Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Journal of Bacteriology, March 2009, p. 1480-1489, Vol. 191, No. 5
0021-9193/09/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/JB.01343-08
Copyright © 2009, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
,
The Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute, Wellcome Trust Genome Campus, Hinxton, Cambridge, Cambridgeshire CB10 1SA, United Kingdom,1 Division of Infection and Immunity, Glasgow Biomedical Research Centre, University of Glasgow, 120 University Place, Glasgow G12 8TA, United Kingdom,2 Department of Infection, Immunity and Inflammation, Medical Sciences Building, University of Leicester, Leicester LE1 9HN, United Kingdom3
Received 26 September 2008/ Accepted 16 December 2008
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
S. pneumoniae is a naturally competent, genetically diverse species, with less than half of the pan-genome conserved between all strains thus far studied (33). The pneumococcal population is normally confined to the human nasopharynx, with rates of asymptomatic carriage varying with demographics, region, and season: surveys of colonization in healthy children generally estimate between 20 and 97% of younger individuals carry pneumococci (9, 32), with levels falling with age. Epidemiological data and animal models of infection indicate that strains exhibit differing propensities for causing invasive disease (13, 29, 63). The invasive disease potential odds ratio, which takes into account the relative frequencies of invasive disease and asymptomatic carriage observed in the human population, varies 80-fold between serotypes (13). However, the functional genetic variation to which this differing ability to cause disease is attributable remains largely unknown. Genome sequencing efforts have mainly focused on clinical pneumococcal isolates; the complete genomes of two highly invasive strains, TIGR4 (70) and D39 (38) (and the laboratory-adapted D39 derivative R6) (34), have been published, along with draft sequences for serotype 19F strain G54 (26) and eight clinical isolates from a hospital in Pittsburgh (65). However, in order to understand the bacterial population structure, and the reasons underlying the variation in pathogenicity, genomic studies of strains that only rarely invade past the mucosal surfaces are required.
S. pneumoniaeSpain23F sequence type 81 (ST81) was one of the first pandemic penicillin-resistant clones identified (47). Initially characterized among isolates from Spain in the 1980s, it spread globally, and by the late 1990s it was estimated to constitute almost 40% of penicillin-resistant disease isolates in the United States (21). The clone is also resistant to chloramphenicol and tetracycline and is one of those most frequently associated with the emergence of fluoroquinolone and macrolide resistance (58, 60). This lack of susceptibility to the major classes of antimicrobial chemotherapies used to treat pneumococcal infections has undoubtedly aided the spread of the strain and lead to the inclusion of the 23F serotype in PCV7. This has resulted in a reduction in the prevalence of the S. pneumoniaeSpain23F ST81 clone in some regions (35). However, the lineage has undergone capsule switching to alternative capsule types on at least three occasions (from serotype 23F to 14 (36), 19A (20), and 19F (19), suggesting it is liable to eventually evade the vaccine. Despite its high carriage prevalence (22), it has a low propensity for causing invasive disease (67) (odds ratio of 0.4 [13]), suggesting its intercontinental distribution has been facilitated by adaptations to colonization of, and survival within, the human nasopharynx. Here we report our analysis of the complete genome of S. pneumoniae ATCC 700669, a member of the serotype 23F ST81 lineage that was isolated in a hospital in Barcelona in 1984 (18).
|
|
|---|
8-fold genome coverage was achieved through sequencing of pUC clones with 1.4- to 2.8-kb inserts and pSMART clones with 8- to 12-kb inserts using a BigDye terminator sequencing kit (Applied Biosystems) and Applied Biosystems 3700 sequencers. Sequences from 30- to 40-kb pEpiFOS-5 fosmid clones and 12- to 23-kb pBACe3.6 BAC clones were used to scaffold contigs and bridge repeats. The sequence was finished according to standard criteria (55). Sequence assembly, visualization, and finishing were performed by using PHRAP (www.phrap.org) and Gap4 (10). All repeat sequences were independently verified. Annotation and genome comparisons. Coding sequences were initially identified by using Glimmer3 (24) and then manually curated using Frameplot (7) and Artemis (62). All genes were annotated in Artemis using standard criteria (6). Genome comparisons were visualized in the Artemis comparison tool (16). Sequence clustering and analysis was performed by using ClustalX 2.0 (39) and MEGA4 (69).
Nucleotide sequence accession numbers. The sequence and annotation of S. pneumoniae ATCC 700669 has been deposited in the EMBL database under the accession number FM211187. Other sequences referred to in the present study are also deposited in the public databases with the following accession numbers: S. pneumoniae TIGR4 (AE005672), D39 (CP000410), R6 (AE007317), G54 (CP001015), and CGSP14 (NC010582) and the eight draft sequences of pneumococcal clinical isolates from Pittsburgh (3-BS71, AAZZ01000001-AAZZ01000024; 6-BS73, ABAA01000001-ABAA01000038; 9-BS68, ABAB01000001-ABAB01000061; 11-BS70, ABAC01000001-ABAC01000025; 14-BS69, ABAD01000001-ABAD01000049; 18-BS74, ABAE01000001-ABAE01000028; 19-BS75, ABAF01000001-ABAF01000030; and 23-BS72, ABAG01000001-ABAG01000032).
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (33K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Circular diagram representing the S. pneumoniae ATCC 700669 chromosome, arranged to have the origin of replication at the top, as indicated by the GC deviation (innermost graph). The outer rings show the arrangement of coding sequences on the two strands of the genome, colored according to annotated function (see the key). The first inner ring indicates the major variable regions as blue blocks: moving clockwise from the origin of replication, these represent the prophage remnant, cps locus, PPI-1, the Na+-dependent ATP synthase island, ICESp23FST81, the pclA gene cluster, MM1-2008, and the psrP gene cluster. The red blocks demarcate loci identified as having atypical nucleotide composition by the Alien Hunter algorithm (71). Moving inward, the rings show the position of IS elements (pink if intact, brown if pseudogene), RUP repeats (blue), and BOX A, B, and C repeat modules (red), respectively. The black graph indicates sequence GC content.
|
Of the annotated genes, 29% are predicted to encode surface exposed or secreted proteins. These include 18 phosphotransferase system (PTS) transporters, 17 of which are shared with both TIGR4 and D39, which have four and three PTS transporters not present in ATCC 700669, respectively. The one system unique to ATCC 700669 (SPN23F18210-18250) forms part of a
10-kb insertion that also includes a putative choline sulfatase. Given the importance of choline to pneumococcal metabolism and pathogenesis, this transporter could represent a novel means of acquiring this nutrient from the host environment. S. pneumoniae genomes also encode many ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporter components, and there are two such systems within the ATCC 700669 genome that are absent from both TIGR4 and D39. One of these, present on a
4-kb insertion along with two putative secreted peptides (SPN23F07060-07090), is similar to systems present in S. pyogenes MGAS6180, S. pyogenes MGAS10270, and S. sanguinis SK36.
Genes implicated in pathogenesis. Genome-wide screens in S. pneumoniae have identified a large number of genes required for full virulence in the mouse model of pneumococcal disease (31, 40, 54, 59), and variation in their sequences may lie behind the differences in invasiveness seen in epidemiological studies. One such "virulence factor" is PspA, a highly variable choline-binding surface protein that protects S. pneumoniae against the bactericidal effects of apolactoferrin, as well as inhibiting complement-mediated opsonization of the pneumococcus (5). It has been shown that the pspA gene of a serotype 23F strain contained a frameshift mutation that truncated the encoded protein to a secreted, rather than surface-associated, form (44). A similar frameshift mutation, caused by variation in the length of the same polyadenosine tract, is observed in this genome. Furthermore, ATCC 700669 lacks the zmpC gene, which encodes a metalloprotease that cleaves and activates human matrix metalloprotease 9 and has been implicated in the pulmonary invasion process (52). However, like S. pneumoniae G54, it encodes an additional surface-exposed zinc metalloprotease, zmpD (15), adjacent to the immunoglobulin A protease gene zmpA. Notably absent from the ATCC 700669 genome are two more surface-exposed proteins, choline-binding protein cbpC and histidine triad protein phtB, which appear to be required for full virulence of TIGR4 in the mouse model, based on signature-tagged mutagenesis data (31).
There are two large islands present in S. pneumoniae ATCC 700669 that are shared with TIGR4 but absent from D39, both of which were found to be overrepresented in invasive strains in a comparative genomic hybridization study of clinical isolates (49). One, region of diversity 8a, is a
25-kb island encoding an Na+-dependent ATP synthase. The second is the psrP gene cluster, encoding a large adhesin similar to the S. gordonii platelet-binding protein GspB, along with associated glycosylases (61). Although ATCC 700669 lacks both identified pneumococcal pilus synthesis gene clusters (2, 3), it does possess the large surface-anchored collagen-like protein PclA (56), which contains G5 domains implicated in biofilm formation (4). Absent from TIGR4, the D39 orthologue is
44% longer due to an expansion in the internal repetitive region of the protein.
Prophage.
Prophage are bacteriophage genomes integrated into the host bacterial chromosome, which have been shown to be responsible for the transduction of virulence factors between pathogens on numerous occasions (72). Two closely related temperate pneumophage,
MM1, from a serotype 23F ST81 strain (50), and
MM1-1998, from a serotype 24 strain (41), have been previously sequenced. Although the S. pneumoniae G54 and D39 genomes are devoid of prophage, a 10.5-kb phage remnant can be found between the eno and rexB genes in the chromosome of TIGR4 (50). The ATCC 700669 genome contains an intact 39.1-kb prophage,
MM1-2008, as well as a smaller prophage remnant.
MM1-2008 is more than 97% identical, at the nucleotide sequence level, to both
MM1 and
MM1-1998. Since
MM1 and
MM1-2008 are from hosts of the same serotype and sequence type, they are probably descended from the same insertion event, while the host of
MM1-1998 is a penicillin-sensitive serotype 24 strain; hence, this prophage is likely to be the result of a different infection. All three phage are present in the same locus, between a pyridine nucleotide-disulfide oxidoreductase gene and a CDS of unknown function. The exact insertion site of the phage appears to be within the 3' region of the downstream hypothetical gene; duplication of this 15-bp att sequence (30) upon integration maintains the full-length target gene sequence and generates the tandem repeats either side of the prophage. Acquisition of
MM1-1998 by pneumococcal hosts was correlated with increased adhesion to eukaryotic cells (41), implying prophage genes may potentially play a role in colonization or pathogenesis.
The 6.4-kb prophage remnant is flanked by genes encoding a putative cytidine deaminase and a deoxyuridine 5' triphosphate nucleotidohydrolase. Along with CDS of phage origin, including integrase and amidase pseudogenes, the prophage appears to carry "cargo" genes that have been retained as the replicative machinery of the virus has degenerated. One of these CDS encodes a type I restriction endonuclease domain and appears to be a member of a family of uncharacterized genes found in a range of bacterial species. Another is an addiction system toxin gene, which may have inhibited the clearance of the remainder of the prophage from the genome. Although a cognate antitoxin cannot be reliably identified, the overlapping upstream gene is a good candidate, as alignments with intact prophage indicate these CDS have been acquired as a pair. A complete 37.5-kb long prophage can be found at this locus in the draft genome of S. pneumoniae 18-BS74 (65), suggesting it may be a common target insertion site for temperate pneumophage.
ICE.
ICEs are autonomously mobile genetic entities that are transmitted between bacteria through conjugative transfer in a circularized form and insert into, and excise from, host DNA via site-specific recombination (14). This grouping includes both conjugative transposons and integrative plasmids that share this common mechanism of horizontal transfer. The
81-kb ICE of ATCC 700669, ICESp23FST81, is a composite element comprising a Tn916-like component inserted into a Tn5252-like transposon, with the latter consequently being split into a larger proximal region and a smaller distal region (Fig. 2A). This combination of conjugative transposons is common in streptococcal ICEs, although the variation observed in the arrangement of these two elements implies it has arisen independently on a number of occasions (Fig. 3). This suggests a potential symbiotic advantage between these different transposon types, perhaps resulting from a synergistic combination of the two sets of conjugative machinery or "cargo" genes. Flanked by a 16-bp tandem duplication, ICESp23FST81 is inserted near the 3' end of rplL, in the same position as that of S. pneumoniae G54 and many other streptococcal ICEs, although Tn5253, the partially sequenced ICE of S. pneumoniae BM6001 (1), appears to have integrated elsewhere.
![]() View larger version (26K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. (A) Representation of ICESp23FST81. "Cargo" genes are colored according to the scheme detailed in Fig. 1 and are labeled with their putative function, where one can be assigned. The division of the ICE into Tn5252 and Tn916-type elements is indicated by the bars at the top and bottom of the diagram. (B) Comparison of the ICE insertion sites in the ATCC 700669 and G54 genomes with the corresponding loci in the TIGR4 and D39 genomes, which lack intact ICE. The ICE are represented as pink blocks: Tn5252-type elements are represented by blocks above the scale line, while Tn916-type elements are represented by blocks below the scale line. Red bands indicate BLAST matches between genomes in the same direction, whereas blue bands indicate matches in opposite directions. The intensity of the band represents the strength of the match. The region of each genome shown is bounded at the 5' end by ICE-derived sequences and at the 3' end by rplL, which streptococcal ICEs frequently insert directly upstream of. The ICE remnants in the TIGR4 and D39 genomes, apparently derived from the distal region of the Tn5252-type element, are marked. The alignment shows that there is a remnant in D39 directly adjacent to rplL, at the point where the elements usually insert, but the two remnants in the TIGR4 genome are further removed upstream.
|
![]() View larger version (33K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 3. Comparison of streptococcal integrative and conjugative elements. Genes likely to be part of the conjugative machinery of the element, on the basis of conservation or functional assignment, are colored pink. Zeta toxin-epsilon antitoxin systems are colored gray, antibiotic resistance genes are white, and other "cargo" genes are green. Bands are colored as in Fig. 2, with the intensity of the color indicating the strength of the BLAST match. Unlike the S. suis and S. pneumoniae elements, the S. agalactiae and S. dysgalactiae Tn5252-like elements do not contain a Tn916-type component, which carries the tetM gene responsible for tetracycline resistance in the other ICE.
|
1.8-kb long ICE remnants that are >80% identical, at the nucleotide level, to the distal Tn5252-type region of ICESp23FST81 (Fig. 2B). Similar remnants are also seen in the ATCC 700669 and G54 genomes immediately upstream of their ICE insertions. A second, larger, ICE remnant is also evident in the TIGR4 genome,
15 kb upstream of rplL; this includes a cytosine methyltransferase gene very similar to homologues in the distal region of ICESp23FST81, on Tn5253 and in the
MM1 phage (85%, 85% and 45% protein sequence identity, respectively). The presence of this gene on conjugative transposons and prophage suggests it may aid the horizontal transfer of both between pneumococci, perhaps through methylating DNA prior to transfer between cells and hence avoiding the recipient's restriction systems.
ICESp23FST81 is clinically important due to its genetic "cargo." The Tn916-type component carries a tetM gene, responsible for the strain's tetracycline resistance. A similar Tn916 element, also carrying the mef(A) macrolide resistance gene, has been detected in the gammaproteobacterial commensal and emerging nosocomial pathogen Acinetobacter junii (53). The
1.2-kb flanking sequences that were determined on either side of the A. junii Tn916 transposon are 99% identical, at the nucleotide level, to the Tn5252-type sequences surrounding the Tn916 transposon on ICESp23FST81, suggesting these composite elements can transfer between very distantly related bacteria. The Tn5252-like component carries a gene for chloramphenicol acetyltransferase, which appears to have been acquired through wholesale integration of the pC194 plasmid (73) originally identified in chloramphenicol-resistant Staphylococcus aureus.
One of the "cargo" genes found toward the 5' end of the element is a uvrD helicase gene, with the closest sequenced homologue being that of the deltaproteobacterium Geobacter lovleyi (26% protein sequence identity). A different uvrD gene, with a dissimilar sequence (15% protein sequence identity), is present at the equivalent position on the G54 ICE. Streptococci lack an SOS response (27), so consequently uvrD is absent from the S. pneumoniae core genome, but horizontal acquisition of this gene could potentially reconstitute the nucleotide excision repair pathway if it were able to act in concert with the uvrABC genes shared by all pneumococci. This pathway is important in the repair of peroxidative damage to DNA (46); therefore, given that S. pneumoniae is catalase negative and produces hydrogen peroxide which can function as an antimicrobial (57), the gain of the uvrD gene may increase the tolerance of ATCC 700669 to reactive oxygen species and hence aid nasopharyngeal colonization, while also resulting in the ICE maintaining its sequence integrity within the host. The other major branch of the SOS response, also absent from the core genome of pneumococci, is mutagenic lesion repair, which requires a reduction in DNA polymerase III replication fidelity caused by an interaction with the UmuC-UmuD complex. Correspondingly, Tn5252 carries a umuCD-containing operon that was demonstrated to increase the UV tolerance of the host bacterium (48), suggesting ICE-carried genes can functionally restore at least one aspect of the SOS response.
An ICE-derived genomic island.
Genes characteristic of streptococcal ICE are also found in another region of the genome, within the putative pathogenicity island 1 (PPI-1), as described by Brown et al. (12). In S. pneumoniae ATCC 700669, this
30-kb region, as defined by its low GC content (SPN23F09511-09860; Fig. 4), contains the pezAT epsilon toxin-zeta antitoxin system, found on ICESp23FST81, as well as related elements in S. suis and S. agalactiae strains, and a cluster of three Tn5252 conjugative machinery genes, including a relaxase and a MobC-domain protein. At the 3' end, coinciding with the edge of the low GC region, there is a further
200-bp region of similarity (>90% identity at the nucleotide level) with ICESp23FST81, which is also shared with Tn5253 and the ICE of the newly sequenced S. pneumoniae CGSP14 strain (accession number NC010582). A site-specific recombinase, similar to one found in S. suis ICEs, is found adjacent to this sequence in some pneumococcal strains, such as S. pneumoniae 14-BS69. Hence, it appears likely that this island originated as an ICE insertion that has subsequently degenerated, with the loss of genes required for the element's autonomous mobility. The gene clusters located between these ICE-like regions are very different in many of the strains for which genome data are available (Fig. 5), suggesting this locus may be able to diversify through exchange of sequences with ICE via homologous recombination in the shared regions.
![]() View larger version (13K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 4. Comparison of PPI-1 of ATCC 700669 with ICESp23FST81 found in the same strain. Three regions of apparently conserved similarity are observed: the zeta toxin-epsilon antitoxin system, a group of Tn5252 conjugative transfer genes (encoding ORF 9, ORF10, and relaxase proteins), and a short stretch of DNA adjacent that forms the 3' border of PPI-1, shortly upstream of the cell division gene ftsW in the pneumococcal chromosome. The GC content of this region is shown, with the line across the graph indicating the average for the region (33.71% GC). The vertical dotted lines on the graph delimit the extent of PPI-1.
|
![]() View larger version (18K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 5. Alignment of PPI-1 from complete and draft pneumococcal genome data. Variation in the regions intervening between the relaxase and 3' end of PPI-1 (these boundaries both have sequence homology with Tn5252-type ICE) appears to be due to horizontal gene transfer, indicating that conjugative elements may contribute to the diversity found within this island through homologous recombination-mediated exchange. There is also variation putatively resulting from degeneration of the original conjugative element insertion: the PPI-1 of S. pneumoniae G54 has lost the pezAT toxin-antitoxin system and much of the cluster of conjugative transfer genes (although it has retained a CDS encoding a MobA-domain protein, which are typically associated with autonomously mobile elements, indicated in pink), while that of 18-BS74 appears to have lost all vestiges of the original element's conjugative machinery.
|
The ability to exchange sequences with conjugative elements may play a role in allowing this locus to rapidly evolve in response to changing selection pressures. In strains that have retained the variable region, CDS similar to genes encoding daunorubicin efflux transporters, inhibitor-resistant methionyl tRNA synthetases, macrolide efflux pumps, and apparently truncated aminoglycoside phospho- and acetyltransferases are found. Furthermore, two of the sequenced Pittsburgh disease isolates (9-BS69 and 14-BS69) seem to carry chloramphenicol acetyltransferase genes on the island. This is at least the fourth documented case in which Tn5252-type elements appear to have contributed to the transfer of chloramphenicol acetyltransferase genes to pneumococci. Tn5253 of S. pneumoniae BM6001 and ICESp23FST81, both intact, potentially mobile, elements, carry chloramphenicol acetyltransferase genes at different positions. The PPI-1 locus and the IQ complex of S. pneumoniae 529, a genomic island containing Tn5252- and Tn916-like fragments, along with chloramphenicol acetyltransferase and macrolide resistance genes (45), both appear to be fragments of conjugative transposons that have been integrated into the chromosome, suggesting that exchange of DNA between ICE and the pneumococcal genome is likely to be an important mechanism in the dissemination of antibiotic resistance throughout the S. pneumoniae population.
In S. pneumoniae ATCC 700669, PPI-1 contains an apparently incomplete lantibiotic synthesis operon. Lantibiotics (lanthionine-containing antibiotics) are small, secreted cyclic peptides containing lanthionine rings formed by the stereospecific intramolecular addition of cysteine to dehydrated serine or threonine residues (74). They frequently function as bacteriocins, with different types hypothesized to operate through inhibiting peptidoglycan transglycoslyation or forming pores in cell membranes, but are also known to act as biosurfactants and phospholipase A2 inhibitors (74). The gene cluster present in the ATCC 700669 PPI-1 lacks a structural prepeptide gene but retains the CDS necessary for immunity. Comparison with the same locus in the serogroup 23 Pittsburgh isolate genome reveals a
6-kb deletion in the ATCC 700669 gene cluster (Fig. 6B). The sequence absent in ATCC 700669 is flanked by thymidine dinucleotides and encodes two lantibiotic structural genes and fragments of two dehydratases. The putative product of the intact locus is a novel dimeric lantibiotic (Fig. 6A) likely to be similar to those produced by Bacillus and Lactococcus species (74).
![]() View larger version (36K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 6. Lantibiotic synthesis gene clusters and predicted structures. The color scheme is the same as that used in Fig. 1. (A) Gene cluster encoded on the PPI-1 of 23-BS72. Each structural gene appears to be associated with its own synthetase. The ABC transporter is thought to be responsible for the self-immunity of the producer. The likely sequences of the mature peptides are shown aligned with other dimeric lantibiotics, with the lanthionine rings (formed by the dehydration of cysteine and serine or threonine residues) conserved between haloduracin and lacticin 3147 indicated by the curved lines above the alignment. The conservation of the functionally most important residues with these other bacteriocins indicates the 23-BS72 lantibiotic is likely to be bactericidal. (B) Alignment of the PPI-1 of S. pneumoniae 23-BS72 and ATCC 700669, revealing a 6-kb deletion in the gene cluster of the latter. (C) Gene cluster encoded on ICESp23FST81. This is predicted to produce a monomeric lantibiotic, most similar to lichenicidin and mersacidin, produced by Bacillus species. The known ring structure of mersacidin is indicated, again showing that the functional, ring-forming residues are largely conserved in this new lantibiotic. It is the third ring (the most strongly conserved between the three sequences) that is thought to be most important for the bactericidal effects of mersacidin, resulting from the inhibition of peptidoglycan transglycosylation.
|
A similar plcR homologue-secreted peptide combination is present on the G54 ICE and also adjacent to a different
10-kb putative lantibiotic synthesis gene cluster (SPN23F19690-19790) conserved in the chromosomes of ATCC 700669, TIGR4 and D39, next to the rpoBC genes. This locus also appears to be a recent addition to the genome on the basis of its atypical nucleotide composition (71) and absence from other pneumococcal sequences (e.g., S. pneumoniae OXC141 and INV104 [www.sanger.ac.uk/Projects/S_pneumoniae/]). In addition, shortly upstream of the ICESp23FST81 insertion site lies another region (SPN23F12290-12330) in these three genomes that appears to have been recently horizontally acquired, on the basis of its nucleotide composition and flanking tandem repeats, which contains the remains of a set of lantibiotic processing machinery. Hence, the range of bacteriocins that individual pneumococcal strains are able to produce appears to change over time as new gene clusters are gained and old ones degenerate. If these antimicrobial peptides are associated with specific quorum-sensing systems, this could further increase the scope for competition between strains, since differences in signaling and regulation of the bacteriocins would also vary between different genotypes. This is likely to result in strains having a variable secretome that could strongly influence intra- and interspecific competition within the nasopharynx.
Concluding remarks. The international spread of S. pneumoniaeSpain23F ST81 indicates the clone is highly effective at nasopharyngeal colonization, and the genome analysis presented here offers some possible explanations. The loss of the blpMN pneumocidin and PPI-1-encoded lantibiotic in ATCC 700669 suggests they may have become redundant during the evolution of the Spain 23F ST81 lineage. In both cases, the structural genes were lost, while those required for immunity were retained, ensuring the strain remained nonsusceptible to these compounds secreted by its competitors. A possible explanation is that the pneumocidin on the ICE may have superceded other bacteriocins produced by the strain and assisted nasopharyngeal colonization, and hence the spread, of the Spain 23F ST81 clone. Both this lantibiotic synthesis gene cluster and another elsewhere in the chromosome are found adjacent to genes encoding plcR-type transcriptional regulators and secreted peptides. If such quorum-sensing systems are involved in the regulation of bacteriocin production, this would add further layers of complexity onto the intercellular signaling already known to occur in S. pneumoniae (the two previously characterized pneumocidins, BlpMN and CibAB, are regulated by the pheromones BlpC and ComC, respectively) (17, 25). Such complexity may be necessary, in an organism with such a variable chromosome, to distinguish clonal relatives from other related strains. Furthermore, cell-density-dependent regulation of the ICE-encoded lantibiotic synthesis gene cluster may be advantageous for the mobile element itself, since suppressing production of the antimicrobial compound until the ICE has saturated the available population of potential hosts is likely to facilitate its horizontal transfer.
ICEs have evidently played an important role in pneumococcal evolution. Given their wide potential host range, as exemplified by the detection of a conjugative element in A. junii apparently similar in structure to ICESp23FST81, and their ability to traffic long stretches of exogenous DNA, ICEs are likely to contribute a significant proportion of the S. pneumoniae pan-genome. The diverse "cargo" carried provides a large gene pool that can facilitate the rapid adaptation of the host species to new selective pressures, as illustrated by the case of antibiotic resistance in general, and chloramphenicol resistance in particular. Analogously, the presence of SOS response genes on pneumococcal conjugative elements may be protective against a different antimicrobial compound, hydrogen peroxide. At relatively low concentrations, this reactive oxygen species causes cell death through chromosomal damage (28); hence, a functional nucleotide excision repair pathway may increase the ability of the pneumococcus to tolerate H2O2 by improving the repair of oxidized DNA. However, the most significant change in the pneumococcal lineage to have been driven by a conjugative element may have been the insertion of the transposon that gave rise to PPI-1. The avirulence of mutants lacking genes in the 5' region of PPI-1 in the mouse, as well as the absence of this genome feature even in closely related streptococci, suggests that ICEs are also likely to have originally played an important role in the emergence of the pathogenic capability of pneumococci, as well as being important in their more recent adaptation to the challenge of antimicrobial chemotherapies.
Even in a species that exchanges genetic material as readily as S. pneumoniae, a small number of clones dominate the population of antibiotic-resistant pneumococci (36), suggesting that resistance must arise in a genetic background conducive to transmission for a multi-drug-resistant strain to emerge as a pandemic clone. Although much of the above analysis has focused on conjugative elements, factors elsewhere in the host chromosome, such as penicillin resistance, must also be important in aiding the spread of the strain, or else multidrug resistance would likely be distributed more quickly through conjugative transfer of ICE rather than clonal dissemination. It seems likely that pneumococcal pandemic clones represent chance combinations of horizontally acquired genetic elements that interact to allow the strain to outcompete other genotypes. The relative contributions of different segments of the chromosome to the emergence of such clones cannot be assessed by techniques such as multilocus sequence typing and BOX fingerprinting, which focus on regions of the genome that vary primarily through genetic drift. High-throughput sequencing and chromosome-wide genotyping technologies will permit a more precise knowledge of population structure, and provide more clues as to why certain lineages rise to international prevalence.
Work in Glasgow is supported by the BBSRC, MRC, and Wellcome Trust.
Published ahead of print on 29 December 2008. ![]()
Supplemental material for this article may be found at http://jb.asm.org/. ![]()
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»