Alternative Transcription Factor ς^B Is Involved in Regulation of Biofilm Expression in a Staphylococcus aureusMucosal Isolate

Construction of a sigB insertion mutant and complementation of the mutation.The inactivation ofsigB was done by insertion of an erythromycin resistance cassette into the sigB gene of S. aureus MA12 by double-crossover integration. For this purpose, the temperature-sensitive shuttle vector pSK8, which carries asigB::ermB mutation, was constructed. A 937-bp fragment containing the entire sigB gene was amplified by PCR from S. aureus MA12 by using the primers 5′ CGG GAT CCG GTG TGA CAA TCA GTA TGA C 3′ and 5′ CGG AAT TCG CGA CAT TTA TGT GGA TAC AC 3′. The DNA fragment was inserted into the shuttle vector pBT1 (17), resulting in pSK7. Then theermB cassette of pEC1 (1) was excised byXbaI-HindIII digestion, treated with the Klenow fragment of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase, and ligated with EcoRV-digested pSK7, resulting in plasmid pSK8. Following passage through the restriction-negative strain S. aureus RN4220, pSK8 was reisolated and transformed into S. aureus MA12 by electroporation (19). Replacement of the chromosomal S. aureus MA12 sigB wild-type gene was achieved by double-crossover integration of thesigB::ermB insert of pSK8 following a temperature shift to the nonpermissive temperature of the shuttle vector (42°C). Erythromycin-resistant and chloramphenicol-sensitive colonies were isolated, and thesigB::ermB integrations were confirmed by Southern hybridization, PCR, and nucleotide sequencing (data not shown). From these experiments, thesigB::ermB insertion mutant S. aureus MA12.2 was selected for further analysis. To restore the ς^B function, the S. aureus MA12.2sigB mutant strain was complemented with plasmid pSK9. Plasmid pSK9 was constructed by inserting the sigB PCR fragment into the expression shuttle vector pHPS9 (8). Prior to transformation into S. aureus MA12.2, the vector was transformed into the restriction-negative cloning host S. aureus RN4220. The plasmid was reisolated and transferred intoS. aureus MA12.2, resulting in the complemented strainS. aureus MA12.2-1(pSK9).

Analysis of the ς^B function.Inactivation of thesigB gene in S. aureus MA12.2 and restoration of its function in the complemented strain S. aureusMA12.2-1(pSK9) was investigated by Northern analysis of theasp23-specific gene expression. asp23 encodes an alkaline shock protein, and the gene was shown to be preceded by a ς^B-dependent promoter (7, 11). Recent studies have shown that asp23 transcription is absent in S. aureus sigB mutants. It has therefore been concluded thatasp23 transcription reliably reflects the activity of the ς^B factor (7, 11, 16).

The Northern hybridization experiments revealed a strongasp23-specific signal in both the wild-type and the complemented strains. In contrast, no asp23-specific transcription was detected in the mutant strain S. aureusMA12.2 (data not shown). Furthermore, as expected for a ς^B-negative strain (2, 11), and in contrast to both the wild-type and complemented strains, the mutant strain had lost its yellow pigmentation and showed enhanced hemolysis on blood agar plates (data not shown). Taken together, these data indicate thatS. aureus MA12.2 is a sigB mutant and that thesigB mutation is restored in the complemented strainS. aureus MA12.2-1(pSK9).

Effect of the sigB mutation on biofilm production andica expression.Quantitative biofilm measurement was done in a microtiter assay as described previously (3, 22). Bacteria were grown overnight in 96-well, flat-bottomed tissue culture plates (Greiner, Nürtingen, Germany) at 37°C using either tryptic soy broth (TSB) (Difco, BBL, Detroit, Mich.) or TSB supplemented with 3% sodium chloride as growth medium. Based upon the optical densities (OD) of the biofilms, the strains were classified as nonadherent strains (OD ≤ 0.120), weak biofilm producers (0.120 < OD ≤ 0.240), or strongly adherent strains (OD > 0.240) according to the scheme introduced by Christensen et al. (3). As shown in Fig. 1, the biofilm formation of S. aureus MA12 was weak when the strain was grown in TSB, but it could be significantly stimulated under osmotic stress conditions (that is, TSB containing 3% sodium chloride). In contrast, the S. aureus MA12.2 sigBinsertion mutant failed to produce any detectable biofilm, irrespective of whether it was grown in TSB alone or in TSB containing 3% sodium chloride. In the case of S. aureus MA12.2(pSK9), in which the inactivated chromosomal copy of sigB was complemented by an expression plasmid carrying sigB, both basal and the osmotic stress-stimulated biofilm formation were restored.

• Open in new tab
• Download powerpoint

Fig. 1.

Biofilm formation on polystyrene tissue culture plates of the wild-type strain (S. aureus MA12), thesigB::ermB insertion mutant (S. aureus MA12.2), the complemented strain [S. aureusMA12.2-1(pSK9)], the cloning host S. aureus RN4220,S. aureus RN4220(pSK9), and S. aureusRN4220(pCN27) carrying the icaADBC operon of S. epidermidis on plasmid pCN27 (9), and S. carnosus TM300(pCN27) (9) after growth in unsupplemented TSB and TSB supplemented with 3% sodium chloride, respectively. A, S. epidermidis RP62A (positive control); and B, S. carnosus TM300 (negative control).

Next, we examined the effect of the sigB inactivation on the transcription of the ica gene cluster by Northern blotting experiments. To this end, RNA was isolated from mid-log cultures of the wild-type strain, the sigB mutant, and the complemented strain, which were grown in TSB containing 3% sodium chloride. Hybridization with a³²P-radiolabeled icaA-specific gene probe revealed a strong signal in the S. aureus MA12 wild-type strain (Fig. 2, lane 1). In contrast,ica transcription was drastically diminished in thesigB mutant (Fig. 2, lane 2) and restored in the complemented strain S. aureus MA12.2SK(pSK9) (Fig. 2, lane 3). These data are consistent with the observed differences in biofilm production under high-salt conditions between the wild-type and mutant strains and again support the conclusion that sigB is involved in the control of biofilm formation in S. aureusMA12.

• Open in new tab
• Download powerpoint

Fig. 2.

Northern blot analysis of ica transcription in the S. aureus MA12 wild-type strain (lane 1), thesigB::ermB insertion mutant S. aureus MA12.2 (lane 2), and the complemented strain S. aureus MA12.2-1(pSK9) (lane 3) after growth in TSB supplemented with 3% sodium chloride.

We then extended the study to another S. aureus strain, RN4220. S. aureus RN4220 is a restriction-negative strain that is commonly used as a cloning host for plasmids prior to their transformation into the staphylococcal strain of interest (10). S. aureus RN4220 had been derived fromS. aureus 8325, which was described recently as a spontaneous sigB-negative mutant with an 11-bp deletion in the rsbU regulatory gene (11, 20). Normally,S. aureus RN4220 does not produce biofilms, under either low-salt or high-salt conditions (Fig. 1). We found that, when transformed with plasmid pSK9, this strain formed biofilms and, moreover, that the biofilm production was induced under high-salt conditions. These results led us to propose that the biofilm-negative phenotype of S. aureus RN4220 is caused by the absence of ς^B. Obviously, this conclusion appears to contradict previous results which demonstrated that S. aureus RN4220 exhibits a biofilm-positive phenotype when the icaADBC genes are provided on a plasmid (5, 14). Therefore, we have done an additional set of experiments. We have transformed plasmid pCN27 (9), which carries the entireica operon of Staphylococcus epidermidis, intoS. aureus RN4220. Consistent with previous data (14), the strain formed a biofilm when grown in TSB (Fig.1). However, in obvious contrast to the pSK9 complementation experiments described above, no induction of biofilm production was observed under osmotic stress conditions. Finally, we found that propagation of pCN27 in Staphylococcus carnosus TM300 (9) increased the biofilm production of this strain under high-salt conditions. The combined data led us to hypothesize that the biofilm-forming phenotype of S. aureus RN4220(pCN27) may result from a basal, vector-driven ica expression, which is enhanced by the copy effect of the plasmid. The absence of biofilm induction, however, suggests that ς^B is required for the activation of biofilm formation in response to osmotic stress.

Conclusions.In this study, we provide evidence that the biofilm-forming phenotype observed in a mucosal isolate ofS. aureus can be induced by changing environmental conditions (in this case, osmotic stress). The results are consistent with our recent data obtained for S. epidermidis (S. Rachid and W. Ziebuhr, unpublished data), which demonstrated that the expression of the biofilm-mediating ica operon is enhanced by high osmolarity, high temperature, and subinhibitory concentrations of certain antibiotics. In contrast to S. epidermidis, allS. aureus strains analyzed so far carry the icagene cluster, but only a few spontaneously express biofilms in vitro (5). It is thus tempting to speculate that, in these biofilm-negative strains, the ica expression may be tightly controlled. The data presented in this study strongly support the idea that this suppression might be overcome by activation of ς^B in response to external stress. Another explanation for the biofilm-negative phenotype in the majority of the S. aureus strains would be the presence of mutations in thesigB gene itself or in its adjacent rsbU,rsbV, and rsbW regulatory genes (11, 20). It is also conceivable that S. aureus biofilm production may be influenced by mechanisms that have been shown to be used by S. epidermidis in the control of the icaexpression (e.g., phase variation and gene rearrangements) (21-23). All these hypotheses still need careful experimental evaluation. It should also be noted that, in this study, we have characterized only the mucosal isolate S. aureus MA12 in detail. Even though we have obtained conclusive evidence for the critical involvement of the ς^B factor in biofilm formation in this isolate, the actual role of ς^Bin ica expression remains to be determined. The nucleotide sequence immediately upstream of the ica operon does not resemble any of the known ς^B-dependent promoter structures, suggesting an indirect activation of the icaexpression by additional unknown regulatory factors. This idea is also supported by the identification of S. aureus strains which express the sigB gene but, nevertheless, are biofilm negative (Rachid and Ziebuhr, unpublished). To answer the question of whether ς^B is directly or indirectly involved in S. aureus ica expression, more experimental work, including primer extension analyses under different growth conditions, is needed. Finally, a broad range of S. aureus strains has to be analyzed to identify possible variations in biofilm regulation among different strains.