Skip to main page content

• HOME
• Current Issue
• Archive
• Alerts
• About ASM
• Contact us
• Tech Support
• Journals.ASM.org

This Article Abstract Full Text (PDF) Alert me when this article is cited Alert me if a correction is posted Services Similar articles in this journal Similar articles in PubMed Alert me to new issues of the journal Download to citation manager Reprints and Permissions Copyright Information Books from ASM Press MicrobeWorld Citing Articles Citing Articles via HighWire Citing Articles via Google Scholar Google Scholar Articles by Jamet, A. Articles by Hérouart, D. Search for Related Content PubMed PubMed Citation Articles by Jamet, A. Articles by Hérouart, D.

 Previous Article  |  Next Article 

Journal of Bacteriology, December 2007, p. 8741-8745, Vol. 189, No. 23
0021-9193/07/$08.00+0     doi:10.1128/JB.01130-07
Copyright © 2007, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.

H₂O₂ Is Required for Optimal Establishment of the Medicago sativa/Sinorhizobium meliloti Symbiosis

Alexandre Jamet, Karine Mandon, Alain Puppo, and Didier Hérouart^*

Interactions Plantes-Microorganismes et Santé Végétale, UMR IPMSV INRA 1064 - CNRS 6192, Université de Nice—Sophia Antipolis, Centre Sophia Agrobiotech, 400 route des chappes, BP 167, F-06903 Sophia Antipolis, France

Received 18 July 2007/ Accepted 20 September 2007

Top ABSTRACT TEXT REFERENCES

 
The symbiotic interaction between Medicago sativa and Sinorhizobium meliloti RmkatB⁺⁺ overexpressing the housekeeping catalase katB is delayed, and this delay is combined with an enlargement of infection threads. This result provides evidence that H₂O₂ is required for optimal progression of infection threads through the root hairs and plant cell layers.

Top ABSTRACT TEXT REFERENCES

 
Leguminous plants can engage in a symbiotic interaction with Rhizobia and form new root organs, the nodules. The nodulation process is initiated by a complex signal exchange between both partners (5). Rhizobial invasion in the symbiotic model Medicago sativa/Sinorhizobium meliloti occurs via root hairs. The perception of bacterial nodulation factors by the host plant leads to cell division in the root pericycle and in the root cortex, where the nodule primordium forms. Simultaneously, root hairs deform and curl. The bacteria are entrapped in this curl, local cell wall is hydrolyzed, and a plasma membrane invagination occurs, leading to the formation of an infection thread (IT) (3). This plant-derived tubule filled with dividing and growing bacteria first progresses through the infected root hair and then traverses several cell layers toward the nodule primordium. Bacterial cells at the tip of the IT are released and enclosed in peribacteroid membranes in the host cell cytoplasm (10). Once inside the plant cells, the bacteria differentiate into nondividing nitrogen-fixing endosymbionts called bacteroids, which are able to fix atmospheric dinitrogen (22).

Important progress has recently been made in analyzing the mechanisms that initiate the establishment of the symbiosis and especially the mechanism of the perception of bacterial nodulation factors by the host plants (12, 18). The development of an IT inside root hair and the architecture of IT networks in nodules have been recently studied (9, 21). In fact, ITs can be considered as tubular ingrowths of the plant cell wall. In pea/Rhizobium leguminosarum symbiosis, a family of extensin-like glycoproteins associated with the lumen of these ITs has been identified (25). However, more data are necessary to clearly identify the biochemical mechanisms by which ITs grow. Reactive oxygen species like O₂^– and H₂O₂ could be implicated, since they have been implicated during the infection process and especially in the ITs (28). The observed distribution of H₂O₂ in ITs and the plant cell wall strongly suggests that H₂O₂ is of plant origin (30). To overcome this reactive oxygen species production, S. meliloti possesses at least two superoxide dismutases (SodA and SodC) and three catalases (KatA, KatB, and KatC). It has been shown that the corresponding genes are differentially expressed not only during free-living growth but also during nodule establishment. Indeed, both sod genes are expressed in ITs (27; D. Touati, personal communication). In contrast, only katB and katC genes, and not the uniquely H₂O₂-inducible katA gene (15), are strongly expressed in the ITs despite the detection of H₂O₂ all around the bacteria (16). Moreover, a nonefficient release into plant cells and a perturbed differentiation of bacteria into bacteroids have been observed for a katB katC double mutant (16). In free-living conditions, the coexpression of katB and katC has been observed only during the stationary phase, suggesting that most of bacteria within the ITs are potentially in a nonexponential growth phase. This has recently been corroborated by experiments showing that bacterial growth occurs only in a very small region on the tip of ITs (9). Moreover, on the basis of observations of root tips, the potential implication of H₂O₂ in an insolubilization of the glycoprotein matrix within IT lumen has been suggested (30).

To further comprehend the mechanisms of IT growth, we tried to modify the H₂O₂ content within IT by using an S. meliloti strain overexpressing one catalase. Among the three catalases, KatB was selected because it plays a housekeeping role, as it is expressed throughout all the growth phases of the free-living bacterium and also during symbiosis. Moreover, KatB shows a higher affinity for H₂O₂ than the two other catalases of S. meliloti (1). In order to overexpress KatB, the Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium trp promoter was fused upstream of the complete coding region of katB by four cloning steps. The first of these consisted of amplification of the katB open reading frame by PCR using the following primers: AJKATB1 (5'-CCATCGATCGCCCAATCGAGGAAGAGG-3'), creating a new ClaI restriction site, and AJKATB2 (5'-ACATGGGCTCGAGCCACGT-3'), creating a new XhoI restriction site (boldface in sequences indicates restriction sites). Subsequent steps included subcloning in pGEM-T (Promega corporation), double digestion ClaI and XhoI, and insertion into pTB93F (11) to create the pTBkatB⁺⁺ plasmid. The efficiency of the trp promoter to overproduce KatB has been tested by transferring this recombinant plasmid into the recipient katB-null mutant GKBZ01 expressing a pkatB-lacZ fusion by triparental mating. Total catalase activities were 36 ± 6.7, 17 ± 7.2, and 380 ± 102 U/µg of protein in crude extracts of GMI211, GKBZ01, and GKBZ01/pTBkatB⁺⁺, respectively, indicating that the trp promoter allows a 10-fold increase in the catalase activity in S. meliloti. However, the recombinant plasmid was unstable in S. meliloti during the plant infection process without antibiotic pressure (data not shown).

To avoid this problem, the chimeric construction allowing the overexpression of katB was integrated into the pSymA megaplasmid by recombination. Four more cloning steps were necessary before the transfer by triparental mating. The BamHI/BglII fragment of the pTBkatB⁺⁺ plasmid, containing the ptrp promoter and 80% of the KatB open reading frame, was subcloned into the BamHI site of the pSUP202 plasmid, resulting in the pSUPkatB⁺⁺ plasmid. A lacZ/Nm^r cassette extracted from the pKOK5 plasmid was inserted into the SalI restriction site of pSUPkatB⁺⁺, resulting in the pSUPkatB⁺⁺lacZ plasmid. The recombinant RmkatB⁺⁺ strain expressing both pkatB-lacZ and pTrp-katB fusions was obtained by triparental mating using the Rm1021 wild-type strain as that recipient strain. Expression levels of trp and katB promoters in the ITs are not known, and it was impossible to accurately measure the catalase activity from IT bacteria. However, the catalase capacities of free-living RmkatB⁺⁺ were determined during growth in Luria-Bertani medium containing 2.5 mM MgSO₄ and 2.5 mM CaCl₂ (LB-MC). During the exponential phase, the total catalase activity in RmkatB⁺⁺ was three times higher than that in Rm1021, whereas a 10-fold increase was observed during the stationary phase (Table 1). Analysis of the catalase activity pattern on native polyacrylamide gel by use of inhibition of diaminobenzidine oxidation by H₂O₂ (14) showed that the increase of total catalase activity in the stationary phase was largely due to an increase of KatB (Fig. 1A and B). To evaluate the resistance of RmkatB⁺⁺ to exogenous H₂O₂, the survival of bacteria was checked by incubating for 30 min in LB-MC containing an increasing concentration of H₂O₂. The treatment was stopped by adding exogenous catalase, and bacteria were counted on the LB-MC plate. In the presence of 10 mM H₂O₂, wild-type Rm1021 bacteria were rapidly killed, whereas the survival of recombinant RmkatB⁺⁺ cells was only slightly reduced (data not shown). The intracellular concentration of H₂O₂ was evaluated in both strains by use of an Amplex Red kit (Molecular Probes, Montluçon, France) as described previously for Agrobacterium tumefaciens (31). H₂O₂ concentrations of 124 nM and 52 nM in Rm1021 and RmkatB⁺⁺, respectively, were estimated, indicating that the mutant strain has a lower internal H₂O₂ level.

View this table: [in this window] [in a new window]

TABLE 1. Catalase activity and symbiotic performance of Rm1021 and RmkatB++ strains

View larger version (29K): [in this window] [in a new window]

FIG. 1. Catalase activity of Sinorhizobium meliloti strains: Rm1021 (lane 1) and RmkatB++ (lane 2) in exponential (A) and stationary (B) phases. The locations of KatA, KatB, and KatC are indicated according to the work of Sigaud et al. (29). Twenty-five micrograms of total protein was loaded on each lane.

To test the effect of katB overexpression on the symbiotic process, the symbiotic performance of recombinant RmkatB⁺⁺ strain to its parental wild type was assessed by three independent experiments. The number of nodules per 72 plants was determined 7, 14, and 21 days after inoculation with the mutant RmkatB⁺⁺ strain and with Rm1021 as the control. The values obtained for 7 and 14 days postinoculation indicate that the RmkatB⁺⁺ strain presents a delayed nodulation phenotype following the infection (Table 1). Moreover, this delay does not appear to be due to a modification of the early steps of the infection process, since the expression levels of early plant nodulin genes ENOD12 (24) and MtN6 (20), determined by reverse transcription-PCR using total RNA from M. truncatula root tips, were found to be similar for infection with Rm1021 and RmkatB⁺⁺ (data not shown). However, 3 weeks after infection, no significant difference between plants inoculated with Rm1021 or RmkatB⁺⁺ was observed in terms of the number of nodules and the capacity of bacteroids to reduce the dinitrogen within nodules (data not shown). To determine more precisely the point at which the RmkatB⁺⁺ strain is affected during the infection process, the plasmid pXLGD4 (17), which contains a hemA-lacZ fusion allowing a constitutive expression of lacZ, was transfected into the Rm1021 and RmkatB⁺⁺ strains. A set of 40 plants were infected for each strain, and the efficiency of infection was estimated 5 days after infection using the following criteria: colonized curled root hairs, initiated ITs, extended ITs, and infected young nodules (Fig. 2). The global numbers of infection events were similar for both strains. In contrast, the number of extended ITs and the ratio of initiated ITs to colonized curled root hairs were significantly higher for Rm1021/pXLGD4 than for RmkatB⁺⁺/pXLGD4. Moreover, the ITs showed an irregular aspect and a larger average diameter for RmkatB⁺⁺ (7.34 ± 2.25 µm) than for Rm1021 (3 ± 1.07 µm). The diameters of 40 ITs from each strain were measured using images from bright-field microscopy (Fig. 3). H₂O₂ accumulation was analyzed in ultrathin sections of ITs of very young nodules as an electron-dense deposit stained with cerium chloride as describe previously (2, 28). When plants were infected with Rm1021, H₂O₂ was detected in most of the ITs, principally between the cell wall and the matrix (Fig. 4A and B). In contrast, no H₂O₂ could be observed in enlarged ITs obtained with RmkatB⁺⁺, whereas the peroxide is still detectable in the cell wall (Fig. 4C and D). This indicates that the mutant has an enhanced ability to inactivate H₂O₂ associated with IT walls. As a control, the detection of H₂O₂ in ITs was completely abolished by treating the sample with 25 µg ml^–1 of catalase before adding cerium chloride, indicating that it reflects H₂O₂ accumulation (data not shown).

View larger version (13K): [in this window] [in a new window]

FIG. 2. Number of infection events 5 days after infection with Rm1021 and RmkatB++ strains. Experimental data were assessed for statistical significance by means of the Student t test; * indicates significant difference (P < 0.05). Abbreviations: CCRH, colonized curled root hair; IIT, initiated IT; EIT, extended ITs; YN, young nodule; WT, wild type.

View larger version (120K): [in this window] [in a new window]

FIG. 3. Structure of ITs in 5-day-old nodules. Nodules were induced by the Rm1021 (A and C) and RmkatB++ (B and D) strains. Black arrows show ITs, and open arrowheads show nuclei. Scale bars = 10 µm.

View larger version (142K): [in this window] [in a new window]

FIG. 4. Detection of H2O2 accumulation as electron-dense precipitate formed in the presence of cerium chloride (arrows) in ITs 5 days after infection with Rm1021 (A and B) and RmkatB++ (C and D). (A, C, and D) Transversal cross section of ITs. (B) Longitudinal cross-section showing the release of bacteria inside the plant cell. Magnitudes of pictures are indicated with scale bars.

Other bacterial mutant strains have been shown also to exhibit a nodulation-delayed phenotype similar to that of RmkatB⁺⁺, particularly those affected in their production of exopolysaccharides (4, 6, 8, 23). To determine if the exopolysaccharide content was affected in RmkatB⁺⁺, two distinct tests were performed: one with the UV-fluorescent calcofluor, which binds a portion of succinoglycan (7), and the other with Sudan black B, which detects the galactoglucan and some succinoglycan, which are not involved in calcofluor fluorescence (19). No difference between Rm1021 and RmkatB⁺⁺ was observed, indicating that the phenotype observed for RmkatB⁺⁺ could not be explained simply by a modification of exopolysaccharide production (data not shown).

In conclusion, our results indicate that the H₂O₂ production observed within some ITs (28), which did not appear to induce an oxidative stress for bacteria (16), has a crucial role in optimizing IT development. This is in line with the hypothesis of an important H₂O₂ involvement in the biomechanics of IT growth via the cross-linking of glycosylated plant glycoproteins, namely, the root nodule extensins, which are localized in the extracellular matrix of legume tissues and in the lumen of ITs (13, 30). The reduced levels of H₂O₂ in the ITs obtained with RmkatB⁺⁺ could influence the rate of cross-linking of these extensins, compromising a polarized growth of ITs and leading to their enlargement. The results presented here are in agreement with an early report by Salzwedel and Dazzo (26), where peroxidase activities were localized during root hair infection and were supposed to contribute to the infection process.

 
We gratefully acknowledge G. Van de Sype for technical help on ultramicroscopic analyses and Julie Hopkins for help with proofreading.

A. Jamet's work was supported by a grant from the Ministère de l'Education National, de l'Enseignement supérieur et de la Recherche.

 
* Corresponding author. Mailing address: Interactions Plantes-Microorganismes et Santé Végétale, UMR IPMSV INRA 1064 - CNRS 6192, Université de Nice—Sophia Antipolis, Centre Sophia Agrobiotech, 400 route des chappes, BP 167, F-06903 Sophia Antipolis, France. Phone: (33) 492 38 66 36. Fax: (33) 492 38 66 40. E-mail: herouart{at}unice.fr

Published ahead of print on 5 October 2007.

Present address: Unité de Recherche en Biologie Moléculaire (URBM), Facultés Universitaires Notre-Dame de la Paix, rue de Bruxelles 61, B-5000 Namur, Belgium.

Top ABSTRACT TEXT REFERENCES

 

1
1. Ardissone, S., P. Frendo, E. Laurenti, W. Jantschko, C. Obinger, A. Puppo, and R. P. Ferrari. 2004. Purification and physical-chemical characterization of the three hydroperoxidases from the symbiotic bacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti. Biochemistry 43:12692-12699.[CrossRef][Medline]
2
2. Bestwick, C. S., I. R. Brown, M. H. Bennett, and J. W. Mansfield. 1997. Localisation of hydrogen peroxide accumulation during the hypersensitive reaction of lettuce cells to Pseudomonas syringae pv phaseolicola. Plant Cell 9:209-221.[Abstract]
3
3. Brewin, N. J. 2004. Plant cell wall remodelling in the Rhizobium-legume symbiosis. Crit. Rev. Plant Sci. 25:1-24.
4
4. Cheng, H.-P., and G. C. Walker. 1998. Succinoglycan is required for initiation and elongation of infection threads during nodulation of alfalfa by Rhizobium meliloti. J. Bacteriol. 180:5183-5191.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
5
5. Denarie, J., F. Debelle, and J. C. Prome. 1996. Rhizobium lipo-chitooligosaccharide nodulation factors: signaling molecules mediating recognition and morphogenesis. Annu. Rev. Biochem. 65:503-535.[CrossRef][Medline]
6
6. D'Haeze, W., J. Glushka, R. De Rycke, M. Holsters, and R. W. Carlson. 2004. Structural characterization of extracellular polysaccharides of Azorhizobium caulinodans and importance for nodule initiation on Sesbania rostrata. Mol. Microbiol. 52:485-500.[CrossRef][Medline]
7
7. Doherty, D., J. A. Leigh, J. Glazebrook, and G. C. Walker. 1988. Rhizobium meliloti mutants that overproduce the R. meliloti acidic calcofluor-binding exopolysaccharide. J. Bacteriol. 170:4249-4256.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
8
8. Fraysse, N., F. Couderc, and V. Poinsot. 2003. Surface polysaccharide involvement in establishing the rhizobium-legume symbiosis. Eur. J. Biochem. 270:1365-1380.[Medline]
9
9. Gage, D. J. 2002. Analysis of infection thread development using Gfp- and DsRed-expressing Sinorhizobium meliloti. J. Bacteriol. 184:7042-7046.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
10
10. Gage, D. J. 2004. Infection and invasion of roots by symbiotic, nitrogen-fixing rhizobia during nodulation of temperate legumes. Microbiol. Mol. Biol. Rev. 68:280-300.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
11
11. Gage, D. J., T. Bobo, and S. R. Long. 1996. Use of green fluorescent protein to visualize the early events of symbiosis between Rhizobium meliloti and alfalfa (Medicago sativa). J. Bacteriol. 178:7159-7166.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
12
12. Geurts, R., E. Fedorova, and T. Bisseling. 2005. Nod factor signaling genes and their function in the early stages of Rhizobium infection. Curr. Opin. Plant Biol. 8:346-352.[CrossRef][Medline]
13
13. Gucciardo, S., E. A. Rathbun, M. Shanks, S. Jenkyns, L. Mak, M. C. Durrant, and N. J. Brewin. 2005. Epitope tagging of legume root nodule extensin modifies protein structure and crosslinking in cell walls of transformed tobacco leaves. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 18:24-32.[CrossRef][Medline]
14
14. Hérouart, D., S. Sigaud, S. Moreau, P. Frendo, D. Touati, and A. Puppo. 1996. Cloning and characterization of the katA gene of Rhizobium meliloti encoding a hydrogen peroxide-inducible catalase. J. Bacteriol. 178:6802-6809.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
15
15. Jamet, A., E. Kiss, J. Batut, A. Puppo, and D. Herouart. 2005. The katA catalase gene is regulated by OxyR in both free-living and symbiotic Sinorhizobium meliloti. J. Bacteriol. 187:376-381.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
16
16. Jamet, A., S. Sigaud, G. Van de Sype, A. Puppo, and D. Hérouart. 2003. Expression of the bacterial catalase genes during Sinorhizobium meliloti-Medicago sativa symbiosis and their crucial role during infection process. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 16:217-225.[Medline]
17
17. Leong, S. A., P. H. Williams, and G. S. Ditta. 1985. Analysis of the 5' regulatory region of the gene for -aminolevulinic acid synthetase of Rhizobium meliloti. Nucleic Acids Res. 13:5965-5976.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
18
18. Limpens, E., C. Franken, P. Smit, J. Willemse, T. Bisseling, and R. Geurts. 2003. LysM domain receptor kinases regulating rhizobial Nod factor-induced infection. Science 302:630-633.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
19
19. Liu, M., J. E. Gonzalez, L. B. Willis, and G. C. Walker. 1998. A novel screening method for isolating exopolysaccharide-deficient mutants. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 64:4600-4602.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
20
20. Mathis, R., C. Grosjean, F. de Billy, T. Huguet, and P. Gamas. 1999. The early nodulin gene MtN6 is a novel marker for events preceding infection of Medicago truncatula roots by Sinorhizobium meliloti. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 12:544-555.[Medline]
21
21. Monahan-Giovanelli, H., C. A. Pinedo, and D. J. Gage. 2006. Architecture of infection thread networks in developing root nodules induced by the symbiotic bacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti on Medicago truncatula. Plant Physiol. 140:661-670.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
22
22. Oke, V., and S. R. Long. 1999. Bacterial genes induced within the nodule during the Rhizobium-legume symbiosis. Mol. Microbiol. 32:837-849.[CrossRef][Medline]
23
23. Pellock, B. J., H.-P. Cheng, and G. C. Walker. 2000. Alfalfa root nodule invasion efficiency is dependent on Sinorhizobium meliloti polysaccharides. J. Bacteriol. 182:4310-4318.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
24
24. Pichon, M., E. P. Journet, A. Dedieu, F. de Billy, G. Truchet, and D. G. Barker. 1992. Rhizobium meliloti elicits transient expression of the early nodulin gene ENOD12 in the differentiating root epidermis of transgenic alfalfa. Plant Cell 4:1199-1211.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
25
25. Rathbun, E. A., M. J. Naldrett, and N. J. Brewin. 2002. Identification of a family of extensin-like glycoproteins in the lumen of Rhizobium-induced infection threads in pea root nodules. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 15:350-359.[Medline]
26
26. Salzwedel, J. L., and F. B. Dazzo. 1993. pSym nod gene influence on elicitation of peroxidase activity from white clover and pea roots by rhizobia and their cell-free supernatants. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 6:127-134.[Medline]
27
27. Santos, R., D. Hérouart, A. Puppo, and D. Touati. 2000. Critical protective role of bacterial superoxide dismutase in Rhizobium-legume symbiosis. Mol. Microbiol. 38:750-759.[CrossRef][Medline]
28
28. Santos, R., D. Hérouart, S. Sigaud, D. Touati, and A. Puppo. 2001. Oxidative burst in alfalfa-Sinorhizobium meliloti symbiotic interaction. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 14:86-89.[Medline]
29
29. Sigaud, S., V. Becquet, P. Frendo, A. Puppo, and D. Hérouart. 1999. Differential regulation of two divergent Sinorhizobium meliloti genes for HPII-like catalases during free-living growth and protective role of both catalases during symbiosis. J. Bacteriol. 181:2634-2639.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
30
30. Wisniewski, J.-P., E. A. Rathbun, J. P. Knox, and N. J. Brewin. 2000. Involvement of diamine oxidase and peroxidase in insolubilization of the extracellular matrix: implications for pea nodule initiation by Rhizobium leguminosarum. Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact. 13:413-420.[Medline]
31
31. Xu, X. Q., L. P. Li, and S. Q. Pan. 2001. Feedback regulation of an Agrobacterium catalase gene katA involved in Agrobacterium-plant interaction. Mol. Microbiol. 42:645-657.[CrossRef][Medline]

---

Journal of Bacteriology, December 2007, p. 8741-8745, Vol. 189, No. 23
0021-9193/07/$08.00+0     doi:10.1128/JB.01130-07
Copyright © 2007, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.

This article has been cited by other articles:

• Chang, C., Damiani, I., Puppo, A., Frendo, P. (2009). Redox Changes during the Legume-Rhizobium Symbiosis. Mol Plant 2: 370-377 [Abstract] [Full Text]  

This Article Abstract Full Text (PDF) Alert me when this article is cited Alert me if a correction is posted Services Similar articles in this journal Similar articles in PubMed Alert me to new issues of the journal Download to citation manager Reprints and Permissions Copyright Information Books from ASM Press MicrobeWorld Citing Articles Citing Articles via HighWire Citing Articles via Google Scholar Google Scholar Articles by Jamet, A. Articles by Hérouart, D. Search for Related Content PubMed PubMed Citation Articles by Jamet, A. Articles by Hérouart, D.