprints were examined on both the noncoding (Fig. 4B) and the coding (data not shown) strands.
When complex 1 was analyzed by footprinting (Fig. 4B), an AlgZ binding site was identified along a string of A-T residues positioned 93 bp upstream of the transcriptional start site. Alternating regions of footprint and hypersensitivity covering an approximately 38-bp sequence from 112 to 74 bp were also noted (Fig. 4C). This sequence was designated algZ1. Interestingly, the footprinted region was not extended when complexes 2 and 3 were examined, suggesting that differing mobilities among AlgZ-algZ complexes were not caused by AlgZ tracking along the algZ1 binding site (Fig. 4A and B, complexes 2 and 3, respectively). Both DNA strands were footprinted, and the three complexes demonstrated identical patterns of footprint and hypersensitivity for each DNA strand examined (Fig. 4B and data not shown). This suggested that multiple-complex formation was not due to a binding preference of AlgZ for one DNA strand over another.
When we performed the footprinting assay described above, we were unable to resolve additional binding sites upstream of algZ1. To explore this possibility, an end-labeled fragment spanning 242 to 66 bp upstream of the algZ transcriptional start site was incubated with His-AlgZ in a DNA binding reaction. The sequence selected for this footprinting experiment covered both a portion of fragment A and all of fragment B (Fig. 2A), providing greater resolution of potential binding interactions immediately upstream of algZ1.
The protein-DNA complexes were separated by EMSA, and two protein-DNA complexes were readily observed (Fig. 5A, complexes 1 and 2). Following in situ copper-phenanthroline footprinting of the coding strand (Fig. 5B), a second AlgZ binding site, designated algZ2, was found to be centered at 161 bp upstream of the transcriptional start site (Fig. 5C). AlgZ bound to the coding strand along a region spanning approximately 18 bp (172 to 155), which contained two footprinted areas separated by a region of hypersensitivity (Fig. 5B). The noncoding strand exhibited increased hypersensitivity upon addition of His-AlgZ, but no footprint was evident (data not shown). The algZ2 sequence covered a region of DNA that was approximately half of the algZ1 protection zone. At lower protein concentrations (complex 1) (Fig. 5A), the algZ2 region was unoccupied, as demonstrated by a lack of protection (Fig. 5B). It was only at higher protein levels (complex 2) (Fig. 5A) that the algZ2 site became occupied (Fig. 5B). This suggests an affinity difference between the two binding sites, with the algZ1 sequence occupied at both low and high AlgZ concentrations and the algZ2 binding site occupied only at higher concentrations. Another lower-affinity binding site(s) present in the sequence of fragment A (278 to 173 bp) (Fig. 2B) was not detected in this experiment. From these studies, we conclude that AlgZ binds at least two sites upstream of the algZ promoter and exhibits a different affinity for each site.
Deletion of mapped AlgZ binding sites results in loss of DNA binding activity. Based on the identification of two AlgZ binding sites, we questioned how the loss of these sites would affect the ability of AlgZ to bind to its promoter. We generated four mutant alleles by either deleting AlgZ binding sites (algZ47, algZ67, and algZ57) or substituting an identically sized nonspecific DNA in place of these binding sites (algZ58). The algZ47 allele contained a deletion of algZ1 (111 to 76 bp), the algZ67 allele contained a deletion of algZ2 (153 to 170), and the algZ57 allele contained deletions of both algZ1 and algZ2 (180 to 71 bp) (Fig. 6A). The algZ58 allele contained a substitution of a 110-bp fragment of algB DNA in place of both algZ1 and algZ2 (Fig. 6A). End-labeled DNAs containing wild-type or allelic variants of the algZ promoter were incubated with increasing amounts of His-AlgZ and analyzed by EMSA (Fig. 6B to F).
![]() View larger version (70K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. Loss of mapped AlgZ binding sites at algZ results in loss of AlgZ binding to the algZ promoter. EMSAs were used to test binding interactions between His-AlgZ and end-labeled fragments (258 to +79 bp of algZ) containing the wild-type algZ promoter or allelic variants. (A) Illustrations of the deletions and substitution of the 5' regulatory region of the algZ promoter are shown. The wild-type algZ promoter contains two mapped AlgZ binding sites centered at 93 and 161 bp upstream of the transcriptional start site, designated algZ1 and algZ2, respectively. Deletion of the algZ1 binding site resulted in a loss of 36 bp (111 to 76 bp) and was designated the algZ47 allele. Deletion of the algZ2 binding site resulted in a loss of 18 bp (153 to 170 bp) of algZ and was designated the algZ67 allele. Removal of a 110-bp fragment (180 to 71 bp) resulted in a deletion of both algZ1 and algZ2 binding sites and was designated the algZ57 allele. A fragment containing 110 bp of algB DNA was used to replace the 110-bp fragment (180 to 71 bp) containing both mapped AlgZ binding sites, generating the algZ58 allele. (B to F) EMSAs containing labeled DNAs from the wild-type algZ promoter or allelic variants (algZ47, algZ67, algZ57, or algZ58) were incubated with His-AlgZ in the following amounts: lane 1, 0 pmol; lane 2, 0.61 pmol; lane 3, 1.22 pmol; lane 4, 1.83 pmol; lane 5, 2.44 pmol; lane 6, 3.66 pmol; lane 7, 4.88 pmol; lane 8, 6.10 pmol; lane 9, 7.32 pmol; lane 10, 8.54 pmol.
|
![]() View larger version (27K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 7. Summary of regulation of algZ transcription and a proposed AlgZ consensus motif. (A) Relevant nucleotide sequences and features of the 5' region of the algZ promoter (positions 218 to +74 relative to the transcription initiation site, designated +1) are shown. The 10/35 boxes recognized by the alternative sigma factor AlgT (AlgU) are indicated in boldface type. Underlined sequences (from 112 to 74 for algZ1 and 170 to 153 for algZ2) indicate AlgZ binding sites as determined by copper-phenanthroline footprinting and deletion analyses. A portion of the AlgZ N-terminal amino acid residues is also listed. (B) Sequence comparison of AlgZ binding sites and proposed AlgZ consensus binding motif. The proposed consensus motif is shown with the following symbols: lowercase letters indicate wobble positions, uppercase letters indicate nucleotides conserved among at least three AlgZ binding sites, and arrows indicate a partial palindrome. algD refers to the previously reported AlgZ binding site at algD (2). The two AlgZ binding sites at algZ reported in this study are designated algZ1 and algZ2. The localization of the consensus motif within the binding sites, i.e., on the coding or noncoding DNA strands, is also listed.
|
|
|
|---|
Based on sequence homology with the bacteriophage P22 repressor Mnt, AlgZ is proposed to be a member of the RHH family of DNA binding proteins, in which DNA binding activity is modulated by ß-strand recognition and binding of nucleotides within the major groove of the DNA. Mnt is a tetramer in solution and binds a 17-bp operator, and each dimer of the tetramer is hypothesized to recognize one symmetric half-site (17, 41, 43). Although detailed structural information about soluble AlgZ or AlgZ bound to its operator DNA is currently unavailable, glutaraldehyde cross-linking studies demonstrate that AlgZ forms dimers and larger oligomeric species in solution (D. M. Ramsey and D. J. Wozniak, unpublished observations). Similar to other members of the RHH family, it is likely that AlgZ binds to its operator site as an oligomer, and the presence of two binding sites upstream of algZ would allow for multiple protein-DNA contacts that could effectively modulate algZ transcription. Binding of both the upper and lower DNA strands in algZ1 may strengthen the binding interaction, as evidenced by the observation that this binding site was occupied at both low and high protein concentrations (Fig. 4B). The algZ2 site is bound only at higher protein concentrations (Fig. 5B), and its reduced affinity may be due to the lack of an adjacent motif on the lower DNA strand that could stabilize AlgZ oligomer formation. The competition assay demonstrated that there is also an affinity difference of AlgZ for the binding sites at algZ versus algD (Fig. 3). This may be due to multiple binding sites present at algZ in comparison to the single site at algD, although differences in nucleotide sequence could contribute to the strength or weakness of individual binding interactions or binding interactions involving oligomers of AlgZ.
An alanine substitution for Arg22 of AlgZ results in a loss of binding to the algZ promoter (Fig. 1C and F) and at algD (data not shown), suggesting that AlgZ utilizes Arg22 for recognition of multiple binding sites. Because the DNA binding activity of the N-terminal portion of Mnt is distinct from the oligomerization properties of the C-terminal domain (44), the binding and oligomerization properties of AlgZ may also be mediated by separate regions. The oligomeric structure of AlgZ in solution and the boundaries of its DNA binding domain are questions that remain to be answered.
The ability of AlgZ to contact or affect the rate of transcription initiation by RNA polymerase may depend on the position of the operator sites in relation to the promoter, the sequence of the operator sites, their affinity for AlgZ, and the number of operator sites within the promoter region itself. These may also contribute to the ability of AlgZ to switch roles from an activator to a repressor. The ability of an RHH protein to assume dual regulatory roles has been illustrated in vitro by studies of Arc, which represses the Pant and Pmnt promoters during lytic growth of bacteriophage P22 (36, 42). Upon binding to specific variants of Pant, Arc acted to slow open-complex formation and accelerate promoter clearance, thus acting as both a repressor and an activator in vitro (36). Here, we report evidence that the transcriptional activator AlgZ is capable of acting as a repressor of algZ transcription in vivo by a currently uncharacterized mechanism (Table 2). This illustrates not only the complexity of transcriptional control by an RHH DNA binding protein, but also the versatility that allows one protein to serve as both activator and repressor of two different genes.
The presence of at least two AlgZ binding sites upstream of the algZ promoter and the subsequent repression exerted by AlgZ suggest a complex regulatory mechanism modulated by both the alternative sigma factor AlgT and now the transcriptional regulator AlgZ (Fig. 7). This repression, however, is modest (approximately twofold) (Table 2), suggesting that the ability of AlgZ to repress its own transcription could be modulated based on the occupation of the binding sites. At low concentrations of AlgZ, the algZ1 binding site is occupied and may activate algZ transcription. As protein levels increase, however, both the algZ1 and algZ2 sites are occupied. Cooperative protein-protein interactions between AlgZ oligomers bound to both sites could introduce a torsional strain in the DNA that reduces the affinity of RNA polymerase for the promoter. Because the affinity of AlgZ for algZ2 appears to be weaker than for algZ1 and highly dependent on the protein concentration, the algZ2 site may be transiently occupied and serve as the switch between activation and repression. The ability of AlgZ to weakly repress transcription guarantees that a measurable amount of AlgZ will be present in cells in which the alternative sigma factor AlgT is derepressed, so that its role as an activator of algD transcription and influence on subsequent alginate production is not greatly attenuated by its role as repressor of its own transcription. Thus, the expression of the mucoid phenotype is sustained through the dual activities of repression and activation by the transcriptional regulator AlgZ.
This work was supported by American Heart Association predoctoral fellowship 0215191U (D.M.R.) and Public Health Service grants AI-35177 and HL-58334 (D.J.W.).
Present address: Department of Biology, St. Edward's University, 3001 South Congress Ave., Austin, TX 78704-6489. ![]()
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»